Top 10 Midfielders

Started by almonds, April 30, 2018, 05:30:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

SilverLion

Gaff anyone?

92, 103, 123, 103, 128, 103, 107, 102

Gavdroid

Quote from: SilverLion on May 13, 2018, 11:20:33 AM
Gaff anyone?

92, 103, 123, 103, 128, 103, 107, 102

Very consistent, but those scores don't show a high enough ceiling for mine. Need those 140+ scores occasionally to be a top mid

almonds

Edward curnow anyone? Lowkey killing it all season

SilverLion

Quote from: Gavdroid on May 13, 2018, 11:28:34 AM
Quote from: SilverLion on May 13, 2018, 11:20:33 AM
Gaff anyone?

92, 103, 123, 103, 128, 103, 107, 102

Very consistent, but those scores don't show a high enough ceiling for mine. Need those 140+ scores occasionally to be a top mid
Probably fair enough, but Oliver didn't start going 140s last year until the second half IIRC.

Quote from: almonds on May 13, 2018, 11:29:43 AM
Edward curnow anyone? Lowkey killing it all season
Not lowkey, just for some reason people don't pick him in SC. More of a RDT/AF player. Though looking a good pick this year in SC too.

Mongoose528

Dusty having a real stinker today, Jacobs has done a great job so far.

Gigantor

Quote from: Mongoose528 on May 13, 2018, 02:51:02 PM
Dusty having a real stinker today, Jacobs has done a great job so far.

If he doesn't hit 100 next week will drop below 500k  :o

Brikett

What are our thoughts on Crouch?

Had him pencilled in for this or next week,

Averaging 105 or so without the injury with a low score on the weekend of 92.

Not bad by any stretch for a guy priced 530k.

Should I be waiting out for someone better?

Could really use the extra 120k or so that I'd be using for Jack Mac elsewhere.




iZander

Quote from: Brikett on May 14, 2018, 02:15:45 PM
What are our thoughts on Crouch?

Had him pencilled in for this or next week,

Averaging 105 or so without the injury with a low score on the weekend of 92.

Not bad by any stretch for a guy priced 530k.

Should I be waiting out for someone better?

Could really use the extra 120k or so that I'd be using for Jack Mac elsewhere.

Last year, every single week i was like "na paying up for docherty is stupid, i could use that cash elsewhere and theres no way he keeps it up"
He ruined my year
Macrae could do that to you :D


sammy123

What are people doing with conigs. I know he been quiet past 2 games not worried at all but will people use hin as bench cover or luxary trade him at the end of the yr?

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: sammy123 on May 14, 2018, 11:10:30 PM
What are people doing with conigs. I know he been quiet past 2 games not worried at all but will people use hin as bench cover or luxary trade him at the end of the yr?

He scored 100 on the weekend so I'd hardly call that quiet

Jacobs tag this week, let's hope it goes to Shiel

As for Conigs I plan on him being my M8 for sure. If I get the luxury, then I'll look to get a 9th mid but he is certainly good enough for M8 this year based on the options available.

Adamant

Quote from: sammy123 on May 14, 2018, 11:10:30 PM
What are people doing with conigs. I know he been quiet past 2 games not worried at all but will people use hin as bench cover or luxary trade him at the end of the yr?

I 'downgraded' him to Zorko last week as a luxury trade. Personally I think he overperformed over the first 5 weeks and don't see him being in the top 10 midfielders from this point onwards. Still a handy M8 as he should be good for 90-110 most weeks but with a career high score of 139 I wouldn't be expecting any monsters.

sammy123

Quote from: Adamant on May 14, 2018, 11:58:21 PM
Quote from: sammy123 on May 14, 2018, 11:10:30 PM
What are people doing with conigs. I know he been quiet past 2 games not worried at all but will people use hin as bench cover or luxary trade him at the end of the yr?

I 'downgraded' him to Zorko last week as a luxury trade. Personally I think he overperformed over the first 5 weeks and don't see him being in the top 10 midfielders from this point onwards. Still a handy M8 as he should be good for 90-110 most weeks but with a career high score of 139 I wouldn't be expecting any monsters.

Thanks. I was thinking hold till his bye and assess from there could become danger if he goes back to scoring 110 every week

Marstar

Quote from: sammy123 on May 14, 2018, 11:10:30 PM
What are people doing with conigs. I know he been quiet past 2 games not worried at all but will people use hin as bench cover or luxary trade him at the end of the yr?

He's hasn't put a foot wrong for a $450k midprice Mid.  He's matching his 2016 pre-injury average and currently the 12th best (non/fwd) Mid in the comp. Trading him out for some1 who could potentially score an extra 3 ppg would be insane.

He is also owned by 40% of all SCs.  So unless every1 starts letting him for and actual reason ... you'd have to perform some sort of miracle trade to gain any advantage getting rid or moving him to M9.


sammy123

Quote from: Marstar on May 15, 2018, 01:23:32 AM
Quote from: sammy123 on May 14, 2018, 11:10:30 PM
What are people doing with conigs. I know he been quiet past 2 games not worried at all but will people use hin as bench cover or luxary trade him at the end of the yr?

He's hasn't put a foot wrong for a $450k midprice Mid.  He's matching his 2016 pre-injury average and currently the 12th best (non/fwd) Mid in the comp. Trading him out for some1 who could potentially score an extra 3 ppg would be insane.

He is also owned by 40% of all SCs.  So unless every1 starts letting him for and actual reason ... you'd have to perform some sort of miracle trade to gain any advantage getting rid or moving him to M9.

When i started him i never planned to keep him but he has been great im just keeping my options open in case

ubeaut

Top 10 by average right now

Macrae 135
Fyfe 123
Titch 119
Oliver 116
Cripps 116
Danger 115
Curnow 115
Treloar 113
Ablett 112
Selwood 109

Dusty,Cogs,Cotchin,Gaff tied at no.11 on 107.