Round 5 Trades

[Holz]

Do you see Grundy continuing a 130+ average for the season?

Why couldn't he have a season like Goldstein in 2015 when he averaged 128?

because your backing him in to have an all time great season.

Dean Cox's best season was a 122
Sandi put up a 114

he certainly could have a 128 season but its extremely unlikely. Im quite confident he will go sub 115 from here on out.

[GoSaints3]

Bonner to Acres/Silicy via DPP
Hibberd to Oliver
Kelly to Titch
Venables to Guelfi

Not sure which of these to go? Leaning towards acres/Silicy so I can have only 1 rookie on the field in the fwd line.
Thoughts?

The first one's a great trade if it allows you to have only 1 forward.

Would you guys pick acres or Sicily?
I like acres consistency with all 90+ even through floggings and I may have some bias haha. Feel like silicy has a higher ceiling but also the chance to have some poor scores

[MontyJnr]

Definitely a chance. Paying top dollar now though, if he goes back to the pack it'd be a waste of a trade. If he does continue, you'd be 20-30 points better off a week.

All gets back to the risk/reward factor, which is what SuperCoach is all about ;)

Yeah agree with all that, I'm happy to take a risk before upgrade season starts next week :)

[tkringle]

Armitage to Oliver my only trade at this time.

Itching to move on Goldy or Hibberd but moves like that normally bite me in the arse..

[Samsturmfels]

Thoughts on going Hibberd to Sicily for cash? or should i just get yeo in?

[Torpedo10]

In his last 5 Friday Night games, JPK hasn't gone below 32 disposals  :-X

Mmk, still going JPK -> Oliver I think. Unless someone can convince me of Conigs or Zerrett?

[whynot102]

Hibberd to Yeo worthy of a trade

[shaker]

In his last 5 Friday Night games, JPK hasn't gone below 32 disposals  :-X

Mmk, still going JPK -> Oliver I think. Unless someone can convince me of Conigs or Zerrett?

JPK is due for a big one maybe tonight ? but Oliver is good so is Coniglio but Merrett just has not shown enough so far to be top 8 this year but that is just my opinion  ;)

[AaronKirk]

Venables to Mirra - moving Garlett forward to cover Fritsch is out - Finlayson to the mids and on field for Holman.

Armitage to Parker who looks IMO to be the Swans best mid this year.

[Bully]

Hibberd to Yeo worthy of a trade

Yep.

[tkringle]

Armitage - Oliver (locked)
Hibberd-Yeo (undecided)

[tommy10]

Armitage - Oliver (locked)
Hibberd-Yeo (undecided)

Sounds like good trades to me

[crowls]

I'm not a happy camper. Somewhat forced into trades I normally wouldn't do.
With ZGL not named, Venables injured and Ryan injured I'll cop a doughnut without a trade and that's not an option on the back of two bad weeks. I've dropped from 6k to 36k in the rankings and won only 2 of 20 league games.

Ryan to Walters (cannot afford Heeney or McLean)
Bonner to Mirra (early)

Hope it works out.

I hear ya NZ. Started with Murphy, Ryan, Venables, ZGL, Mcrouch, Hibberd & Josh Kelly. My ranking stinks & I am down to 24 trades already.

Reasonable trades NZ.     Best options available.   

[billnats]

Billings can GAGF as well

Decision to make with him... wondering whether I just downgrade him for a Guelfi or English to cash generate.

Then again, I also have Venables and Langdon out. As well as Fritsch who may be out

[no eye deer]

Billings can GAGF as well

Decision to make with him... wondering whether I just downgrade him for a Guelfi or English to cash generate.

Then again, I also have Venables and Langdon out. As well as Fritsch who may be out

Definitely wouldn’t be doing that, still a potential donut, not to mention your downgrades meh score on the field.