Mitch Crowden vs Ed Richards vs Andrew Brayshaw

[david17]

At first was gonna trade out Ryan and Brayshaw for Crowden and Richards to get some money in the bank but after Stephenson score tonight im keeping Ryan for the loophole now trying to decide if i should trade Brayshaw or hold for another week

[quinny88]

I don't feel like either trade is necessary with guys like Mira and Coffield coming in. Brayshaw just needs 1 decent game to get going. If you feel the need to do 1 I'd prefer Richards as I think he should have good JS and a bit better scoring potential than Crowden

[david17]

Reckon i will just hold Brayshaw for another week  trades are like gold and im sure there will be plenty of more rookies to look at

[Judd Magic]

Reckon i will just hold Brayshaw for another week  trades are like gold and im sure there will be plenty of more rookies to look at

[GCSkiwi]

With Kelly out I have to play one of Brayshaw or Banfield to cover him. Alternately, I could trade Barry, move Finlayson into kids to cover Kelly, and trade in Richards. Already done Ryan to Henry. Worth it?

Otherwise, who to field of Brayshaw and Banfield, I’m thinking Banfield...

[GoSaints3]

With Kelly out I have to play one of Brayshaw or Banfield to cover him. Alternately, I could trade Barry, move Finlayson into kids to cover Kelly, and trade in Richards. Already done Ryan to Henry. Worth it?

Otherwise, who to field of Brayshaw and Banfield, I’m thinking Banfield...

We are in the exact same situation, already done the Ryan to Henry trade too.
I was thinking if I grab Richards then it will allow me to place Murray on the field in defence, no point a good sitting on my bench. However atm I have just fielded Banfield over Brayshaw.

[david17]

Yeah i cant decide who to start Brayshaw v Banfield v LDU