Hogan??

Started by Jrads11, April 09, 2018, 11:26:04 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Jrads11

Now here me out, as a demon supporter ive noticed his role had completely changed, hes pushing way up the groud and playing stunts through the midfield plus hes the main man in attack kicking goals, collecting 20+ disposals and plenty of marks, went large over 100 twice already thinking going lobb to Hogan change my mind

Samm79

Small sample size, but he’s a gun. Lambert to him or Heeney this week

crowls

Hogan on the watch list.  Looks to be playing a more like Buddy role with a mix of Fyfe.
At his price if the role stays and his form holds he is likely to remain around the 100+ mark.   
Just not sure I want to risk it yet.

quinny88

Wouldn't be rushing him in but he's worth keepin an eye on

SilverLion

Key forward. Had 3 good games in a row.

Could easily play 3 bad games next.

Not saying he's not an option, but reminds me very much of T. Lynch last year.

quinny88

Quote from: SilverLion on April 09, 2018, 11:10:32 PM
Key forward. Had 3 good games in a row.

Could easily play 3 bad games next.

Not saying he's not an option, but reminds me very much of T. Lynch last year.

Has been playing in the midfield a lot though which could help his consistency. Would like to reasses after about 6 weeks though and see how he's going

brodiejay

Quote from: quinny88 on April 10, 2018, 12:00:16 AM
Quote from: SilverLion on April 09, 2018, 11:10:32 PM
Key forward. Had 3 good games in a row.

Could easily play 3 bad games next.

Not saying he's not an option, but reminds me very much of T. Lynch last year.

Has been playing in the midfield a lot though which could help his consistency. Would like to reasses after about 6 weeks though and see how he's going

I'm bringing him in this week for that exact reason. His time pushing up the ground has looked good and will help him score consistently when he's not impacting with goals. He'll still be taking marks and could notch some inside 50s delivering to Petracca, Gawn when he pushes forward, and their capable small forwards.

I'm taking a punt on him.

Ringo

Just look at who is opposition has been over the last 2 rounds Lions and Kangas - Was at the Gabba and a lot of his points would have been from marks with Andrews standing off him will not always have that luxury. Struggled is first round against Cats.

Still on watch list and if he can ton up against hawks, Tigers and Bombers in next 3 games then will be a strong possibility.

ants

Quote from: Ringo on April 10, 2018, 05:29:41 PM
Just look at who is opposition has been over the last 2 rounds Lions and Kangas - Was at the Gabba and a lot of his points would have been from marks with Andrews standing off him will not always have that luxury. Struggled is first round against Cats.

Still on watch list and if he can ton up against hawks, Tigers and Bombers in next 3 games then will be a strong possibility.
the problem with that ideology is he will be out of reach price wise by then and not worth the gamble! its now or never . im strongly considering him at that price. wish i started him

hawkers65

Im stuck with Lobb, and i just think he has to go now Dawson has a chance to hold the #1 ruck. The thing is i dont have a lot of cash. So my forward options are:

Hogan
Acres (Already have Billings...)
Petracca

Neither of those stand out to me other than Hogans potential if he stays in the guts. The other option is swing sicily forward and grab a Shaw, Ryan type.

None of those names are great tbh, but from them Hogan and Ryan stick out to me, thoughts?

Bully

Quote from: hawkers65 on April 12, 2018, 09:05:44 PM
Im stuck with Lobb, and i just think he has to go now Dawson has a chance to hold the #1 ruck. The thing is i dont have a lot of cash. So my forward options are:

Hogan
Acres (Already have Billings...)
Petracca

Neither of those stand out to me other than Hogans potential if he stays in the guts. The other option is swing sicily forward and grab a Shaw, Ryan type.

None of those names are great tbh, but from them Hogan and Ryan stick out to me, thoughts?

I'd grab Petracca, at least you have a swingman if his form drops.

Jrads11

Quote from: hawkers65 on April 12, 2018, 09:05:44 PM
Im stuck with Lobb, and i just think he has to go now Dawson has a chance to hold the #1 ruck. The thing is i dont have a lot of cash. So my forward options are:

Hogan
Acres (Already have Billings...)
Petracca

Neither of those stand out to me other than Hogans potential if he stays in the guts. The other option is swing sicily forward and grab a Shaw, Ryan type.

None of those names are great tbh, but from them Hogan and Ryan stick out to me, thoughts?

Lobb to Hogan lock

Weideman is named for dees and will be playing the tall key forward, already had this trade done but seeing that made it a super lock for me

hawkers65

Quote from: Jrads11 on April 12, 2018, 09:24:41 PM
Quote from: hawkers65 on April 12, 2018, 09:05:44 PM
Im stuck with Lobb, and i just think he has to go now Dawson has a chance to hold the #1 ruck. The thing is i dont have a lot of cash. So my forward options are:

Hogan
Acres (Already have Billings...)
Petracca

Neither of those stand out to me other than Hogans potential if he stays in the guts. The other option is swing sicily forward and grab a Shaw, Ryan type.

None of those names are great tbh, but from them Hogan and Ryan stick out to me, thoughts?

Lobb to Hogan lock

Weideman is named for dees and will be playing the tall key forward, already had this trade done but seeing that made it a super lock for me

what makes you so confident? Word was hes playing more in the guts this year but i just got the heat map up, first 2 games he was up at 80% in the forward half, and most of that deep. Round 3 he was 65% forward, which is much kinder and got posies on the boundary all the way up to half back. But is showing that for one game enough? I dont think so

Big Mac

Quote from: Jrads11 on April 12, 2018, 09:24:41 PM
Quote from: hawkers65 on April 12, 2018, 09:05:44 PM
Im stuck with Lobb, and i just think he has to go now Dawson has a chance to hold the #1 ruck. The thing is i dont have a lot of cash. So my forward options are:

Hogan
Acres (Already have Billings...)
Petracca

Neither of those stand out to me other than Hogans potential if he stays in the guts. The other option is swing sicily forward and grab a Shaw, Ryan type.

None of those names are great tbh, but from them Hogan and Ryan stick out to me, thoughts?

Lobb to Hogan lock

Weideman is named for dees and will be playing the tall key forward, already had this trade done but seeing that made it a super lock for me

Weid only on the extended bench though, and with only Tyson coming out it is more likely a mid will replace him

RoughRed

So what you y'all think now?
Averaging 110
BE 66
Priced at 485k
79 VS Geelong
Big scores V Brisbane (145)  and North (125)
94 against Hawthorn
Serious keeper??
Or downhill skier??