Round 4 Trades

[RoughRed]

Lobb to Savage or Petracca or McClean?

McLean. Defence more plentiful in rookies, less important to bring in a prem.

this

+1

[Southstorm]

Thinking:

Ryan -> Richards via Keefe DPP
Garlett to Mids
Zerrett -> McLean

Thoughts?

[batt]

If Lobb misses this week he is 220% gone and if he doesn't he's 90% gone.

I selfishly just want to get a full team on park.

R1: Danger & Kreuz
R2: Kreuz (English) & Crouch
R3: Beams (Brayshaw), Lobb & Sicily

Trying to talk myself out of Luke Ryan but can't do it.

[Ricochet]

So we're 100% sold on McLean? I haven't seen enough of the Bullies games

[Nige]

So we're 100% sold on McLean? I haven't seen enough of the Bullies games

91, 125 and 115 so far. Playing mostly through the midfield but is capable forward and part of the rotation. Not afraid to get the hardball and always in the contest. I think he was a pretty reliable pick from the start.

[Nige]

So after thinking about it all week, I've come up with three trades I wanna do.

Brayshaw -> Crowden
Gaz -> Lyons
Lobb -> Hogan

Obviously can't make three.

Brayshaw -> Crowden will generate cash and Brayshaw's BE is like 33 so that's a given.

Hard to choose between the other two.

I'm thinking that with Lobb a chance of missing and me already hoarding ZGL, it'd mean I wouldn't have forward cover if Lobb missed and his scores +injury concern are more of an issue.

I can cover Gaz for a week and then get JL in for him because his BE is 20 and even though he'll rise a bit, I'll still be able to afford it.

Still not too sure though.

[Hazza09]

Very undecided in which way to go this week. With limited funds i have come up with these 2 trade options.
Lobb is definitely gone regardless if he plays or not, so this is how it looks.

1. Brayshaw - Crowden (Hold Ryan & play Venables as F6) to Lobb - Mclean
2. Ryan - Henry (Wait for Higgins to trade with Brayshaw & play Henry as F6) to Lobb - Petracca

Ideally i would rather Mclean but with Option 2 i only have 475k to play with...nobody really standing out other than Petracca.

Thoughts?

[batt]

So after thinking about it all week, I've come up with three trades I wanna do.

Brayshaw -> Crowden
Gaz -> Lyons
Lobb -> Hogan

Obviously can't make three.

Brayshaw -> Crowden will generate cash and Brayshaw's BE is like 33 so that's a given.

Hard to choose between the other two.

I'm thinking that with Lobb a chance of missing and me already hoarding ZGL, it'd mean I wouldn't have forward cover if Lobb missed and his scores +injury concern are more of an issue.

I can cover Gaz for a week and then get JL in for him because his BE is 20 and even though he'll rise a bit, I'll still be able to afford it.

Still not too sure though.

Lobb and Gaz are much bigger problems than Brayshaw.  There's still a very good chance he makes good $$, just as a slower burner early.

Lyons is a brave pick, particularly with the R10 bye.  But fortune favours the brave.  I think you should only take one of Lyons and Hogan though, as it's very unlikely they both end up as top 8/6 picks in their positions.

[jbjimmyjb]

Need some advice, I can do 2 of these 3 options:
1. Bont -> Gibbs/Fyfe (don't ask me why I chose to start Neale over Fyfe  :-[ )
2. Ryan -> Henry/Crowden
3. Billings -> Mclean

Thinking option 2 is a must, seeing as Ryan is out for almost 3 months. But very scared that Bont/Billings are going to pull out another 60 for me, facing Sydney and Geelong (in Geelong).
Thanks to Beverage, Bontempelli is getting no midfield time, and with Sydney's defence being both very tall and strong, there's a worry he'll see none of it playing as a tall forward. However his BE is only 109, which he's probably got about 40% chance of reaching. Compare that to Billings' BE of 160, and it looks much more appealing.

Currently leaning towards options 1&2, and giving billings one more chance against a weakish Geelong defence. There's also the possibility of him getting more midfield time (that we were promised pre-season) as obviously St Kilda's current plans aren't working.

[Nige]

So after thinking about it all week, I've come up with three trades I wanna do.

Brayshaw -> Crowden
Gaz -> Lyons
Lobb -> Hogan

Obviously can't make three.

Brayshaw -> Crowden will generate cash and Brayshaw's BE is like 33 so that's a given.

Hard to choose between the other two.

I'm thinking that with Lobb a chance of missing and me already hoarding ZGL, it'd mean I wouldn't have forward cover if Lobb missed and his scores +injury concern are more of an issue.

I can cover Gaz for a week and then get JL in for him because his BE is 20 and even though he'll rise a bit, I'll still be able to afford it.

Still not too sure though.

Lobb and Gaz are much bigger problems than Brayshaw.  There's still a very good chance he makes good $$, just as a slower burner early.

Lyons is a brave pick, particularly with the R10 bye.  But fortune favours the brave.  I think you should only take one of Lyons and Hogan though, as it's very unlikely they both end up as top 8/6 picks in their positions.

I think I've made up my mind to get both Lyons and Hogan for Gaz and Lobb respectively. Let Brayshaw hopefully get to his BE and rise a little and then I can assess from there. Could potentially do Brayshaw -> Higgins and pass on Crowden this week.

[Bully]

Need some advice, I can do 2 of these 3 options:
1. Bont -> Gibbs/Fyfe (don't ask me why I chose to start Neale over Fyfe  :-[ )
2. Ryan -> Henry/Crowden
3. Billings -> Mclean

Thinking option 2 is a must, seeing as Ryan is out for almost 3 months. But very scared that Bont/Billings are going to pull out another 60 for me, facing Sydney and Geelong (in Geelong).
Thanks to Beverage, Bontempelli is getting no midfield time, and with Sydney's defence being both very tall and strong, there's a worry he'll see none of it playing as a tall forward. However his BE is only 109, which he's probably got about 40% chance of reaching. Compare that to Billings' BE of 160, and it looks much more appealing.

Currently leaning towards options 1&2, and giving billings one more chance against a weakish Geelong defence. There's also the possibility of him getting more midfield time (that we were promised pre-season) as obviously St Kilda's current plans aren't working.

Options 1 & 2, need to give Billings some time.

[_wato]

Three trade ideas for me, number 1 is definitely a goer.

1. Ryan > Richards via Sicily DPP.
2. GAJ > Dangerfield
3. Lobb > Heeney/RGray

Option 2 means I field Lobb + Danger, Option 3 means I field Holman + Heeney/RGray and move on Ablett next week.

[iZander]

Three trade ideas for me, number 1 is definitely a goer.

1. Ryan > Richards via Sicily DPP.
2. GAJ > Dangerfield
3. Lobb > Heeney/RGray

Option 2 means I field Lobb + Danger, Option 3 means I field Holman + Heeney/RGray and move on Ablett next week.

Option 3 imo

[ubeaut]

Three trade ideas for me, number 1 is definitely a goer.

1. Ryan > Richards via Sicily DPP.
2. GAJ > Dangerfield
3. Lobb > Heeney/RGray

Option 2 means I field Lobb + Danger, Option 3 means I field Holman + Heeney/RGray and move on Ablett next week.

Option 3. With Heeney. Easy decision if Lobb doesn't play which is looking likely. GAJs price won't change, Danger should drop a bit so save some dollars too.
Wish my trade options were as clear cut as this!

[Bully]

Three trade ideas for me, number 1 is definitely a goer.

1. Ryan > Richards via Sicily DPP.
2. GAJ > Dangerfield
3. Lobb > Heeney/RGray

Option 2 means I field Lobb + Danger, Option 3 means I field Holman + Heeney/RGray and move on Ablett next week.

Would pick Heeney ahead of Gray, reckon you'll get Gray cheap down the track.