Hibberd

[RaisyDaisy]

Which defender do we go?
- Simpson
- Yeo
- Shaw
- Sicily

Not Yeo

[Bully]

Will have a BE of around 170.....

Goneski, will be my first trade next week.

Which defender do we go?
- Simpson
- Yeo
- Shaw
- Sicily

Shaw for me.

[PowerBug]

Do I trade Hibberd knowing his losing $$$ or bring in English knowing he will make it. Anything over 80 points again tomorrow and English may make the decision for me.

Why not get both?

M. Crouch

2 options, grab him now presuming you have trades this week. Or hold Crouch for a week.

Or trade Crouch to English and cop the points hit for a week?

[iZander]

Which defender do we go?
- Simpson
- Yeo
- Shaw
- Sicily

Not Yeo

Simmo, no doubt

[quinny88]

It's Simmo vs Shaw for me. Gonna be a hard call that I ponder all week

[tommy10]

It's Simmo vs Shaw for me. Gonna be a hard call that I ponder all week

Shaw looking very tempting and save extra $$

[sammy123]

Still going by my dont trade a premmo rule

[tkringle]

Out for Shaw..

[kilbluff1985]

ppl trading him are chasing points they can't get

[Bully]

ppl trading him are chasing points they can't get

Shaw enables other trades to be made before the price rises. A bit different to rage trading.

[enzedder]

ppl trading him are chasing points they can't get

Possibly.
I’m considering this trade for next week based on Shaw scoring well in two games and Hibberd scoring low in two games.
Premo for Premo trades are usually a waste and solid advice is to conserve the trade and not go sideways.
However Shaw is doing well and looking like he is back to playing the role he used to with Wilson and co gone.
I haven’t seen Hibberd play but his scoring is a worry as is the reading that he is taking fewer kick ins.
I have what appears a solid team and Hibberd to Shaw could be the best trade I could make next week.
There’s a bit of cash to add to the coffers too.

[Jalapeno]

ppl trading him are chasing points they can't get

This ^^^

Hibberd, in my opinion will be a top 4 defender so you need to hold. You all picked him for a reason, so back your reason and hold

[SilverLion]

ppl trading him are chasing points they can't get

This ^^^

Hibberd, in my opinion will be a top 4 defender so you need to hold. You all picked him for a reason, so back your reason and hold

Agreed.

You guys are crazy for jumping off so quick. Sure he's been a bit underwhelming, but are you really going to burn a trade just because he's gunna lose some cash? Mind you, come mid-year, he'll probably have made the cash back up anyways.

[tkringle]

Will need another ~100K to get Danger in for Armitage in a couple of weeks. Hibberd to Shaw facilitates this

[no eye deer]

Will need another ~100K to get Danger in for Armitage in a couple of weeks. Hibberd to Shaw facilitates this

Exactly. Except I need the cash for Dusty. Not willing to wait for byes to get him. He’s a must have now, and if I have to sideways Hibberd to Shaw, so be it.