Coulda Woulda Didn't

Started by RaisyDaisy, March 31, 2018, 10:28:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

RaisyDaisy

Bit of fun :)

We all know it's only 2 weeks in so nothing to get worried about but what are the selections that have already cost you?

Bell over Bundy
Hibberd over Simpson
Arma and the cash over Conigs
Lobb over Devon

Crouch injured :(

Just list the ones you were genuinely 50/50 on and got wrong. I never considered Bonner so I don't count him in this, for example

Bully

This is what correction trades are for, no need to get flustered. Some trades I'm thinking about are -

Hibberd to Shaw (70k)
Armitage to Bundy (45k)

We now have the benefit of hindsight, just need to work out the best combo.

English I'm also keen on but will wait and see if he holds his place once Redpath is back. Definitely want Dusty but all my premos have delivered with the exception of Bont.


billnats

I went Crouch, Hibberd and Taylor as a POD.

Gibbs, Simpson and Buddy/Greene makes a lot more sense in hindsight

_wato

Went Beams/Bont/Sandi/Rioli/Byrne/Armo to save cash and shore up line(s) as lack of good scoring rookies.
Imagine Dusty/Titch/Goldy/Buddy/LMurphy/Fogarty instead. Flower me

Daicos.

Hibberd over Simpson is definitely my main regret.

Besides that I'm relatively happy with my team.

GoSaints3

Kelly over Oliver
Hibberd over Hurley
And taking Ryder at the start so I burnt a trade

brodiejay

I had Oliver in my mids, Taranto in my forwards and Heath Shaw in my backline all preseason then switched them out last minute for no reason really....

Brought in Alex Neal-Bullen and Michael Hibberd, who was never on my list, so no idea why I chose him in a rush!

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: GoSaints3 on April 01, 2018, 01:51:10 AM
Kelly over Oliver
Hibberd over Hurley
And taking Ryder at the start so I burnt a trade

Kelly over Oliver? If that's one of your big misses you're doing better than the rest of us!

kilbluff1985

i overthought things and went Rayner over Brayshaw, thought he had better JS and dpp


Dolan

Hibberd over Shaw. Had a feeling about Shaw but he has burned me in the past.

SilverLion

MCrouch over Oliver (Not anyone's fault really, injuries happen)
Taranto...

HoleMeal

Quote from: _wato on March 31, 2018, 11:30:06 PM
Went Beams/Bont/Sandi/Rioli/Byrne/Armo to save cash and shore up line(s) as lack of good scoring rookies.
Imagine Dusty/Titch/Goldy/Buddy/LMurphy/Fogarty instead. Flower me
I do have these...however, Bell instead of Bundy and Hibbo instead of Simmo are my regrets.

no eye deer

Hibberd over Shaw.
Bell over Bundy, then downgraded Bell to Garlett instead of sideways to Bundy yesterday. Now I’m stuck with two rookies on the field in the fwds. Stupid. :(

igotworms

Only regret now is the injury to Matt Crouch. He was on fire too, and will still be top 10 midfielder in averages by seasons end!
Haven't used any trades as yet, so Crouch to Oliver will be my first.
Rookies all good except possibly English if he performs and keeps his spot! Had Bonner and chose Smith over Lobb!  ;)
Oh, one other regret............. TAKING THE VC OF DUSTY MARTIN THURSDAY BEFORE THE BOUNCE!!! >:(
Never again Dusty, I promise!!

ubeaut

HIBBERD. Had a bad feeling ps but couldn't work out why. Thought Yeo and Hurley were too expensive and Simpson and Shaw slowing down.
Wrong.
BRAYSHAW joins LDU,Rayner and Dow as too expensive for a rookie. Thought he was going to be the highest scorer when Brodie wasn't named.

Wrong
Leaving BUNDY out due to poor JLT.
Not starting CONIGLIO or any GWS premo for thar matter.
Haven't got Geelong premos either although I've got cash for Danger.
Perhaps should have left MERRETT out for him.
Taking the VC off Dusty this week and Merrett getting injured last has meant a crappy start for me. Hopefully will improve!