Round 3 Trades

[billnats]

M. Crouch out for...
Oliver, Jelwood, Gibbs or Parker?

[SilverLion]

M. Crouch out for...
Oliver, Jelwood, Gibbs or Parker?

Oliver

[Jimmykidd]

M. Crouch out for...
Oliver, Jelwood, Gibbs or Parker?

love gibbs as a POD but oliver is the safe bet. gonna be top 10 mid for sure.

[Bones Bombers]

M. Crouch out for...
Oliver, Jelwood, Gibbs or Parker?

Oliver

[Jimmykidd]

zgl > venables worth it? i have all other rookies.

i plan to do menegola to billings and bont to oliver but i just realised ZGL is out  :'(

[SilverLion]

zgl > venables worth it? i have all other rookies.

i plan to do menegola to billings and bont to oliver but i just realised ZGL is out  :'(

Am really on the fence with trading ZGL out myself. I'm not sure whether the extra 100-150k you'll make from the trade is justifiable, given that ZGL will make cash when he comes back in.

Atm I'm leaning towards holding ZGL, but I really don't know.

[crowls]

who has better job security   L Fogarty Geelong or D Barry Port?
Have to downgrade Brayshaw to one of these for cash to upgrade to Dusty.

[Jimmykidd]

zgl > venables worth it? i have all other rookies.

i plan to do menegola to billings and bont to oliver but i just realised ZGL is out  :'(

Am really on the fence with trading ZGL out myself. I'm not sure whether the extra 100-150k you'll make from the trade is justifiable, given that ZGL will make cash when he comes back in.

Atm I'm leaning towards holding ZGL, but I really don't know.

yeah agreed. i think he will slot straight back in to the team and make nice cash for us. i just hope we don't need the extra bench cover in those 4 weeks. although i have garlett i can swing with stephenson so it should be ok. would rather fix poor premo selections myself.

[Jimmykidd]

who has better job security   L Fogarty Geelong or D Barry Port?
Have to downgrade Brayshaw to one of these for cash to upgrade to Dusty.

dont like any of those tbh! brayshaw great JS. if you're set on getting dusty this way then flip a coin for 1 of them. i rate them being the same JS and scoring wise.

[shaker]

who has better job security   L Fogarty Geelong or D Barry Port?
Have to downgrade Brayshaw to one of these for cash to upgrade to Dusty.

dont like any of those tbh! brayshaw great JS. if you're set on getting dusty this way then flip a coin for 1 of them. i rate them being the same JS and scoring wise.

Fogarty named on extended bench with S Selwood in Barry on the Bench wait till Sunday benches named and then go from there crowls

[Bones Bombers]

who has better job security   L Fogarty Geelong or D Barry Port?
Have to downgrade Brayshaw to one of these for cash to upgrade to Dusty.

dont like any of those tbh! brayshaw great JS. if you're set on getting dusty this way then flip a coin for 1 of them. i rate them being the same JS and scoring wise.

Fogarty named on extended bench with S Selwood in Barry on the Bench wait till Sunday benches named and then go from there crowls

I would say Barry has the better JS of those two. He laid 7 tackles last week. His first game was a low score but he had 22 disposals and seems to have fit in to the team well.

[Big Mac]

Thinking i'll lock in Byrne to Bonner but still need to bring in Ryan. Could trade out either Naughton, Langdon or even Dayne Beams

[justaverage]

T Bell on the chopping block for my 1 corrective trade
ZGL and Dogarty out is an inconvenience but I dont mind sitting then on the bench for now.
Not interested in English, Venables or Waterman, L Murphy is interesting
My thoughts are:
Naughton -> L Murphy (for $$$)
T Bell - > Taranto

[crowls]

who has better job security   L Fogarty Geelong or D Barry Port?
Have to downgrade Brayshaw to one of these for cash to upgrade to Dusty.

dont like any of those tbh! brayshaw great JS. if you're set on getting dusty this way then flip a coin for 1 of them. i rate them being the same JS and scoring wise.

Thanks Jimmy.      Will roll the dice on Barry,   

[oh_lol]

Coniglio or Taranto + 87k?