Round 3 Trades

[Thewizz71]

Points or cash?
Looking at Brayshaw to either Bonner or L Ryan via dpp.
Which is better long term?
Already doing Hibberd to Simmo this week.

[Mahogany]

Was going to go -

Dunkley to Ryan and

Naughton to Sicily

but obviously Siciliy stuffed that.

Is it work still doing the same nut getting Bonner in?

It basically means Keeping Dunkley or getting Bonner which would allow me to put Murray on the pine but have to field Ryan Fritsch or Garlett

[jumbo]

With No Sicily, Giles-Langdon and Greene in doubt this week.

I'm going Roberton to Bonner for hopefully similar scoring and cash grab and

Giles-Langdon to Zac Fisher (Alternative was L Ryan but was his 115 a fluke and his 38 more like it...)

Am I crazy to drop Roberton for this move?

Back line will be

Laird, Simpson, Sicily, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson (Murray, Naughton)

Fwd Line

Heeney, D Smith, Greene, Fisher, Stephenson, Fritsch (Venables, Keeffe)

[mattttwillll]

Do I move Sicily on or not? Unsure if he can improve his maturity on the field or not just yet.

Potentials from moving him on are

Sicily > Bonner
Keeffe/Naughton > Ryan

Giving me 190-240k in the bank

or Try to sideways him to Simpson which will require a second trade of Brayshaw for the money.

[jvalles69]

Do I move Sicily on or not? Unsure if he can improve his maturity on the field or not just yet.

Potentials from moving him on are

Sicily > Bonner
Keeffe/Naughton > Ryan

Giving me 190-240k in the bank

or Try to sideways him to Simpson which will require a second trade of Brayshaw for the money.

Both of those trades look like a waste to me.  You started with Sicily (like me and others) for a reason, Bonner will only be another guy you will prob have to trade out again, 2 game sample size does not = proven.  Assume Keeffe was there as a loophole option, otherwise not sure why you would've started with him? Ryan will see a nice price rise, but unsure if he can keep it up, looks lively all time but will have quiet games.

[TableKing]

Hey crew need some help please.

Mistake - Weitering and Brodie (GC)

Option 1 - Weitering to Bonner and Brodie to Fisher via DPP of McLean. $28k

Option 2 - Weitering to Bonner and Caddy to Fisher $230k

Kinda stuck in the thinking of it. I dont think il end wirh Caddy but Brodie isnt playing.

Help?

[Southstorm]

Hey crew need some help please.

Mistake - Weitering and Brodie (GC)

Option 1 - Weitering to Bonner and Brodie to Fisher via DPP of McLean. $28k

Option 2 - Weitering to Bonner and Caddy to Fisher $230k

Kinda stuck in the thinking of it. I dont think il end wirh Caddy but Brodie isnt playing.

Help?

What's the rest of your team looking like?

[TableKing]

Hey crew need some help please.

Mistake - Weitering and Brodie (GC)

Option 1 - Weitering to Bonner and Brodie to Fisher via DPP of McLean. $28k

Option 2 - Weitering to Bonner and Caddy to Fisher $230k

Kinda stuck in the thinking of it. I dont think il end wirh Caddy but Brodie isnt playing.

Help?

What's the rest of your team looking like?

I put faith in the rookie defenders this year. (Too much faith in Weitering)

Def - McGovern, Savage, Weirering, Finlayson, Murray, Doedee (Naughton and L Murphy)

Mid - Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Coniglio, T, Kelly, A Brayshaw and Holman (Brodie, Banfield and Barry)

Rucks - Gawn, Goldstein (Cameron)

Fwd - Franklin, Greene, McLean, Smith, Caddy and Sicily (L Ryan and Fritsch)

[crowls]

A trade used to be considered justifiable if it made / saved over around $100,000?

Hibberd to Bonner

Three round projection saving = $180,000


But lose a potential keeper, maybe some points along the way but it is tempting especially with all those lovely trades just sitting there burning a hole in my pocket.

As a doctor our perception is money would be no problem. ;D as I walk past Tesla 75D in Doctors parking spot outside my office.
  Do the trade Doc.   Hibberd is not turning it around whilst he is has current role to play.   

[plumdog millionaire]

ZGL to Murphy straight up, but two options on how to do it:

Move Garlett into FWD, Finlayson to MID (Playing L Ryan/Venables) OR

Sicily to FWD (Playing Brayshaw/Banfield)

Leaning towards option two I think?

[Southstorm]

Hey crew need some help please.

Mistake - Weitering and Brodie (GC)

Option 1 - Weitering to Bonner and Brodie to Fisher via DPP of McLean. $28k

Option 2 - Weitering to Bonner and Caddy to Fisher $230k

Kinda stuck in the thinking of it. I dont think il end wirh Caddy but Brodie isnt playing.

Help?

What's the rest of your team looking like?

I put faith in the rookie defenders this year. (Too much faith in Weitering)

Def - McGovern, Savage, Weirering, Finlayson, Murray, Doedee (Naughton and L Murphy)

Mid - Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Coniglio, T, Kelly, A Brayshaw and Holman (Brodie, Banfield and Barry)

Rucks - Gawn, Goldstein (Cameron)

Fwd - Franklin, Greene, McLean, Smith, Caddy and Sicily (L Ryan and Fritsch)

I'd go Caddy to a rookie forward and Weitering to a premo

[Southstorm]

3 Trades I want to do this week

ZGL -> Ryan
Crouch -> Dusty
Hibberd -> Simmo

Obviously can only do 2, leaning towards the first two due to injury but worried about carrying Hibbo any further. What do?

[whynot102]

Decided to keep Hibberd think will come good and trade Crouch to Taranto via Garlett DPP to mids and then Armitage to Cripps gets Garlett of the ground in the forward line
Thoughts

[Bully]

3 Trades I want to do this week

ZGL -> Ryan
Crouch -> Dusty
Hibberd -> Simmo

Obviously can only do 2, leaning towards the first two due to injury but worried about carrying Hibbo any further. What do?

I'd do the first two just out of necessity.

[Bones Bombers]

I don't really like the idea of trading out a premium level player but with Hibberd scoring poorly right now and about to lose some value I have the possibility of trading him to Clayton Oliver (who I am a massive fan of) by moving Finlayson back to defence.
The defence rookies are looking reasonably reliable and the extra mid premo looks amazing!
Do we really need to trade Hibberd or should we hold and give him more time?

Good trade I think. I’ve done similar, traded Hibberd to a premium on another line and backed  in the defense rookies.

Can then pick the best defender premos when they become clearer. If Hibberd becomes one I will still look at him.
I may have started Clarry instead of Danger if not for the reported knee injury.

If I do go ahead with this trade it will be two years in a row I have picked up Oliver in Rd3. Better start him next year!