Round 3 Trades

[Jimmykidd]

My POD pick in Menegola has back fired hard so I'll be trading him to Heeney.

My other trade is a toss up between Kruze and Bont.

Bont still wasn't convincing in my opinion, even though he hit the ton. Macca looks to be the best mid at the dogs ATM.

Kruze could be in for another injury interrupted season after being so good last season. Big worry.

Will more than likely hold both if they play, but I've been burned in the past by holding premos hoping they come good. (looking at you heater)

[dmac07]

The two Im ditching are Crouch and Bell (what was I thinking). I have two options that work.

Option 1 - Crouch to Conglio and Bell to D.Smith

Option 2 - Crouch to Oliver/Parker/Pendles and Bell to Fisher/Christensen

Thoughts? Currently leaning to Oliver and Fisher as Im not convinced Smith can be a top 6-8 forward.

[frenzy]

Hmmmmm fix cash generation or chase the points, what to do?

[Jalapeno]

The two Im ditching are Crouch and Bell (what was I thinking). I have two options that work.

Option 1 - Crouch to Conglio and Bell to D.Smith

Option 2 - Crouch to Oliver/Parker/Pendles and Bell to Fisher/Christensen

Thoughts? Currently leaning to Oliver and Fisher as Im not convinced Smith can be a top 6-8 forward.

I would take Option 2 as Oliver will be a top 4 mid in my opinion and Christensen a great stepping stone.

Option 2 is more of an unknown, yet dev smith looks the goods

[Southstorm]

The two Im ditching are Crouch and Bell (what was I thinking). I have two options that work.

Option 1 - Crouch to Conglio and Bell to D.Smith

Option 2 - Crouch to Oliver/Parker/Pendles and Bell to Fisher/Christensen

Thoughts? Currently leaning to Oliver and Fisher as Im not convinced Smith can be a top 6-8 forward.

I'd probably go the first option; Coniglio certainly looks like a top 10 forward with his game at the moment and I'd back Devon in to stay at the coalface. I don't think Woosha ever intended to play him as a forward and he puts in more effort around stoppages than just about everybody else in red and black right now. 

2 keepers vs 1 keeper and a mid pricer

[tor01doc]

The two Im ditching are Crouch and Bell (what was I thinking). I have two options that work.

Option 1 - Crouch to Conglio and Bell to D.Smith

Option 2 - Crouch to Oliver/Parker/Pendles and Bell to Fisher/Christensen

Thoughts? Currently leaning to Oliver and Fisher as Im not convinced Smith can be a top 6-8 forward.

I'd probably go the first option; Coniglio certainly looks like a top 10 forwardwith his game at the moment and I'd back Devon in to stay at the coalface. I don't think Woosha ever intended to play him as a forward and he puts in more effort around stoppages than just about everybody else in red and black right now. 

2 keepers vs 1 keeper and a mid pricer

[tor01doc]

I still agree 

[Bones Bombers]

I don't really like the idea of trading out a premium level player but with Hibberd scoring poorly right now and about to lose some value I have the possibility of trading him to Clayton Oliver (who I am a massive fan of) by moving Finlayson back to defence.
The defence rookies are looking reasonably reliable and the extra mid premo looks amazing!
Do we really need to trade Hibberd or should we hold and give him more time?

[no eye deer]

I don't really like the idea of trading out a premium level player but with Hibberd scoring poorly right now and about to lose some value I have the possibility of trading him to Clayton Oliver (who I am a massive fan of) by moving Finlayson back to defence.
The defence rookies are looking reasonably reliable and the extra mid premo looks amazing!
Do we really need to trade Hibberd or should we hold and give him more time?

Good trade I think. I’ve done similar, traded Hibberd to a premium on another line and backed  in the defense rookies.

[jvalles69]

Still so torn about Bont...if Dogs keep playing like this he will be rubbish.  I'm tempted to burn a trade on someone who will net me the most cash whilst scoring well, then trade that person onto Danger when he's peaked.  I'd be holding trades otherwise, but being well ranked I feel like I need to make a ballsy move early.  Options are Taranto for the biggest cash grab, or go to Cripps/Jelwood for the price rise and solid scoring.  Does anyone think Jelwood or Cripps can be keepers?   I could then get Danger later, just feel Bont is gonna burn me and it will be a case of shoulda, woulda, coulda.  :-\

[Dir Goose]

atm thinking Bont - Oliver and ZGL - Garlett

[Bones Bombers]

I don't really like the idea of trading out a premium level player but with Hibberd scoring poorly right now and about to lose some value I have the possibility of trading him to Clayton Oliver (who I am a massive fan of) by moving Finlayson back to defence.
The defence rookies are looking reasonably reliable and the extra mid premo looks amazing!
Do we really need to trade Hibberd or should we hold and give him more time?

Good trade I think. I’ve done similar, traded Hibberd to a premium on another line and backed  in the defense rookies.

Can then pick the best defender premos when they become clearer. If Hibberd becomes one I will still look at him.
I may have started Clarry instead of Danger if not for the reported knee injury.

[El Duke 2]

I don't really like the idea of trading out a premium level player but with Hibberd scoring poorly right now and about to lose some value I have the possibility of trading him to Clayton Oliver (who I am a massive fan of) by moving Finlayson back to defence.
The defence rookies are looking reasonably reliable and the extra mid premo looks amazing!
Do we really need to trade Hibberd or should we hold and give him more time?

Good trade I think. I’ve done similar, traded Hibberd to a premium on another line and backed  in the defense rookies.

Can then pick the best defender premos when they become clearer. If Hibberd becomes one I will still look at him.
I may have started Clarry instead of Danger if not for the reported knee injury.

Looking at the same, can bring in Danger to go with Titch, Dusty, Ablett, Fyfe and Cripps.

[Bones Bombers]

Geez, I'm finding it hard enough to trade Hibberd, let alone Bont.
The guy is a superstar. Surely he gets to play his proper position soon and returns to his best scoring.
He has my Bombers this week. Watch him go....

[PureSwag]

I've got two more options and what to do.

Option 1: Naughton to Bonner (7.6k in the Bank)
Option 2: Brayshaw to Bonner (via Finlayson) (About 66k in the bank)

Option 1 is the better options terms as points but Option 2 will leave me with a lot of cash to due another trade if needed. Which option is better?