Round 3 Trades

[Fid]

Pi$$ed off with Sicily

Sicily to Ryan

Hibberd to Simpson

Then I'll have over $340K in the kitty and look at getting Danger in a few weeks

[billnats]

Definitely need some assistance:
Trade 1:
M. Crouch to Parker, Jelwood or Gibbs?? 

Trade 2:
Hibberd to Simpson
Or
Bring English in for Giles-Langdon considering he is injured

[DunnyBrush]

Definitely need some assistance:
Trade 1:
M. Crouch to Parker, Jelwood or Gibbs?? 

Trade 2:
Hibberd to Simpson
Or
Bring English in for Giles-Langdon considering he is injured

Don't go near English, he flopped on the weekend and may get dropped.
If you have a premium mid out for 3 weeks you need to take care of that, otherwise i would say get in Simmo.

[tommy10]

Def: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray (Naughton, Murphy)
Mids: Titch, Zerrett, Fyfe, Bont, Cripps, Conigs, Kelly, Holman (Brayshaw, Banfield, Barry)

Option 1:
Hibberd to Shaw
Bont to Dusty

Option 2:
Brayshaw to Fogarty
Naughton to Bonner

Option 3:
Hibberd to Simmo
Zerrett to Dusty

Option 4:
Hibberd to Shaw
Naughton to Bonner

Thoughts? Leaning towards option 4 as I think Hibberd’s role is different from last year and doesn’t seem to take kick ins.

Thought guys?

[bowyanger]

Probably guilty of overanalysing/

Keeping both Beams and Bont at this stage - Reasoning Beams will build as the season goes on as he missed a fair bit of pre-season with rehab early, wet weather and death of father.  Bont showed some good signs so giving him another week or 2.

Thoughts on these trades;
Lambert - Westhoff Know Rd 10 bye but will be the only one with it so can cover.
Finlayson to mids and Brayshaw to Bonner.

I started Lambert as well
Ive traded him out this week so he will score 110 now this week so you should hold

I looked closely at Hoff, Dixon or Boak...I think Dixon has the most upside but Hoff would be a good trade as well - splitting hairs really

I was looking at Lambert, Duggan > Bonner, Dixon...was surprising what that did to my projection score
At the moment Ive gone Lambert, Duggan > LRyan, TMitch (swapped Finlayson to backs)...this resulted with less projection on above trade even with TMitch as Captain

[GoLions]

Def: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray (Naughton, Murphy)
Mids: Titch, Zerrett, Fyfe, Bont, Cripps, Conigs, Kelly, Holman (Brayshaw, Banfield, Barry)

Option 1:
Hibberd to Shaw
Bont to Dusty

Option 2:
Brayshaw to Fogarty
Naughton to Bonner

Option 3:
Hibberd to Simmo
Zerrett to Dusty

Option 4:
Hibberd to Shaw
Naughton to Bonner

Thoughts? Leaning towards option 4 as I think Hibberd’s role is different from last year and doesn’t seem to take kick ins.

Thought guys?

2 if you have to trade i guess

[RoughRed]

Def: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray (Naughton, Murphy)
Mids: Titch, Zerrett, Fyfe, Bont, Cripps, Conigs, Kelly, Holman (Brayshaw, Banfield, Barry)

Option 1:
Hibberd to Shaw
Bont to Dusty

Option 2:
Brayshaw to Fogarty
Naughton to Bonner

Option 3:
Hibberd to Simmo
Zerrett to Dusty

Option 4:
Hibberd to Shaw
Naughton to Bonner

Thoughts? Leaning towards option 4 as I think Hibberd’s role is different from last year and doesn’t seem to take kick ins.

Thought guys?

IMO

Zerrett: you have cover with good rooks - Hold unless you think ongoing concussion is an issue - not on the AFL injury list tonight

Naughton: Slow burn, good JS - Hold

Hibberd: BE 171 ... forecast drop of $38K on projected 91 score - bye bye for me not because of the price drop but because
not sure of his role is SC friendly

Brayshaw:  has a BE of  -2 +$28.5K increase on projected score of 60 -Fogarty (Geelong) is cash grab (BE -60, $+56K on projected score of 65) - so +28K on performance + $80K (approx) on player price differential - so potential is +$100K plus in the kitty.

Only a short term play IMO  with Danger, Gaz, JSelwood, MDuncan (to return), Scooter (to return) and Kelly (young gun) there is not a long term position

Brayshaw => Fogarty
Hibberd => Shaw/Simpson

Hey but I just lost 50K+ places last round so what do I know :)

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm considering

Hibberd to L.Ryan via DPP
Crouch to Dusty

Leaves me with over 400k so next week I can go Arma to Danger

I'd be fielding both Ryan and Fritsch at F5/6 but I could swing Sicily forward to replace one of them if a def rookie does well enough

Laird, Sicily, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray would be my back 6 - reckon I can run with that for a while and then look to get another prem forward in shortly after so Ryan/Fritsch would only be on field for maybe 1-2 weeks tops

[AN1611]

Naughton to murphy
Bell to mclean
1 forward rookie of fristch or liam ryan
3 mid rookies - kelly holman brayshaw

Or

Naughton to Murphy
Bell to cogz
2 forward rookies from fristch,ryan and garlett
Mid rookies: kelly holman (brayshaw on bench)

Currently leaning towards mclean as he is more chance of a top 8 fwd than cogz a top 10mid
What do you guys think?

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

At this stage, I'm going:

Naughton -> L.Murphy
Cyril -> Fisher

Gives me a nice little bank to help with upgrades.

Watching Fisher the first two rounds, he has been flowering good. If he can maintain an 80-85 avg, I will take that.

[igotworms]

At this stage, I'm going:

Naughton -> L.Murphy
Cyril -> Fisher

Gives me a nice little bank to help with upgrades.

Watching Fisher the first two rounds, he has been flowering good. If he can maintain an 80-85 avg, I will take that.

I too have been watching Fisher, he's looking very tempting! Slightly awkward price, but if he maintains an average of 80-85 like you say, great stepping stone. Great user of the ball and is getting a bit of it. For a wee little fella, he has a crack too!
I'm thinking of downgrading Crouch to Taranto......... my stepping stone to Danger. (hopefully)
Upgrading Garlett to Fisher.......... much faster cash generation!

[ubeaut]

I'm considering

Hibberd to L.Ryan via DPP
Crouch to Dusty

Leaves me with over 400k so next week I can go Arma to Danger

I'd be fielding both Ryan and Fritsch at F5/6 but I could swing Sicily forward to replace one of them if a def rookie does well enough

Laird, Sicily, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray would be my back 6 - reckon I can run with that for a while and then look to get another prem forward in shortly after so Ryan/Fritsch would only be on field for maybe 1-2 weeks tops

Gets u Dusty and Danger plus cash generation in Ryan.
Backline would be a bit exposed tho who's D7-8? Back rookies are doing well however so should be worth it.

[WizzFizz]

have byrne and bell

trade bell > fisher and field lmurphy
or
trade byrne > bonner and field fritch

leaning toward option 1

thoughts

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm considering

Hibberd to L.Ryan via DPP
Crouch to Dusty

Leaves me with over 400k so next week I can go Arma to Danger

I'd be fielding both Ryan and Fritsch at F5/6 but I could swing Sicily forward to replace one of them if a def rookie does well enough

Laird, Sicily, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray would be my back 6 - reckon I can run with that for a while and then look to get another prem forward in shortly after so Ryan/Fritsch would only be on field for maybe 1-2 weeks tops

Gets u Dusty and Danger plus cash generation in Ryan.
Backline would be a bit exposed tho who's D7-8? Back rookies are doing well however so should be worth it.

Pretty convinced this is what I will go with

Naughton and Murphy on the bench, with the ability to swing Sicily and Keeffe to loophole each week should be fine for a couple of weeks

I get Dusty this week, Danger next week and then I've got Danger, Dusty, Titch, GAJ, J.Kelly, Fyfe, T.Kelly, Holman which can hopefully produce and hold the fort whilst I then make my first upgrade in the forward line shortly after

[Dudge]

I'm considering

Hibberd to L.Ryan via DPP
Crouch to Dusty

Leaves me with over 400k so next week I can go Arma to Danger

I'd be fielding both Ryan and Fritsch at F5/6 but I could swing Sicily forward to replace one of them if a def rookie does well enough

Laird, Sicily, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray would be my back 6 - reckon I can run with that for a while and then look to get another prem forward in shortly after so Ryan/Fritsch would only be on field for maybe 1-2 weeks tops

Gets u Dusty and Danger plus cash generation in Ryan.
Backline would be a bit exposed tho who's D7-8? Back rookies are doing well however so should be worth it.

Pretty convinced this is what I will go with

Naughton and Murphy on the bench, with the ability to swing Sicily and Keeffe to loophole each week should be fine for a couple of weeks

I get Dusty this week, Danger next week and then I've got Danger, Dusty, Titch, GAJ, J.Kelly, Fyfe, T.Kelly, Holman which can hopefully produce and hold the fort whilst I then make my first upgrade in the forward line shortly after

Looks good RD, love that midfield so early in the season