Round 3 Trades

[Jalapeno]

For the people trading out zerret, is it because you don't think he is 110+ mid anymore or because of the injured and slow start, he's had.

I still think he is more than capable of averaging 110 rest of the year so the drop in value isn't really gonna affect me especially since most people who don't have him will try to get him in round 4-5.


Unless you really need that cash for an upgrade elsewhere or no longer believe that he will average in the top 10-12 mids, I don't think you should consider trading him out.


but then again I'm ranked like 20k so what do I know haha.

I truly do not believe he will go 110+ this season. And is an easy upgrade to danger for me. I had plqnned to trade whichever mid premo didnt fire to Danger after round 2 so itll be Zerrett for me

[Ringo]

Option 1.

Lambert to Jack Martin
Beams/Bontempelli to Dusty

Option 2
Lambert to Jack Martin
Naughton to Bonner

[SilverLion]

Option 1.

Lambert to Jack Martin
Beams/Bontempelli to Dusty

Option 2
Lambert to Jack Martin
Naughton to Bonner

Option 2 for mine. Gets Murray off the field.

[jfitty]

Option 1.

Lambert to Jack Martin
Beams/Bontempelli to Dusty

Option 2
Lambert to Jack Martin
Naughton to Bonner

Not sure about Jack Martin, do you think he'll go 90+ for the season Ringo? Had a great game on the weekend, but feel like he's not too much of an upgrade to Lambert.

I'd probably ditch Beams for Dusty, so option 1 for mine.

[Ringo]

Option 1.

Lambert to Jack Martin
Beams/Bontempelli to Dusty

Option 2
Lambert to Jack Martin
Naughton to Bonner

Not sure about Jack Martin, do you think he'll go 90+ for the season Ringo? Had a great game on the weekend, but feel like he's not too much of an upgrade to Lambert.

I'd probably ditch Beams for Dusty, so option 1 for mine.

had Martin in my team up until the last few days whenI thought Lambert may be the better option hence why I am going back to him. Watched both Suns games and he is spending quite a bit of time around the ball. Happy if he goes 90+ early signs positive,
Bont was the other alternative to Beams to go to Dusty. Still reallly undecided which one with Lions bias and Beams underdone due to fathers death. Will get better no doubt,   

[WhatsSC???]

I might do 1,2 or no trades but my only thoughts were....

Naughton to Bonner
Brayshaw to Fisher


I have Hibberd and Zorko, slightly underwhelming, but worst case they get better or end up at the end of the season as D7 and M9, which will be better bench cover than majority of teams...

[iZander]

I might do 1,2 or no trades but my only thoughts were....

Naughton to Bonner
Brayshaw to Fisher


I have Hibberd and Zorko, slightly underwhelming, but worst case they get better or end up at the end of the season as D7 and M9, which will be better bench cover than majority of teams...

I personally like the look of brayshaw dont think hes worth a trade, fisher may keep it up but i very much doubt it

naughton to bonner looks the goods though if you can still do it!

[Colty]

Crouch to Coniglio, do we think he is a must have? Will have ave 110?

[SilverLion]

Crouch to Coniglio, do we think he is a must have? Will have ave 110?

Far from a must have when theres players like Oliver, Macrae, Zerrett, Kelly etc.

Good way to bank some cash, but would bring in one of the 600k-ish mids in preference.

[PureSwag]

Need a bit of help of trades

Option 1:
Bont to Dusty

Option 2:
Naughton to Bonner

I think Option 1 because after this week Dusty is going to be so hard to get but I'm unsure.

[Colty]

Crouch to Coniglio, do we think he is a must have? Will have ave 110?

Far from a must have when theres players like Oliver, Macrae, Zerrett, Kelly etc.

Good way to bank some cash, but would bring in one of the 600k-ish mids in preference.

wanted to punt that stinky Byrne for Torranto, would need to downgrade Crouch to Coniglio to do so. Is that falling into a trap?

[SilverLion]

Crouch to Coniglio, do we think he is a must have? Will have ave 110?

Far from a must have when theres players like Oliver, Macrae, Zerrett, Kelly etc.

Good way to bank some cash, but would bring in one of the 600k-ish mids in preference.

wanted to punt that stinky Byrne for Torranto, would need to downgrade Crouch to Coniglio to do so. Is that falling into a trap?

Maybe, but could be worth the punt.

Think Taranto is worth waiting on to see if he is going to average 90+ consistently. Agreed that Byrne has to go though. Bonner would be the other option down back, or downgrade to a rookie.

[WhatsSC???]

I might do 1,2 or no trades but my only thoughts were....

Naughton to Bonner
Brayshaw to Fisher


I have Hibberd and Zorko, slightly underwhelming, but worst case they get better or end up at the end of the season as D7 and M9, which will be better bench cover than majority of teams...

I personally like the look of brayshaw dont think hes worth a trade, fisher may keep it up but i very much doubt it

naughton to bonner looks the goods though if you can still do it!

Still not sold on all options....
Naughton, bulldogs in general have been smashed so scores are expected to be low...
Bonner, only real indication is syd game 76 points, but may get less of a role when Pittard is back....
Brayshaw is highest $$ with probably a slow burn, and moving him to fisher allows me to reduce my fwd rookies to 1
Fisher, well who knows what all these young kids can do at Carlton might be a rollercoaster, but can see him hitting $400k quickly

my only other option was Brayshaw -> Taranto but he's near the keeper range and the FWD line is a mess with who will be Top 6, 10, even 20 this year....

I'll probably wait till Teams are released and go with my gut from there....

[js19]

Armo to Dusty just about locked

Caddy to Ryan or Taranto (or just hold) is the conundrum

[tommy10]

Def: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray (Naughton, Murphy)
Mids: Titch, Zerrett, Fyfe, Bont, Cripps, Conigs, Kelly, Holman (Brayshaw, Banfield, Barry)

Option 1:
Hibberd to Shaw
Bont to Dusty

Option 2:
Brayshaw to Fogarty
Naughton to Bonner

Option 3:
Hibberd to Simmo
Zerrett to Dusty

Option 4:
Hibberd to Shaw
Naughton to Bonner

Thoughts? Leaning towards option 4 as I think Hibberd’s role is different from last year and doesn’t seem to take kick ins.