Round 3 Trades

[HoleMeal]

I'm thinking I might hold my trades this week, head into round 3 with 29 in the bank for a change.

Happy to hang onto Naughton on the bench considering his JS, and the rest of the rookies I have look fairly solid. Fogarty and English the only 2 I was looking at and neither of them look like they're worth a trade to bring in.

Hibberd the only concern, but think I'll keep the faith. Wouldn't mind a drop in his ownership, plus a ton next week and all will be forgiven.

^^^THIS exactly. 29 after doing Bell to Bonner last week via DPP.

[WizzFizz]

holman vs bonner vs ryan which one should i grab in what order

[HoleMeal]

holman vs bonner vs ryan which one should i grab in what order

I would go Holm/Ryan/Bonner

[Goosey]

Holman best value, Bonner better player?

[Nige]

Swinging Finlayson to the middle and trading Clark to Bonner is probably gonna be a trade I'll make now.

[tommy10]

holman vs bonner vs ryan which one should i grab in what order

Holman > Bonner > Ryan. Holman is a must have. Bonner respectable score against the Swans and Ryan will be up and down.

[Bluesalltheway]

With Kelly and Holman travelling along so well I think my play might be to downgrade Armitage to Ryan, as he's currently at m7 meaning one of them is wasted on the bench. Will probably hold my second trade and just sit on the cash in case someone like Lobb needs upgrading

[ubeaut]

Is Fogarty a must?

I'm not convinced. Think Brayshaw --> Fogarty would be a waste of a trade.

Not a must. However, if like me u have only 2 spots on field, Kelly taking one of them and Holman being a mature age tackling machine, where does that leave Brayshaw?A 200k rookie sitting on the bench that's where. I stupidly played Brayshaw over Kelly 1st week and Holman this week. It's killing me.
If Fogarty can keep his spot it's a mighty tempting trade. Even tho Brayshaw will improve is he worth the price tag? Banfield and Cerra taking their slice of the pie as rookies as well.

[ubeaut]

Tempted to trade Brayshaw to either Bonner or L.Fogarty.
Problem with Bonner is I'd have Finlayson coming into mids which leaves Holman on the bench which is partly why I'm trading Brayshaw in the first place!

Other trades could be Hibberd > Simpson
Controversial trade is Merrett > Danger
I believe the tag is back and Merrett,Sloane,Zorko type players will suffer. Plus he is going to lose a heap of cash and the best trade out for Danger given Titch,Dusty,Cripps and Fyfe are my other premos

[kilbluff1985]

is Rocky to conigs a decent trade

after doing that and Rayner to Ryan i already have enough for my first upgrade when it's time

[SilverLion]

is Rocky to conigs a decent trade

after doing that and Rayner to Ryan i already have enough for my first upgrade when it's time

Trades look good to me.

Unsure on if its worth trading in Conigs now, given that its likely you'll have to trade him out again at some stage. Can be justified though.

[ubeaut]

is Rocky to conigs a decent trade

after doing that and Rayner to Ryan i already have enough for my first upgrade when it's time

100 % I would do these trades. Not sure why u started with Rayner but he should be traded to either Bundy or Ryan for sure.
Rocky will improve but there's too many mids at Port, and despite his assertion he would play "similar to at Lions with mostly midfield and some time fwd"'i believe they got him for depth and to play a fwd role switching with Boak and Gray.
Coniglio I regret not starting BIG TIME.
I advised others he would be such a value pick but couldn't squeeze him in.

[kilbluff1985]

is Rocky to conigs a decent trade

after doing that and Rayner to Ryan i already have enough for my first upgrade when it's time

100 % I would do these trades. Not sure why u started with Rayner but he should be traded to either Bundy or Ryan for sure.
Rocky will improve but there's too many mids at Port, and despite his assertion he would play "similar to at Lions with mostly midfield and some time fwd"'i believe they got him for depth and to play a fwd role switching with Boak and Gray.
Coniglio I regret not starting BIG TIME.
I advised others he would be such a value pick but couldn't squeeze him in.

overthought with Rayner thought he had better JS and dpp

[walloo44]

Hibberd â€"> Shaw
Crouch â€"> dusty +78K
Or
Hibberd â€"> Simpson
Crouch â€"> Parker (180k) / Olver (120k)

[GoLions]

Probably hold my trades this week I reckon