Round 3 Trades

[crowls]

Have enough cash to do -

Naughton to Sicily
Dunkly to Ryan

thoughts

cash generation and points improvement.  good trades

[Mahogany]

Thanks guys. Really appreciate your feedback!

[AN1611]

Thoughts on this:

Hibberd to Bonner
Bell to Dusty

[SilverLion]

Thoughts on this:

Hibberd to Bonner
Bell to Dusty

Means an extra FWD rookie on the ground instead of a mid rookie I'd say. Probably not worth it.

Bell --> FWD rookie, Naughton --> Bonner would be what I would do (If you have Naughton).

[AN1611]

Thoughts on this:

Hibberd to Bonner
Bell to Dusty

Means an extra FWD rookie on the ground instead of a mid rookie I'd say. Probably not worth it.

Bell --> FWD rookie, Naughton --> Bonner would be what I would do (If you have Naughton).

Should have specified that bell was my F5 - reasonably comfortable with that. Other option is:

naughton to murphy
Bell to cogz

[iZander]

Thoughts on this:

Hibberd to Bonner
Bell to Dusty

Means an extra FWD rookie on the ground instead of a mid rookie I'd say. Probably not worth it.

Bell --> FWD rookie, Naughton --> Bonner would be what I would do (If you have Naughton).

Yeah good call, want to get as many fwd rookies off the field as possible

[enzedder]

Thoughts on this:

Hibberd to Bonner
Bell to Dusty

Means an extra FWD rookie on the ground instead of a mid rookie I'd say. Probably not worth it.

Bell --> FWD rookie, Naughton --> Bonner would be what I would do (If you have Naughton).

On paper massive trades to get Dusty for Bell. But if factoring a weakened fwd line it does negate things somewhat.
Hibberd to Shaw/ Simmo/ Sicily/ Savage
Bell to Christensen/ Langdon/ Fritsch/ Ryan/ Marshall
Correction trades to in form players or rookies who will generate money and will also give you pocket money towards an upgrade.

[duffercoat]

Hibberd -> Savage/Lloyd/Hurn/Shaw

Brayshaw -> Taranto F5 (via garlett)

Thoughts? 

[Southstorm]

M. Crouch -> Dusty. Don't think I'll be doing anything else.

[Southstorm]

Hibberd -> Savage/Lloyd/Hurn/Shaw

Brayshaw -> Taranto F5 (via garlett)

Thoughts?

I don't know if I'd be jumping off Hibberd just yet, especially to somebody that isn't Yeo/Laird/Hurley/Simpson.

[RoughRed]

Is Hurn seriously into the SC equation this year - 112 and 138 from 1st two games
$487,200
BE after Rd1 was 42 ... now?
Could be his breakout year :)

[Bully]

Will be Hibberd to Shaw
Bont to Dusty/Mitchell

[SilverLion]

Is Fogarty a must?

I'm not convinced. Think Brayshaw --> Fogarty would be a waste of a trade.

[Bully]

Is Fogarty a must?

I'm not convinced. Think Brayshaw --> Fogarty would be a waste of a trade.

Not a must unless you need to free up cash to get a bolter before the price rises

[jfitty]

I'm thinking I might hold my trades this week, head into round 3 with 30 in the bank for a change.

Happy to hang onto Naughton on the bench considering his JS, and the rest of the rookies I have look fairly solid. Fogarty and English the only 2 I was looking at and neither of them look like they're worth a trade to bring in.

Hibberd the only concern, but think I'll keep the faith. Wouldn't mind a drop in his ownership, plus a ton next week and all will be forgiven.