Round 3 Trades

[_wato]

Byrne > Bonner
Crouch > Pahka

I know I have underperforming premos (enter Beams) but the guy is a proven gun, I know he’ll lose cash but I also know he’ll start to score well soon and I’ll be pissy I traded (much like Fyfe last year)
Sandi is staying, few rucks scored poo this round. Has Witts and then Lobb so I’m sure he can get back up to premium scoring.
Bont looked good in another flogging, will be better once they start to get into a groove.

Other than that, happy with all my rookies so just gonna wait and sit.

[SilverLion]

MCrouch to Oliver looking the most likely one for me. Grape, Macrae or a MID/FWD of my choosing are the alternatives.

Don't think I'll make a second trade unless Fogarty goes 80+ again. Naughton to Murphy potentially, but don't really think its worth it.

[tommy10]

How quickly a day of footy changes everything. Exactly the reason I don't trade after 1 round. I'm sure plenty did Ryan to English which I had locked and loaded until a few hours ago.

I'm now thinking
Hibberd > Shaw/Simmo
Naughton > Bonner

Best start to a year I've had in a long time and have pretty much nailed all my picks

Thinking the exact same trades for me too. Only thing that might change these trades is trying to get Dusty. Zerrett/Bont to Dusty the only options I see but not worth it even though they will lose cash. Bit stumped on this one  :-\ The other option is Fogarty if he does well tomorrow.

[billnats]

With Crouch injury, I was thinking of the following:
Crouch to Gibbs/Jelwood
Cameron to English

But will have enough cash to also go:
Petracca to Heeney... it’s not needed but just regret not starting Heeney!

[RaisyDaisy]

Feel like I've nailed my rookie picks. Well, I don't think I've missed any must haves except possibly Ryan but I'm definitely not expecting him to score well regularly, bit his JS should be very good and he should make quick cash now

I reckon I have 3 options. Which 2 do I pick, and which one do I pass on?

Hibberd to Shaw
Naughton to Ryan
Crouch to Dusty

I could do the first two trades this week, bench Crouch for a week and then trade him next week. Means I cop a lower score having to field Brayshaw instead of Dusty essentially, but it does allow me to get the other 2 which will help much more in terms of future $ plus I kind of like the idea that it gives me another round to see Danger/Dusty/Oliver and then pick one of them the following week for Crouch

[js19]

Feel like I've nailed my rookie picks. Well, I don't think I've missed any must haves except possibly Ryan but I'm definitely not expecting him to score well regularly, bit his JS should be very good and he should make quick cash now

I reckon I have 3 options. Which 2 do I pick, and which one do I pass on?

Hibberd to Shaw
Naughton to Ryan
Crouch to Dusty

I could do the first two trades this week, bench Crouch for a week and then trade him next week. Means I cop a lower score having to field Brayshaw instead of Dusty essentially, but it does allow me to get the other 2 which will help much more in terms of future $ plus I kind of like the idea that it gives me another round to see Danger/Dusty/Oliver and then pick one of them the following week for Crouch

If you're willing to leave the $ on the bench for a week it may be better in the long run.

The quick $ to be made from Ryan is tempting. I'd need to trade either Garlett or Venables to get him in. Given up on English for now.

Armo to Dusty, Venables/Garlett to Ryan
v
Caddy to Cripps, Venables to Taranto

Are a couple of options for me. I've got Caddy who has a holiday, so could do Armo-Cripps, Caddy to Shaw/Simpson.... Ahhh, decisions

[Ringo]

Looks like these will be my trades:

Beams to Dusty
Lambert to Sicily/Jack Martin.

2 correction trades at this stage.

Ah you didn't end up starting with Martin Ringo? Saw him playing well yesterday and thought of ya.

Started him in DT not SC, Thought Lambert may have been better for SC How wrong.

[batt]

Naughton looked better yesterday.  Will definitely get burn.

Still need the cash for Dusty, so:

Armitage -> Bonner via Finlayson
Crouch -> Dusty

[iZander]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd isn't taking kick outs, will definitely hurt his scoring. Shaw is & we know how high his ceiling can be. In 3 weeks Shaw will be Hibberd's value, so we're looking at a 150k turnaround. That to me is worth a trade.

Findlayson showed today that he is the best kick in the GWS team in their defense. He is splitting the kick-ins with Shaw and I wouldn't be surprised if he started to take more given he is the long term option out of their defense and Shaw is in the back-end of his career.

Shaw's been great in the 2 games and definitely on my radar to bring into my side. I'm personally not comfortable trading out keepers after 2 weeks.

Cash in bank is really important, a Hibberd to Shaw trade is worth about 90k. If & when Hibberd returns to his best then bring him in but he will be bleeding money over the next few weeks.

Cash in the bank is important but so is a trade :P

[SilverLion]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd isn't taking kick outs, will definitely hurt his scoring. Shaw is & we know how high his ceiling can be. In 3 weeks Shaw will be Hibberd's value, so we're looking at a 150k turnaround. That to me is worth a trade.

Findlayson showed today that he is the best kick in the GWS team in their defense. He is splitting the kick-ins with Shaw and I wouldn't be surprised if he started to take more given he is the long term option out of their defense and Shaw is in the back-end of his career.

Shaw's been great in the 2 games and definitely on my radar to bring into my side. I'm personally not comfortable trading out keepers after 2 weeks.

Cash in bank is really important, a Hibberd to Shaw trade is worth about 90k. If & when Hibberd returns to his best then bring him in but he will be bleeding money over the next few weeks.

Cash in the bank is important but so is a trade :P

Agreed. Is 90k cash really worth 2 trades?

[Woppa15]

Potentially Hibberd to Simpson as it allows me to go Naughton to Bonner.

[iZander]

Potentially Hibberd to Simpson as it allows me to go Naughton to Bonner.

Yeah i can get behind this one, seems like legit upgrades

Where as shaw seems just as likely to drop as hibbo is to keep putting up his showerty scores :P

[bkimm32]

Hunter clark is my only must trade, and will likely go to lachie fogarty (depending how he goes today) my second trade all depends on how Dangerfield goes today. If he performs below expectations I can spend a bit of my danger fund to get someone like Tarrant in for d fogarty or venables, if Danger kills it then I probably have to downgrade someone like Hibberd to shaw to make a tad more money to get danger in sooner.

After today itll become more clear what u must do.

[Mahogany]

Have enough cash to do -

Naughton to Sicily
Dunkly to Ryan

thoughts

[enzedder]

Have enough cash to do -

Naughton to Sicily
Dunkly to Ryan

thoughts

I like those.