Round 3 Trades

[Bully]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd isn't taking kick outs, will definitely hurt his scoring. Shaw is & we know how high his ceiling can be. In 3 weeks Shaw will be Hibberd's value, so we're looking at a 150k turnaround. That to me is worth a trade.

[js19]

Looking at getting English if he delivers tomorrow

Venables to English and Armo to Dusty

OR

Olango to English and Armo to any premo mid except Dusty...?

[AaronKirk]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd isn't taking kick outs, will definitely hurt his scoring. Shaw is & we know how high his ceiling can be. In 3 weeks Shaw will be Hibberd's value, so we're looking at a 150k turnaround. That to me is worth a trade.

Findlayson showed today that he is the best kick in the GWS team in their defense. He is splitting the kick-ins with Shaw and I wouldn't be surprised if he started to take more given he is the long term option out of their defense and Shaw is in the back-end of his career.

Shaw's been great in the 2 games and definitely on my radar to bring into my side. I'm personally not comfortable trading out keepers after 2 weeks.

[Bully]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd isn't taking kick outs, will definitely hurt his scoring. Shaw is & we know how high his ceiling can be. In 3 weeks Shaw will be Hibberd's value, so we're looking at a 150k turnaround. That to me is worth a trade.

Findlayson showed today that he is the best kick in the GWS team in their defense. He is splitting the kick-ins with Shaw and I wouldn't be surprised if he started to take more given he is the long term option out of their defense and Shaw is in the back-end of his career.

Shaw's been great in the 2 games and definitely on my radar to bring into my side. I'm personally not comfortable trading out keepers after 2 weeks.

Cash in bank is really important, a Hibberd to Shaw trade is worth about 90k. If & when Hibberd returns to his best then bring him in but he will be bleeding money over the next few weeks. 

[RaisyDaisy]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd isn't taking kick outs, will definitely hurt his scoring. Shaw is & we know how high his ceiling can be. In 3 weeks Shaw will be Hibberd's value, so we're looking at a 150k turnaround. That to me is worth a trade.

Findlayson showed today that he is the best kick in the GWS team in their defense. He is splitting the kick-ins with Shaw and I wouldn't be surprised if he started to take more given he is the long term option out of their defense and Shaw is in the back-end of his career.

Shaw's been great in the 2 games and definitely on my radar to bring into my side. I'm personally not comfortable trading out keepers after 2 weeks.

Cash in bank is really important, a Hibberd to Shaw trade is worth about 90k. If & when Hibberd returns to his best then bring him in but he will be bleeding money over the next few weeks.

Hibberd is picked as a keeper, so cash loss is irrelevant. We trade him out if we think he won't be Top 10

I'm looking at Hibberd to Shaw because I honestly don't know if Hibberd will be Top 5-10 based on his altered role.

It's definitely reactionary, I know that, and like AK said this week should be rookie corrections and LTI's but in hindsight I wish I didn't outlay 545k on Hibberd. I had Simpson and Shaw is most versions of my side all preseason which makes it sting even more

All it takes is a 95+ score next week and all will be forgiven that's what always happens

Shaw and Simmo are so much more proven though, and the extra cash is handy.

If English and Fogarty flop then there won't be a rookie I've missed, so I might use those correction trades put aside for rookies to correct prems instead

[Hazza09]

Potential trades that I am thinking about:

J Kelly - Oliver
Fyfe - Coniglio
Lobb - Sicily
Venables/Ryan - English

[RaisyDaisy]

Potential trades that I am thinking about:

J Kelly - Oliver
Fyfe - Coniglio
Lobb - Sicily

Lol

[kilbluff1985]

Rayner to English
Dow to Bonner if he does ok maybe or maybe Macpherson

[Bully]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd isn't taking kick outs, will definitely hurt his scoring. Shaw is & we know how high his ceiling can be. In 3 weeks Shaw will be Hibberd's value, so we're looking at a 150k turnaround. That to me is worth a trade.

Findlayson showed today that he is the best kick in the GWS team in their defense. He is splitting the kick-ins with Shaw and I wouldn't be surprised if he started to take more given he is the long term option out of their defense and Shaw is in the back-end of his career.

Shaw's been great in the 2 games and definitely on my radar to bring into my side. I'm personally not comfortable trading out keepers after 2 weeks.

Cash in bank is really important, a Hibberd to Shaw trade is worth about 90k. If & when Hibberd returns to his best then bring him in but he will be bleeding money over the next few weeks.

Hibberd is picked as a keeper, so cash loss is irrelevant. We trade him out if we think he won't be Top 10

I'm looking at Hibberd to Shaw because I honestly don't know if Hibberd will be Top 5-10 based on his altered role.

It's definitely reactionary, I know that, and like AK said this week should be rookie corrections and LTI's but in hindsight I wish I didn't outlay 545k on Hibberd. I had Simpson and Shaw is most versions of my side all preseason which makes it sting even more

All it takes is a 95+ score next week and all will be forgiven that's what always happens

Shaw and Simmo are so much more proven though, and the extra cash is handy.

If English and Fogarty flop then there won't be a rookie I've missed, so I might use those correction trades put aside for rookies to correct prems instead

Obviously his role comes into the equation, the kick outs are critical when assessing his worth. But back on Shaw, really liked his game today, the urgency was back again, something we didn't really see last year. The cash will also be very handy, just looking at some other options, Taranto may come into the frame for me, especially with Scully going down. Back to back tons has me interested. Could he be the Oliver of this year?

Fyfe - 70 (year 1), 110 (year 2)
Oliver - 70 (year 1), 111 (year 2)
Bont - 78 (year 1), 103 (year 2)
Selwood - 77 (year 1) 98 (year 2)
Dusty - 77 (year 1) 98 (year 2)

Can he make the jump? Former pick 2 who seems to be a permanent mid now, also plenty of defensive work & tackling. Thinking that at 365k he might be a solid bet given he could very well become a keeper. The more I think about it the more it makes sense.

[SilverLion]

Mcrouch --> Oliver

And pending English and Fogarty's performances...

Brayshaw --> Fogarty/English (via Garlett)

[igotworms]

Obviously his role comes into the equation, the kick outs are critical when assessing his worth. But back on Shaw, really liked his game today, the urgency was back again, something we didn't really see last year. The cash will also be very handy, just looking at some other options, Taranto may come into the frame for me, especially with Scully going down. Back to back tons has me interested. Could he be the Oliver of this year?

Fyfe - 70 (year 1), 110 (year 2)
Oliver - 70 (year 1), 111 (year 2)
Bont - 78 (year 1), 103 (year 2)
Selwood - 77 (year 1) 98 (year 2)
Dusty - 77 (year 1) 98 (year 2)

Can he make the jump? Former pick 2 who seems to be a permanent mid now, also plenty of defensive work & tackling. Thinking that at 365k he might be a solid bet given he could very well become a keeper. The more I think about it the more it makes sense.
[/quote]

I have him in my draft, but at that price am a little indecisive when it comes to classic! You are spot on though, playing a midfield role, excellent numbers and defensive pressure. Could be a great stepping stone......... possibly even a keeper!! Scully out may impact him even more positively too!! I'll be hovering the mouse over him over the next week that's for sure.

[SilverLion]

Obviously his role comes into the equation, the kick outs are critical when assessing his worth. But back on Shaw, really liked his game today, the urgency was back again, something we didn't really see last year. The cash will also be very handy, just looking at some other options, Taranto may come into the frame for me, especially with Scully going down. Back to back tons has me interested. Could he be the Oliver of this year?

Fyfe - 70 (year 1), 110 (year 2)
Oliver - 70 (year 1), 111 (year 2)
Bont - 78 (year 1), 103 (year 2)
Selwood - 77 (year 1) 98 (year 2)
Dusty - 77 (year 1) 98 (year 2)

Can he make the jump? Former pick 2 who seems to be a permanent mid now, also plenty of defensive work & tackling. Thinking that at 365k he might be a solid bet given he could very well become a keeper. The more I think about it the more it makes sense.

I have him in my draft, but at that price am a little indecisive when it comes to classic! You are spot on though, playing a midfield role, excellent numbers and defensive pressure. Could be a great stepping stone......... possibly even a keeper!! Scully out may impact him even more positively too!! I'll be hovering the mouse over him over the next week that's for sure.

Am considering him myself. Could be a bandaid Crouch replacement.

For me, on the field would look like this:

Taranto (F4, Christensen F5) + Holman (M8) + 250k in bank

Oliver (M3, Kelly M8) + Giles-Langdon (F5, Fritsch F6) + 15k in bank

[shaker]

Now I have done this weeks trades and have Danger back in my team I can look to next weeks , English will come in if he plays well again and gets a game the other could be a choice of a few , Greene is the main concern but will wait and see what unfolds with him and I really have to see what goes down with remaining rookies and O'Meara today.

[ubeaut]

Hibberd to Shaw is a terrible idea. Must have no other problems with your team if you are sideways trading premos after 2 weeks.

I have Hibberd and yes in hindsight would have kept Hurley but i'm going to stick with him for now.

I'd be sticking to correctional rookie trades and LTI's at this stage. If you picked Hibberd I don't see why you would be trading him after 2 weeks.

Hibberd is not taking many kick ins. Hard to see much improvement.
The same happened to Shaw last year and those that kept him week after week fruitlessly waiting for him to improve were much worse off than those who traded to Yeo/Hurley/Laird

[igotworms]

Tossing up between these two options:

Matt Crouch straight swap to either Oliver or Parker.
Matt Crouch down to Taranto which allows me to upgrade Naughton to Sicily! (Dependant upon Naughtons performance today)

Also, is it worth swapping Garlett to English for cash generation? Think Garlett might be a bit of a slow burn!