Round 3 Trades

[crowls]

Coniglio or Taranto + 87k?

both good choices,  dependin on how many rookies you are starting in mids and fwds.  fwd rookies are not scoring as well so good to have 5 solid options in place.  Also Taranto has good chance to be keeper or f7 later in the year.   

[tommy10]

who has better job security   L Fogarty Geelong or D Barry Port?
Have to downgrade Brayshaw to one of these for cash to upgrade to Dusty.

Who you upgrading to Dusty Crowls?

[petefisker]

Who to trade out Dunkley (BE 21 and liked him rd 1 87, rd 2 he couldn't find it as much) but he attends centre bounces and with libba out should make good coin or Brayshaw the overpriced rookie who isn't delivering.
Both are in place to make cash, but dunkley is on the field as fwd rookies are bad. So im not loosing anything by trading Brayshaw expect maybe 50-90k IF he comes good. Unsure, trading Brayshaw allows me to have zero rookies on field up forward.

[crowls]

who has better job security   L Fogarty Geelong or D Barry Port?
Have to downgrade Brayshaw to one of these for cash to upgrade to Dusty.

Who you upgrading to Dusty Crowls?

Bont is out,  too many sub 90 scores.  Dogs playing like dogs and bont not spending time on the ball.   Trade early and hard

[Hogan17]

Christensen + 100k vs Taranto is my bid headache! Thoughts appreciated!

[AaronKirk]

Christensen + 100k vs Taranto is my bid headache! Thoughts appreciated!

Bundy has a -10 BE after scoring a ton. Would not be trading him at this stage. Look to upgrade one of your rookies to Taranto if you like him.

[crowls]

Christensen + 100k vs Taranto is my bid headache! Thoughts appreciated!

coin flip.  both capable of f6/7

[tkringle]

Thinking to keep Hibberd for now and trust he will come good.

Considering the following:

* Lobb to D Smith
Smith looks like a potential keeper and should provide a more consistent return if he keeps playing midfield and only costs an extra ~40K. Lobb may even lose money this week with a BE of 78.. I don’t trust Lobb after watching his first two famed so see this as a failed mid pricer to potential keeper trade

* Brayshaw to Ryan (via Garlett DPP)
Whilst Brayshaw has great JS, so do a lot of other rookies, he is riding the bench for me at the moment with Kelly and Holman starting.
If he stays on a 60 average it will take him till round 10 to make $100K. Ryan will make more than that in the next two rounds + the 80K price saving. Also opens up DPP mid-fwd for me.

Thoughts?

[RaisyDaisy]

Christensen + 100k vs Taranto is my bid headache! Thoughts appreciated!

Bundy has a -10 BE after scoring a ton. Would not be trading him at this stage. Look to upgrade one of your rookies to Taranto if you like him.

I don't think he is looking to trade Bundy - sounds like he is trying to decide who to pick out of the two

Tough decision. Depends on how much that 100k will do for you I guess.

[Jalapeno]

Hey Guys! Need some advice please...

Caddy and Arma >> Z Fisher and Coniglio

Or

Caddy and Fogarty >> Taranto and Liam Ryan

Thanks in advance

[SilverLion]

Hey Guys! Need some advice please...

Caddy and Arma >> Z Fisher and Coniglio

Or

Caddy and Fogarty >> Taranto and Liam Ryan

Thanks in advance

Bit of mid price madness there mate.

Fogarty --> Ryan would be one move definitely.

Either hold Caddy or go up to a Petracca/Smith/Walters/McLean type if you can afford it.

[Dir Goose]

What would be the better option?

Option 1: Sicily - Bonner + ZGL - Fisher

Option 2: Bont - Coniglio + ZGL  - Fisher

Option 3: Bont - Coniglio + Naughton - Bonner

Fisher becomes F6
Bonner becomes D3 option 1 and D4 option 3
Coniglio M5

[jvalles69]

Decided on 2 trades that I'm happy with and don't feel like its a waste.

1. Bont -> Simmo via Finlayson DPP
2. Langdon -> Bonner via Sicily DPP

Happy with my team so happy to make Danger my next upgrade rather than sacrifice for him, and don't want to sit on dead cash in Langdon.  Leaves with this team:

Def: Laird, Simpson, Lloyd, Seedsman, Bonner Doedee (Murray, Naughton)
Mid: Titch, Dusty, Parker, Fyfe, Coniglio, Kelly, Holman, Finlayson (Brayshaw, Banfield, Barry)
Ruc: Gawn, Goldy (Olango)
For: Buddy, Billings, Smith, Sicily, Lobb, Fritsch (Ryan, Venables)

I feel this maximises my cash generation as well as allowing me to put up solid scores.  Hoping Keefe can get into best 22 so I can swing him with Sicily.  Prob won't use any more trades until LTI's or cows are fat.

[Hogan17]

Christensen + 100k vs Taranto is my bid headache! Thoughts appreciated!

Bundy has a -10 BE after scoring a ton. Would not be trading him at this stage. Look to upgrade one of your rookies to Taranto if you like him.

I don't think he is looking to trade Bundy - sounds like he is trying to decide who to pick out of the two

Tough decision. Depends on how much that 100k will do for you I guess.

I think from the general feel of what ppl are thinking is that Taranto has a better chance at being a keeper. I'd rather pay that extra then for a non keeper or f7.

Cheers for your thoughts fellas!

[Samsturmfels]

What would be the better option?

Option 1: Sicily - Bonner + ZGL - Fisher

Option 2: Bont - Coniglio + ZGL  - Fisher

Option 3: Bont - Coniglio + Naughton - Bonner

Fisher becomes F6
Bonner becomes D3 option 1 and D4 option 3
Coniglio M5

id  go bont to coniglio and maybe ZGL to fisher