MRP Findings 2018

[Ricochet]

That's pretty average, Buddy should be out for a week and I have him in my SC.

MRO overstepping his bounds by electing to call Buddy's intentional strike as 'misconduct'. It's striking, so it should be a week.

Tend to agree. Thought it'd be a week

[enzedder]

That's pretty average, Buddy should be out for a week and I have him in my SC.

MRO overstepping his bounds by electing to call Buddy's intentional strike as 'misconduct'. It's striking, so it should be a week.

Tend to agree. Thought it'd be a week

Very lucky not to be suspended. Thought he'd cop a week as well.

[RaisyDaisy]

All this talk about Bud, reckon Vlastuin got off easy flying an elbow like that and flushing Parker in the eye

[Chrispy75]

That's pretty average, Buddy should be out for a week and I have him in my SC.

MRO overstepping his bounds by electing to call Buddy's intentional strike as 'misconduct'. It's striking, so it should be a week.

Tend to agree. Thought it'd be a week

Very lucky not to be suspended. Thought he'd cop a week as well.

Wonder if the AFL will consider appealing the decision as they have done with other cases in recent history (Curnow, Houli).

[Gandalf123]

Geez you lot are out for a blokes head for an open palm push that happens 10 times a game, what vlastuin did was far worse and only gets 1, no way buddy gets a week

[Trindacut]

Geez you lot are out for a blokes head for an open palm push that happens 10 times a game, what vlastuin did was far worse and only gets 1, no way buddy gets a week

There are players getting a week for open hand strikes to the body. Buddy strikes (not push) a guys throat and gets a fine. You must be a Sydney supporter.

Think vlastain's week is fair enough, it was low impact

[shaker]

Geez you lot are out for a blokes head for an open palm push that happens 10 times a game, what vlastuin did was far worse and only gets 1, no way buddy gets a week

Ha ha coming from a Sydney supporter Buddy always gets off  ::)

[jvalles69]

Menegola's tackle being looked at?  In the instant I saw it, I thought of Nic Nat's tackle straight away.

[Deadly6]

Menegola's tackle being looked at?  In the instant I saw it, I thought of Nic Nat's tackle straight away.

Tackle cleared - no rotation, sling, pile drive

[SilverLion]

Oliver in trouble for a dangerous tackle apparently?

[RaisyDaisy]

Oliver in trouble for a dangerous tackle apparently?

I reckon it was fine. Would be shocked if he was suspended

[GoLions]

Oliver in trouble for a dangerous tackle apparently?

I reckon it was fine. Would be shocked if he was suspended

Same

[Ricochet]

Oliver in trouble for a dangerous tackle apparently?

Just traded him in for Treloar so guaranteed he'll get weeks :-X

[Trindacut]

I really don't understand how Buddy Franklin and Jack Steele got off. It's a vastly different interpretation, which today was justified by saying it was below the threshold to be a low impact.

I still can't get over Nic Nat's ban, apparently niether can the rest of the AFL supporter base that took part in the survey (75% disagreed with the finding).

I really want this MRO system to work, and I avoid being a doomspeaker but I've lost a bit of faith in the system after seeing the rules implemented with different interpretations.

[shaker]

Tex appealing his $1500 fine can't comment because have not seen it but will laugh if he cops the full $2500 , must be short of a bob or just a tightarse  ;D