MRP Findings 2018

Started by Ricochet, March 24, 2018, 03:59:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Trindacut


Ringo

Cameron only 5 weeks BS. Takes a player out who may not play till next season. Know Biased but these days the MRP seems to be afraid of dishing out long sentences. Although it was his last game remember to the 2004 final where Lynch had a big go at Wakelin and received 13 weeks, We do not see that now.

Holz

5 weeks seems slightly harsh but fair enough

pretty clear to me he recklessly protected himself not thinking of the damage he was doing to another person.

I dont understand people calling for more though. Barry Hall got 7 for blatantly punching a guy not while a play was going on.


Ringo

Quote from: Holz on June 27, 2018, 12:31:33 PM
5 weeks seems slightly harsh but fair enough

pretty clear to me he recklessly protected himself not thinking of the damage he was doing to another person.

I dont understand people calling for more though. Barry Hall got 7 for blatantly punching a guy not while a play was going on.
I was expecting 6 given the incident was very similar to Buggs to be fair.

Trindacut

Quote from: Ringo on June 27, 2018, 01:59:37 PM
Quote from: Holz on June 27, 2018, 12:31:33 PM
5 weeks seems slightly harsh but fair enough

pretty clear to me he recklessly protected himself not thinking of the damage he was doing to another person.

I dont understand people calling for more though. Barry Hall got 7 for blatantly punching a guy not while a play was going on.
I was expecting 6 given the incident was very similar to Buggs to be fair.

I thought 6 too actually, and thought that 'bleeding on the brain' would get it there. 5 isn't bad, Andrews may be back in two weeks.

RaisyDaisy

Vlastuin will have a holiday

fanTCfool

Probably 1-2 weeks depending on the medical report from the Swans.

Ricochet

Buddy will get looked at as well

jvalles69


shaker


RaisyDaisy

Buddy fined

Vlas offered 1 week

SilverLion


Trindacut

#297
That's pretty average, Buddy should be out for a week and I have him in my SC.

MRO overstepping his bounds by electing to call Buddy's intentional strike as 'misconduct'. It's striking, so it should be a week.

Ringo

Quote from: Trindacut on June 29, 2018, 06:47:49 PM
That's pretty average, Buddy should be out for a week and I have him in my SC.

MRO overstepping his bounds by electing to call Buddy's intentional strike as 'misconduct'. It's striking, so it should be a week.
Yep More inconsistencies from MRO definitely a deliberate act and should have been intentional low impact 1 week same as Vlas.

shaker

Quote from: Ringo on June 29, 2018, 07:46:51 PM
Quote from: Trindacut on June 29, 2018, 06:47:49 PM
That's pretty average, Buddy should be out for a week and I have him in my SC.

MRO overstepping his bounds by electing to call Buddy's intentional strike as 'misconduct'. It's striking, so it should be a week.
Yep More inconsistencies from MRO definitely a deliberate act and should have been intentional low impact 1 week same as Vlas.
If Buddy did what Cameron did he would only get a week  ::)