MRP Findings 2018

[crowls]

Geez Carlisle looks steep to me.    Looked like he was going for the ball to me.  Not his fault Jack has a egg shell noggin.

[Gigantor]

Geez Carlisle looks steep to me.    Looked like he was going for the ball to me.  Not his fault Jack has a egg shell noggin.

If the Saint's had got the win I reckon 2 weeks would have been worth it haha

[Ringo]

Jake Carlisle can accept 2 games, striking J Riewoldt.

Dustin Martin can accept $1500 sanction, misconduct against J Webster.
Devon Smith can accept $2000 sanction, rough conduct against Z Langdon.
Darcy Gardiner can accept $1500 sanction, misconduct against W Hayward.
Shane Edwards can accept $3000 sanction, striking H Clark.
Jack Steven can accept $1000 sanction, careless conduct umpire D Margetts.
Brennan Cox can accept $2000 sanction, rough conduct against S Higgins.
Willie Rioli can accept $1500 sanction for misconduct against B Hardwick & $1000 sanction for careless contact with umpire R Chamberlain.
Dylan Buckley can accept $1500 sanction, misconduct against M Guelfi.
Bailey Banfield can accept $1500 sanction, misconduct against S Higgins.

In my opinion Buckley extremely lucky with a fine. And Rioli pat on Chamberlain was deliberate not careless so again we see inconsistency with this one man MRP.

Lighten up. A pat on the rump for $1000!

How much would Razor Ray charge to go ‘all the way’?

Doc just trying to point out how ridiculous the touching the umpire rules are - Classed as careless but was deliberate in my eyes. In my opinion only deliberate intimidation of an umpire should result in suspension, especially with umpires now not signalling which way they are backing out.

[Ringo]

JUST IN: Jake Carlisle’s two-match suspension for striking Jack Riewoldt has been upheld by the AFL Tribunal.

[sammy123]

Sinclair got a fine for his dive. Lets seenif rance gets one now.

[SilverLion]

Saw the Robbo incident live, reckon it'll be thrown out, Hartung flopped. Simpkin could get a week for the bump on Christensen though.

[Bully]

Fyfe gone I reckon.

[enzedder]

Fyfe gone I reckon.

[Daicos.]

Fyfe gone I reckon.

Didn't think there was much in it as a Pies fan.

[RaisyDaisy]

Just got to watch the footage

I reckon he gets a fine only

[sammy123]

Just saw the footage of fyfe. I think its a fine but i reckon one man mrp gives him week

[Ringo]

Just saw the footage of fyfe. I think its a fine but i reckon one man mrp gives him week

Yep even with a one man MRP it is still a lottery. Think we are still seeing the inconsistencies this one man MRP was supposed to reduce.

[iZander]

no way they cost him another brownlow with that

[Bully]

no way they cost him another brownlow with that

That's what they said about Danger.

[tommy10]

no way they cost him another brownlow with that

That's what they said about Danger.

That’s because they knew Dusty was going to win it anyway  :P