Your thoughts would be appreciated

Started by GtownFan, March 20, 2018, 08:10:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

GtownFan

Am i spreading myself too much or could it work ?



ubeaut

Could work. Especially if Petracca and Sicily work out. I'm always impressed at a team that manages to fit 15 possible keepers in.
Obvious weakness is mids with no Danger and Conigs and Libba at M5-6.
Fwds,backs and rucks look great.
I guess Titch amd Fyfe would be your captain options?

GtownFan

I'd say they would be my only 2 options atm,

thanks for the critique, i suppose i'm banking on a couple mid priced guys being the key at the start but hopefully with 30k in the bank i'm hopeful i could get a cheap upgrade if things dont work out

PowerBug

Coffield and Naughton are too very good rookies you don't own. Feels like you've gone too hard trying to find 16 possible keepers when if it all blow up in your face you could be left with 8 (First 2 in each line). On the flip side it could all work out for you so if you really like it then go with your own feel :)

I'd suggest dropping one of those guys in the bottom 8 of your 16 to a rookie, then look at getting the better rookies. Don't think Murphy will start seeing as the Crows announced debutantes today, also Keefe is no lock to play either.
Leader of the King Karl Amon fan club
Coach of WXV side Rio De Janeiro Jaguars
2023 SC: Rank 126

stevolen23

Fogarty could be a risk, cause when tex comes back he could replace him. But i've actually gone with fogarty at f5 too.

GtownFan

I like your thinking , i suppose there needs to be room to move into premiums , my only problem is that Coffield and Naughton are in positions where i'm happy with the line , petracca would be the sacrifise i would make but the shuffle would involve Sicily going forward to allow both of them in , i guess the decisions would come down to Smith or Petracca making room for them

Ringo

With Fogarty the one likely to make way when Tex returns which will before Rd 3 so he may not make cash.  I would downgrade him to Giles-Langdon, Waterman or Rioli or other forward named Rd 1. With JJK undergoing surgery JS should be there for Eagles. Then if cash allows would upgrade Murphy to Naughton or Coffield your choice. No real need for both although a lot of teams are going with both, Basically your decvision will be will Petracca/Smith become keepers saving a trade or do i need to downgrade to a rookie to make cash for upgrades,

GtownFan

Thanks Ringo, that got Naughton in with 2.9k left , would of preferred Coffied with dpp but allowed me to keep Sicily , i did try and take  him out out which allowed to get Coffield and Naughten down back and allowed for Liba to be upgraded to Gazza , but this might be better


cuz_crew

one of the stronger teams I've seen here. You should do well this season.

I'm liking the Savage, Liber and Billings picks.

Money Shot

I also really like this team with some underpriced premium mids allowing you too bolster other lines.

No Danger/Dusty is a risk though.