Thoughts appreciated guys

Started by ando_10, March 11, 2018, 07:41:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ando_10

Now i know i have no Danger but this is just trialling the side without him due to his injury

Backs: Laird Hibberd Simpson Sicily O Shea Doedee,
Emg: Murray Mirra

Mids: Dusty Titch Kelly(GWS) Duncan Coniglio And.Brayshaw Dow Kelly (GEE)
Emg: Holman Barry Worpel

Rucks: Ryder Gawn
Emg: Cameron

Fwd: Heeney Billings Smith Bell Christensen Keefe
Emg: Garlett Ryan

37k left

ando_10

must be too good to comment on ;)

Bully

Rookies might need adjusting, Mirra, O'Shea, Worpel, Barry & Keeffe would be doubtful IMO.

dmac07

Def - Like the structure, only player I wouldn't be sold on is Simpson. Oshea/Naughton are interchangeable on whos named. Finlayson seems like a lock of a rookie and don't think Mirra will get a game.

Mids - First three really solid, like Kelly as a slightly more unique. Duncan priced at 600k though I just can't come at despite his consistent scoring last year. Merrett, Crouch, Bont or Cripps for someone cheaper all better. Rookies good.

Ruck - Good

Fwd - Having all of Smith, Bell, Christensen is risky but could pay off well! Missing Fritsch who seems a must have rookie but that's east changed.

Overall, really like the structure of this team. Only change id make is Duncan > Cripps and Smith > Greene/Walters/Dahl, and probably Mirra to a Naughton or Finlayson.

HoleMeal

Quote from: ando_10 on March 11, 2018, 07:41:00 PM
Now i know i have no Danger but this is just trialling the side without him due to his injury

Backs: Laird Hibberd Simpson Sicily O Shea Doedee,
Emg: Murray Mirra

Mids: Dusty Titch Kelly(GWS) Duncan Coniglio And.Brayshaw Dow Kelly (GEE)
Emg: Holman Barry Worpel

Rucks: Ryder Gawn
Emg: Cameron

Fwd: Heeney Billings Smith Bell Christensen Keefe
Emg: Garlett Ryan

37k left

Potentially 14 keepers is a good start!
Don't like Duncan, more value in Fyfe or Neale.
Would swap Garlett for Fritsch.

Other than that you could sit on this til Rnd 1 teams come out.

Ringo

The benefit of a forum where we can agree to disagree.

Do not mind the Duncan pick as a POD. In JLT has showed he is carrying on from last year where he averaged 120 from his last 7 games. Great alternative for Danger.

Fritsch looks being a must as a forward rookie making money.

Only concern is Ryder with Rd 10 bye and Cameron maybe shaky as a replacement.

ando_10

UPDATE

B: Laird Hibberd Simpson Naughton Murray Doedee
Emg: Finlayson Murphy

M: Dangerfield Dusty Titch Z.Merrett Coniglio Brayshaw (freo) Dow Kelly (Geel)
Emg: Barry Holman Banfield

R: Martin Gawn
Emg: Cameron

F: Heeney Billings Smith Sicily Christensen Fritsch
Emg: Waterman Ryan

100k in the bank

Bully

I like it, the only suggestion would be Dow to Garlett (get your midfield link) & Bundy up to Lobb.

ando_10

Quote from: Bully on March 21, 2018, 06:49:35 PM
I like it, the only suggestion would be Dow to Garlett (get your midfield link) & Bundy up to Lobb.
is lobb going to play though? he is very underdone

Bully

Quote from: ando_10 on March 21, 2018, 06:56:29 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 21, 2018, 06:49:35 PM
I like it, the only suggestion would be Dow to Garlett (get your midfield link) & Bundy up to Lobb.
is lobb going to play though? he is very underdone

We'll soon find out but if named he'll be hard to pass. Solo ruck in an A grade midfield = plenty of points.

crowls

Very nice team Ando.  Bit thin in the mids with coniglio M5,  he might make m8/9, though see cripps, bont better options.