Insert Witty Name 2018

Sven · March 10, 2018, 05:58:53 PM

Hey all!

Looking for any and all help for season 2018!

Haven't done the research I would have liked this season....but I feel like my 23,102nd draft is looking okay. So, without further ado!

Happy with the premos, hoping Sicily and Smith live up to their respected hypes, and rookies all look good (so far). Feels very vanilla at the moment, thats my only issue.

Love to hear any and all thoughts! Thanks and happy Supercoaching! :D

Samsturmfels · March 10, 2018, 10:58:00 PM

Nice team, not a bad structure. If i were you id move coffield to the backline and trade naughton to brayshaw

rodneycc · March 10, 2018, 10:58:29 PM

I dont mind this team one bit. The first I have seen with the balls not to pick Danger ( and putting it to good effect). It could pay off bigtime with a few question marks. New aflpa role, baby duty, Ablett, you know could work.

Changes Id make would be possibly be Nank, Goldstein or Jacobs for Lycett (you have one risky play, dont see why you would double down with two risky moves).

Franklin to maybe Billings but I don't mind Buddy either. And Im not sold on LDU.

But yeah why not no Danger, Go for it.

Edit: btw I have Danger, I haven't got the stones!

ubeaut · March 11, 2018, 10:09:36 AM

Quote from: Sven on March 10, 2018, 05:58:53 PM
Hey all!

Looking for any and all help for season 2018!

Haven't done the research I would have liked this season....but I feel like my 23,102nd draft is looking okay. So, without further ado!

Happy with the premos, hoping Sicily and Smith live up to their respected hypes, and rookies all look good (so far). Feels very vanilla at the moment, thats my only issue.

Love to hear any and all thoughts! Thanks and happy Supercoaching! :D

I feel that with Lycett your mids should be stronger. Fwds and backs very strong, but I'd drop a fwd premo, move Sicily fwd and get another back rookie as there are more back than fwd rookies atm.
Then use cash to get another mid. No Danger is fine but u need another premo mid to compensate who will outscore any fwd premo.

Sven · March 18, 2018, 09:48:43 PM

Thanks ubeaut, rodneycc and Samsturmfels for your feedback! :D

Version 45,193 now, and I think its more well balanced guns and rookies (except one) side. Forward line is my only concern, but it was LDU + D Smith or Coniglio + Rayner. Easy choice.

Love to hear any and all feedback, getting close now!!! Thanks again and happy Supercoaching! :)

Sven · March 19, 2018, 09:29:29 PM

Looking for any and all feedback! :D

PureSwag · March 19, 2018, 09:48:11 PM

1. Holemen needs to be and stay on bench, to unknown to take the field just yet
2. Franklin every year is a risk as his a key forward but a key forward that scores, as a safer option maybe Heeney.
3. Rayner just isn't going to be good enough at his 200k value but could be wrong just my opionion.

Sven · March 20, 2018, 12:01:41 AM

Quote from: PureSwag on March 19, 2018, 09:48:11 PM
1. Holemen needs to be and stay on bench, to unknown to take the field just yet
2. Franklin every year is a risk as his a key forward but a key forward that scores, as a safer option maybe Heeney.
3. Rayner just isn't going to be good enough at his 200k value but could be wrong just my opionion.

Thanks for checking our my team PureSwag and your feedback!

1. Only reason Holman is on the field is as a rookie placeholder until teams are named.
2. Franklin is Franklin, but Franklin's ceiling is much higher than Heeneys and he's in for another big year.
3. Yeah, but there's little other option, who would replace him? Only got $4,600 left... :/

greco272 · March 20, 2018, 12:10:34 AM

You could downgrade Green to D. Smith as they will play the same role and Smith might even get more midfield time.

Then use your money to upgrade Rayner to Christensen or even Rioli.

Overall your team is very nice. Just be careful with the FWD rookies as they are always the first dropped from any team. Sometimes its better to pay for job security than points.

Cheers

Money Shot · March 20, 2018, 12:35:42 AM

agree. Rayner to bundy needs to happen:

Ringo · March 20, 2018, 04:11:38 PM

Do you have a plan for Danger if he starts as i think he needs to be in team if he does.

Regarding team

Franklin will invaraiably get cheaper during the season as he turns in the inevitable stinker so would consider a downgrade to Heeney, Dahlhus or Macrae.
Greene is an inigma and if cash needed would look at downgrading to Devon Smith.
And at 202k Rayner will be a very slow burn as he will spend most of his time half forward so will not be a prolific scorer either so would upgrade him to Bundy if you have the cash.

Apart from those suggestions nice team.