JLT Player Discussion

[SilverLion]

I backed in Cogs to be this year's Murphy months ago. Should easily get 100-105+, perfect for M8/9.

Now everyone's gunna have him :P

[Pepi]

I swear Heath Shaw does this tome every year  :'(

[Ringo]

Sidearse may be a better proposition than Pendles although no treloar so maybe watch JLT2.

[SilverLion]

I swear Heath Shaw does this tome every year  :'(

Said it in the game comments on the FF match centre, I can't see Shaw returning to his 2016 form with Whitfield playing HB. Wouldn't take anything out of tonight's scores for either of them SC wise, but would keep in mind that Whitfield will likely be playing Williams' role.

[quinny88]

I swear Heath Shaw does this tome every year  :'(

Said it in the game comments on the FF match centre, I can't see Shaw returning to his 2016 form with Whitfield playing HB. Wouldn't take anything out of tonight's scores for either of them SC wise, but would keep in mind that Whitfield will likely be playing Williams' role.

Leon Cameroon interview at half time Saying Shaw will play on the wing this year. Don't know if that's good or bad

[Ringo]

SC Scores:

GIANTS
Stephen Coniglio 130
Josh Kelly 127
Dylan Shiel 124
Heath Shaw 114
Callan Ward 92
Lachie Whitfield 91
Daniel Lloyd 88
Jeremy Finlayson 86
Dawson Simpson 83
Matthew de Boer 72
Lachlan Tiziani 69
Jeremy Cameron 68
Tim Taranto 68
Sam J. Reid 66
Phil Davis 65
Adam Tomlinson 65
Harry Perryman 61
Nicholas Shipley 60
Harry Himmelberg 59
Jonathon Patton 52
Zac Giles-Langdon 45
Lachlan Keeffe 44
Tim Mohr 41
Matthew Flynn 19

COLLINGWOOD
Tom Langdon 115
Will Hoskin-Elliott 112
Josh Thomas 109
Brodie Grundy 104
Steele Sidebottom 102
Taylor Adams 92
Jack Crisp 83
Tyson Goldsack 77
Tom Phillips 73
Mason Cox 66
Callum Brown 65
Scott Pendlebury 61
Brayden Maynard 60
Ben Reid 55
Brody Mihocek 50
Travis Varcoe 49
Josh Smith 49
Jaidyn Stephenson 48
Lynden Dunn 46
Tim Broomhead 43
Flynn Appleby 34
Adam Oxley 12
Chris Mayne 8

[quinny88]

Finlayson looked like a 200 game player

[quinny88]

Sidearse may be a better proposition than Pendles although no treloar so maybe watch JLT2.

Pendles wasn't even interested. Wouldn't look into that at all

[Daicos.]

Not one of the Pies players I was interested in impressed me, on the plus side, Coniglio from a lock went to an absolute lock, not moving.

[Ringo]

Sidearse may be a better proposition than Pendles although no treloar so maybe watch JLT2.

Pendles wasn't even interested. Wouldn't look into that at all

Thanks Quinny only following the stats. with no foxtel.
Agree on Finlayson looks like another defensive lock with Doedee.

[LordSneeze]

Every year people follow the scores. Every year people get burnt when the season starts.
Alot of prems take these as match fitness preparation, while players needing to impress go all out. Its more about roles, structure, movements and rookies feel at the level.

[quinny88]

Sidearse may be a better proposition than Pendles although no treloar so maybe watch JLT2.

Pendles wasn't even interested. Wouldn't look into that at all

Thanks Quinny only following the stats. with no foxtel.
Agree on Finlayson looks like another defensive lock with Doedee.

Yeah Pendles honestly didn't look interested, particularly in the first half. Seemed a bit more urgent after half time.

Yeah loved the look of Finlayson. Reads the play really well

[quinny88]

Intersting that Dawson Simpson scored 83 with only 11 hitouts. If Lobb was to have a set back and need to miss a large chunk of footy he could be a serious consideration

[RaisyDaisy]

LOL this happens every single year, and I'm surprised that people continue to fall for this

A proven prem is a proven prem - don't let their preseason scores have any impact on your thoughts

Rookies, players returning from LTI and to a lesser extent positional changes (which even then can only be taken with a grain of salt) is what you should be looking for now, and that's it

[AaronKirk]

D5-D7 starting to take shape ok. Another 1 or 2 1/2 decent defensive rookie options and we will be looking ok there.

Forward bench rookies hmm......

I put Heater in my side prior to the game tonight to suit my byes better - won't be leaving at this stage.

If I need a cheap mid option to use cash elsewhere than Conigs is my man I think.