James Sicily

[elephants]

https://twitter.com/Bryceltics/status/988317826497757184

The footage

That is the softest thing I've ever seen, his foot is still on an angle as he walks over Atley. They call this serious but it's ok to bump someone into the fence. Sounds to me like they are hunting Siciliy, now that Dusty is off limits they need a new bad boy.

Cheap shot that was unecessary and off the ball.

Whats your argument its ok to lightly step on a guy on the ground

Why is this not in the misconduct category? Compared to some of the other incidents I've seen this is pathetic. Mitchell threw an elbow at Goldy's head & got off, this is fine material.

This is different, Mitchell slipped high. He's not dumb enough to throw an elbow at the opposition ruckman when he's a brownlow shout. It was a glancing blow at worst and even Goldy said there was absolutely nothing in it

Sic is a flog, stepping on a player on the ground and then running away is just the tip of the iceberg. Should get 2-3, its an awful look for the game. Can't have kids around the country thinking that stepping on a player while they're on the ground is okay

2-3? You have to be joking.  :o

Convince me otherwise? Off the ball, unnatural football act, the list goes on. Don't let the fact he's in your fantasy teams cloud your judgement

You can still see the underside of his shoe as he walks over, intentional maybe but low impact. No way 2-3 weeks.

Is that grading system even relevant when an incident has been sent straight to the tribunal classed as "serious misconduct"

[shaker]

You don't get a fine when you get sent to the tribunal Christian was just on the news and did not seems at all amused with it , said it was a dangerous action that could cause injury he's gone 2 minimum my guess

[tommy10]

https://twitter.com/Bryceltics/status/988317826497757184

The footage

That is the softest thing I've ever seen, his foot is still on an angle as he walks over Atley. They call this serious but it's ok to bump someone into the fence. Sounds to me like they are hunting Siciliy, now that Dusty is off limits they need a new bad boy.

Cheap shot that was unecessary and off the ball.

Whats your argument its ok to lightly step on a guy on the ground

Why is this not in the misconduct category? Compared to some of the other incidents I've seen this is pathetic. Mitchell threw an elbow at Goldy's head & got off, this is fine material.

This is different, Mitchell slipped high. He's not dumb enough to throw an elbow at the opposition ruckman when he's a brownlow shout. It was a glancing blow at worst and even Goldy said there was absolutely nothing in it

Sic is a flog, stepping on a player on the ground and then running away is just the tip of the iceberg. Should get 2-3, its an awful look for the game. Can't have kids around the country thinking that stepping on a player while they're on the ground is okay

2-3? You have to be joking.  :o

Convince me otherwise? Off the ball, unnatural football act, the list goes on. Don't let the fact he's in your fantasy teams cloud your judgement

You can still see the underside of his shoe as he walks over, intentional maybe but low impact. No way 2-3 weeks.

I reckon he’ll get 2, already suspended in round 2 so that doesn’t look good. With Fritsch out, was thinking of bringing him in but prob just upgrade Bundy instead

[elephants]

https://twitter.com/Bryceltics/status/988317826497757184

The footage

That is the softest thing I've ever seen, his foot is still on an angle as he walks over Atley. They call this serious but it's ok to bump someone into the fence. Sounds to me like they are hunting Siciliy, now that Dusty is off limits they need a new bad boy.

Cheap shot that was unecessary and off the ball.

Whats your argument its ok to lightly step on a guy on the ground

Why is this not in the misconduct category? Compared to some of the other incidents I've seen this is pathetic. Mitchell threw an elbow at Goldy's head & got off, this is fine material.

This is different, Mitchell slipped high. He's not dumb enough to throw an elbow at the opposition ruckman when he's a brownlow shout. It was a glancing blow at worst and even Goldy said there was absolutely nothing in it

Sic is a flog, stepping on a player on the ground and then running away is just the tip of the iceberg. Should get 2-3, its an awful look for the game. Can't have kids around the country thinking that stepping on a player while they're on the ground is okay

2-3? You have to be joking.  :o

Convince me otherwise? Off the ball, unnatural football act, the list goes on. Don't let the fact he's in your fantasy teams cloud your judgement

Dont let sicily being a flog cloud your judgement, far more dangerous to forcefully push someone into the fence. While its a terrible look its not gonna cause a heap of harm, which seems to be all people care about, not the actual intention of the act for some strange reason.

Strongly disagree there man. Check out the Dickson/McKenna incident. Didn't even draw blood yet McKenna will spend 3 weeks on the sidelines for the bite.

[Belegur]

I've got Sic and backed him up on the last incident which I still think was ok, but this.. if they gave out weeks for stupidity would be right up there with ball tampering. There's cameras everywhere what the hell is he thinking. In isolation there's not much in it but this is where the MRP has been getting it wrong for years now. Injury is irrelevant, needs to be graded on intent of the action, he has only one intent here and that is to injure, no place for this on a football field, just lucky the act itself is pretty benign.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm flowering done with this season

[zoomba23]

Gotta be the most frustrating player I've ever had in my team. He keeps being stupid, why can't Clarko hurry up and belt him. So unnecessary. If it's 2 weeks or more he's out. Buggered if I know who for, but he's out.

[Mongoose528]

Your flowering kidding me.

[SilverLion]

Toby Greene has met his match.

He'll get week(s) because of a bad record.

Impact would be less than low given no injury reports whatsoever from North. Won't be adjudicated that way though as it was unsportsmanlike, so it'll be interesting to see what they say.

My guess is 1-2. Though because it's Sicily, 3-4 is more likely.

[crowls]

If he's rubbed out I'm keeping, hopefully only 2 weeks.

2 weeks,  have you seen the video Bully?    Sort of light pressure as he puts his weight on his other leg.  Total BS should have been a find and get on with it.   
Not trading Sicily. Can imagine Clarko having a friendly "wtf were you thinking Son" chat with him.    or more like, turn the brain on you stupid red headed moron.

[Bully]

If he's rubbed out I'm keeping, hopefully only 2 weeks.

2 weeks,  have you seen the video Bully?    Sort of light pressure as he puts his weight on his other leg.  Total BS should have been a find and get on with it.   
Not trading Sicily. Can imagine Clarko having a friendly "wtf were you thinking Son" chat with him.    or more like, turn the brain on you stupid red headed moron.

Have seen it & reckon it's soft in the extreme, should be a fine. If he firmly planted his foot into the calf then fair enough, from that video you'd be struggling to even confirm contact.

[Toga]

If it's serious misconduct and straight to the tribunal then I would assume he's gonna cop more than a fine.

Fairly low force but it's not a good look, and not something the MRO will be happy to let go.

[Toga]

Impact would be less than low given no injury reports whatsoever from North.

Pretty sure there was a medical report from North - probably what drew attention to it.

[Gandalf123]

I like him

[zoomba23]

If he's rubbed out I'm keeping, hopefully only 2 weeks.

2 weeks,  have you seen the video Bully?    Sort of light pressure as he puts his weight on his other leg.  Total BS should have been a find and get on with it.   
Not trading Sicily. Can imagine Clarko having a friendly "wtf were you thinking Son" chat with him.    or more like, turn the brain on you stupid red headed moron.

Have seen it & reckon it's soft in the extreme, should be a fine. If he firmly planted his foot into the calf then fair enough, from that video you'd be struggling to even confirm contact.

Guaranteed suspension, like the optimism though. Not a good look for the game, and can't have red headed flogs walking around standing on their opponents. Christian ain't amused, will probably be 2 weeks. 3 if Christian's in a really narky mood and feels like a bit of vengeance.