Player X vs. Player Y

Started by SilverLion, January 20, 2018, 10:20:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

strikeforce

Quote from: Ringo on July 12, 2018, 03:12:50 PM
Quote from: Ricochet on July 12, 2018, 12:58:35 PM
Quote from: strikeforce on July 12, 2018, 12:50:10 PM
Pendles vs Higgins vs Duncan vs Jelwood vs Gazza

Leaning towards Gazza or Duncan.

Duncan is a flat track bully against the lower teams and Gazza is gonna perform strong for the run home. All this criticism and the cats going for a finals berth. He will lift
Pendles imo. Durable, consistent and proven
Similar question but Would you still take Pendles over Beams or Oliver.

I would take oliver. Got him already. Beams is a interesing one. Surely one injury and he is on ice for the remainder of the season.

Its really down to POD Duncan vs Beams vs Pendles?

shaker

Crouch V Oliver ?
Crouch doesn't seemed to get tagged , seems to play better with Sloane back which will also be a huge lift for the Crows with him staying.
Oliver can pump out the big scores but doesn't handle a tag that good , after this week have Cats , Crows , WC away in there draw plus Sydney who tag and even this week could get Dunkley who shut Mitchell out last week.
Who is the best pick?

ubeaut

Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 03:43:04 PM
Crouch V Oliver ?
Crouch doesn't seemed to get tagged , seems to play better with Sloane back which will also be a huge lift for the Crows with him staying.
Oliver can pump out the big scores but doesn't handle a tag that good , after this week have Cats , Crows , WC away in there draw plus Sydney who tag and even this week could get Dunkley who shut Mitchell out last week.
Who is the best pick?
Are u even serious??
As a Crouch owner just don't. Look at his scores, I can't understand why anyone would want him.
As I said in another thread, he's had only two good scores since injury. A 126 and a modest 107. He gets 35-40 touches and barely hits 100. He's not risen above 500k since injury. He's cheap for a reason.
I understand the concern of the tag with Oliver, but he's a class above Crouch SC wise. I think he handles rhe tag better than most. Got 30 touches and 75 SC vs the best tagger in Jacobs.
Is there any one else u can get?
Pendles? Selwood? Duncan? Gaff?
Neale? Anyone but Crouch.

shaker

Quote from: ubeaut on July 12, 2018, 07:17:24 PM
Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 03:43:04 PM
Crouch V Oliver ?
Crouch doesn't seemed to get tagged , seems to play better with Sloane back which will also be a huge lift for the Crows with him staying.
Oliver can pump out the big scores but doesn't handle a tag that good , after this week have Cats , Crows , WC away in there draw plus Sydney who tag and even this week could get Dunkley who shut Mitchell out last week.
Who is the best pick?
Are u even serious??
As a Crouch owner just don't. Look at his scores, I can't understand why anyone would want him.
As I said in another thread, he's had only two good scores since injury. A 126 and a modest 107. He gets 35-40 touches and barely hits 100. He's not risen above 500k since injury. He's cheap for a reason.
I understand the concern of the tag with Oliver, but he's a class above Crouch SC wise. I think he handles rhe tag better than most. Got 30 touches and 75 SC vs the best tagger in Jacobs.
Is there any one else u can get?
Pendles? Selwood? Duncan? Gaff?
Neale? Anyone but Crouch.

Just got a feeling the Crows will go bang tonight , Sloane signing will be a huge boost as was Dusty for the Tiges when he signed , have Pendles none of the others don't know just a gut feeling Crouch will have a good end to the season and the Crows are going to go out blazing plus the Dees have some very tough away games as I said, the finger is on the trade button ha ha  ;D

ubeaut

Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 07:34:01 PM
Quote from: ubeaut on July 12, 2018, 07:17:24 PM
Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 03:43:04 PM
Crouch V Oliver ?
Crouch doesn't seemed to get tagged , seems to play better with Sloane back which will also be a huge lift for the Crows with him staying.
Oliver can pump out the big scores but doesn't handle a tag that good , after this week have Cats , Crows , WC away in there draw plus Sydney who tag and even this week could get Dunkley who shut Mitchell out last week.
Who is the best pick?
Are u even serious??
As a Crouch owner just don't. Look at his scores, I can't understand why anyone would want him.
As I said in another thread, he's had only two good scores since injury. A 126 and a modest 107. He gets 35-40 touches and barely hits 100. He's not risen above 500k since injury. He's cheap for a reason.
I understand the concern of the tag with Oliver, but he's a class above Crouch SC wise. I think he handles rhe tag better than most. Got 30 touches and 75 SC vs the best tagger in Jacobs.
Is there any one else u can get?
Pendles? Selwood? Duncan? Gaff?
Neale? Anyone but Crouch.

Just got a feeling the Crows will go bang tonight , Sloane signing will be a huge boost as was Dusty for the Tiges when he signed , have Pendles none of the others don't know just a gut feeling Crouch will have a good end to the season and the Crows are going to go out blazing plus the Dees have some very tough away games as I said, the finger is on the trade button ha ha  ;D
Well I'll be more than happy to be proven wrong. Crouch owes me big time.
But don't say I didn't warn you!

shaker

Quote from: ubeaut on July 12, 2018, 07:40:17 PM
Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 07:34:01 PM
Quote from: ubeaut on July 12, 2018, 07:17:24 PM
Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 03:43:04 PM
Crouch V Oliver ?
Crouch doesn't seemed to get tagged , seems to play better with Sloane back which will also be a huge lift for the Crows with him staying.
Oliver can pump out the big scores but doesn't handle a tag that good , after this week have Cats , Crows , WC away in there draw plus Sydney who tag and even this week could get Dunkley who shut Mitchell out last week.
Who is the best pick?
Are u even serious??
As a Crouch owner just don't. Look at his scores, I can't understand why anyone would want him.
As I said in another thread, he's had only two good scores since injury. A 126 and a modest 107. He gets 35-40 touches and barely hits 100. He's not risen above 500k since injury. He's cheap for a reason.
I understand the concern of the tag with Oliver, but he's a class above Crouch SC wise. I think he handles rhe tag better than most. Got 30 touches and 75 SC vs the best tagger in Jacobs.
Is there any one else u can get?
Pendles? Selwood? Duncan? Gaff?
Neale? Anyone but Crouch.

Just got a feeling the Crows will go bang tonight , Sloane signing will be a huge boost as was Dusty for the Tiges when he signed , have Pendles none of the others don't know just a gut feeling Crouch will have a good end to the season and the Crows are going to go out blazing plus the Dees have some very tough away games as I said, the finger is on the trade button ha ha  ;D
Well I'll be more than happy to be proven wrong. Crouch owes me big time.
But don't say I didn't warn you!

Will revisit after match  :P

shaker

Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 07:47:04 PM
Quote from: ubeaut on July 12, 2018, 07:40:17 PM
Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 07:34:01 PM
Quote from: ubeaut on July 12, 2018, 07:17:24 PM
Quote from: shaker on July 12, 2018, 03:43:04 PM
Crouch V Oliver ?
Crouch doesn't seemed to get tagged , seems to play better with Sloane back which will also be a huge lift for the Crows with him staying.
Oliver can pump out the big scores but doesn't handle a tag that good , after this week have Cats , Crows , WC away in there draw plus Sydney who tag and even this week could get Dunkley who shut Mitchell out last week.
Who is the best pick?
Are u even serious??
As a Crouch owner just don't. Look at his scores, I can't understand why anyone would want him.
As I said in another thread, he's had only two good scores since injury. A 126 and a modest 107. He gets 35-40 touches and barely hits 100. He's not risen above 500k since injury. He's cheap for a reason.
I understand the concern of the tag with Oliver, but he's a class above Crouch SC wise. I think he handles rhe tag better than most. Got 30 touches and 75 SC vs the best tagger in Jacobs.
Is there any one else u can get?
Pendles? Selwood? Duncan? Gaff?
Neale? Anyone but Crouch.

Just got a feeling the Crows will go bang tonight , Sloane signing will be a huge boost as was Dusty for the Tiges when he signed , have Pendles none of the others don't know just a gut feeling Crouch will have a good end to the season and the Crows are going to go out blazing plus the Dees have some very tough away games as I said, the finger is on the trade button ha ha  ;D
Well I'll be more than happy to be proven wrong. Crouch owes me big time.
But don't say I didn't warn you!

Will revisit after match  :P
You were right he's a spud  :P but Duncan Selwood did no better should have gone Oliver  ::) oh well them's the breaks he might come good.

BLBBLB


frenzy


Fid



TommyC


HoleMeal

Oliver vs Macrae???? (can afford anyone)

My other mids are Titch Cripps Danger JKelly Conigs Curnow Dustbin

ubeaut

Quote from: HoleMeal on July 18, 2018, 09:32:15 PM
Oliver vs Macrae???? (can afford anyone)

My other mids are Titch Cripps Danger JKelly Conigs Curnow Dustbin
Can I ask why u traded in both Curnow and Kelly instead of Oliver?
I'd go Macrae as he's about the best POD u can get. But be aware he has a date with Jacobs soon.

fanTCfool

Quote from: ubeaut on July 18, 2018, 10:00:17 PM
Quote from: HoleMeal on July 18, 2018, 09:32:15 PM
Oliver vs Macrae???? (can afford anyone)

My other mids are Titch Cripps Danger JKelly Conigs Curnow Dustbin
Can I ask why u traded in both Curnow and Kelly instead of Oliver?
I'd go Macrae as he's about the best POD u can get. But be aware he has a date with Jacobs soon.

He also has a date with Hutchings this week. That, as well as the Sicily injury, are persuading me to wait one more week.