Player X vs. Player Y

[jbjimmyjb]

Danger + Devon Smith F6/ Guelfi F7
OR
Heppell + Heeney F6/ Devon Smith F7??

Dangerfield

[Ricochet]

Kelly vs Cripps (for Fyfe)

Cripps

[jvalles69]

Kelly vs Cripps (for Fyfe)

Cripps

I've got the same issue and pulling the trigger with Cripps.

[TommyC]

Kelly vs Cripps (for Fyfe)

Cripps

[SilverLion]

Bit of a complicated one here, advice much appreciated :)

Fyfe --> Gaff
Next week T. Smith --> R. Gray (If he goes sub 115, otherwise Menegola as F6, either option pushes Walters to F7, would also have to do another rookie downgrade to afford this)

Leaves me with 3 trades and would have to play a rookie this week to cover for Heeney.

Vs.

Fyfe --> E. Curnow
T. Smith --> C. Curnow

C. Curnow would be F7, with Walters staying on the field. He would cover this week for Heeney though.

4 Trades left.

I'd do the first option if you can get Gray, as Ed Curnow has dropped off over the last few weeks, whereas Gaff is thriving trying to carry WCE. But Gray is much better in terms of consistency than Menegola, so if you can't afford Gray I'd go option 2.

Unfortunately won't know if I can afford Gray until after they play, and Carlton play before them so I'd be risking it.

Have narrowed my options to essentially:

Gaff + Jroo vs. E + C Curnow

[dmac07]

Gaff v Danger

[HoleMeal]

Gaff v Danger

THIS is THE question of the season for me also.

[Fid]

Gaff v Danger

THIS is THE question of the season for me also.

I would go Gaff.  Danger more likely to play more fwd time, especially with the inclusion of Scott Selwood

[ubeaut]

Gaff v Danger

THIS is THE question of the season for me also.

Danger gets my vote.
Both have been really consistent but Danger has more upside and runs on the board.
Cats have a tough draw coming up including Swans,Tigers,Crows and Dees, which helps in his case as he'll be needed through the midfield more in these games.
If I didn't have Danger I'd 100% get him in for Fyfe.
My 2 cents anyway.

[tommy10]

Gaff vs Neale vs Kelly vs Jelwood vs Curnow and in what order?

[North Melbournes Finest]

Gaff vs Neale vs Kelly vs Jelwood vs Curnow and in what order?

I'm in a similar predicament, this is how I have it at the moment

Kelly - Neale - Jelwood - Gaff - Curnow

[Bully]

Gaff vs Neale vs Kelly vs Jelwood vs Curnow and in what order?

I'm in a similar predicament, this is how I have it at the moment

Kelly - Neale - Jelwood - Gaff - Curnow

Best players based on 5 round average.

Ward - 118
Kelly - 117
JPK - 117
Higgins - 115
Neale - 112
Gaff - 110
Jelwood - 107
Beams - 105
Curnow - 101

[strikeforce]

Surely Kelly's Groin cant last. Once there out of the finals run, Do they rest him?

[Bully]

Surely Kelly's Groin cant last. Once there out of the finals run, Do they rest him?

Kelly has been a big reason they have hit form, no way they rest him.

[Judd Magic]

Who to pick out of Neale and Gaff as my Neale replacement?

And who do I play to cover Heeney this week, Holman or Ahern?