Player X vs. Player Y

Started by SilverLion, January 20, 2018, 10:20:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

_wato

Duncan v Jelwood or pay up for Danger

Honestly thinking Duncan, massive POD and never ever gets tagged.

107, 134, 98, 101, 123, 136 in his last 6.

SilverLion

Quote from: _wato on June 07, 2018, 10:45:06 PM
Duncan v Jelwood or pay up for Danger

Honestly thinking Duncan, massive POD and never ever gets tagged.

107, 134, 98, 101, 123, 136 in his last 6.
Duncan is one of my favourite players, rate him higher than Duckwood and Ablett (only because he's not out there often enough).

Since he's not in their best 3 though according to the wisdom of the media he doesn't seem to get any attention, so a great PoD definitely.

_wato

Big call there SL, but I agree he’s underrated as flower. Should go 110/115 on the run home.

What about Gray v Westhoff? Head is pointing towards the Hoff....

jfitty

Thinking I'll have to bring a defender in this week to make up 18! Gosh this week sucks..

Luke Ryan vs Jeremy Howe?

Bye isn't too big of a deal, but loving what Ryan is doing at the moment and leaning that way


Bully

Quote from: _wato on June 07, 2018, 11:03:45 PM
Big call there SL, but I agree he’s underrated as flower. Should go 110/115 on the run home.

What about Gray v Westhoff? Head is pointing towards the Hoff....

Beg to differ, Gray has the runs on the board, very confident he'll be back in the midfield in the backend of the season.

dmac07

Quote from: jfitty on June 08, 2018, 12:05:49 AM
Thinking I'll have to bring a defender in this week to make up 18! Gosh this week sucks..

Luke Ryan vs Jeremy Howe?

Bye isn't too big of a deal, but loving what Ryan is doing at the moment and leaning that way
Ive got and loving both. But I'd go Howe if it was between the two. Just seems more likely to maintain it.

Chrispy75

Quote from: dmac07 on June 08, 2018, 02:26:22 PM
Quote from: jfitty on June 08, 2018, 12:05:49 AM
Thinking I'll have to bring a defender in this week to make up 18! Gosh this week sucks..

Luke Ryan vs Jeremy Howe?

Bye isn't too big of a deal, but loving what Ryan is doing at the moment and leaning that way
Ive got and loving both. But I'd go Howe if it was between the two. Just seems more likely to maintain it.

Have neither, but Ryan would be my choice.  Worried Howe could miss more games through injury.

_wato

Alright

Danger + Boak v Duncan + Gray

jbjimmyjb

Quote from: _wato on June 08, 2018, 03:51:10 PM
Alright

Danger + Boak v Duncan + Gray
Ultimately it depends on whether Gray goes back to the midfield or not. If Richmond blows Port away tonight, surely that'll smack some sense into Hinkley and he'll put his best player back on the ball, but we shall see.
Danger obviously scores better playing 100% midfield, but still manages to ton up regardless of his fwd time.

I'd just go with your gut, based on who you think is more likely to return to 100% mid (Gray or Dangerfield).
Personally I'd go Duncan + Gray bc they have more upside, and Gray is more likely to play mid than Boak and Danger.

Maca24

Crouch vs Selwood vs Ablett?

Ricochet

Quote from: Maca24 on June 08, 2018, 06:58:09 PM
Crouch vs Selwood vs Ablett?
Selwood or Crouch. I'd probably lean towards Crouch

GoSaints3


Chrispy75

B Rice vs L Austin vs J Heron.

To fill D8, but needs to play the next two weeks (only 19-20 during byes).  JS vital and prefer better scoring.  Price also a factor

My thoughts: 
JS - Heron, Rice, Austin
Scoring - Austin, Rice, Heron
Price - Heron, Austin, Rice

Overall, thinking Rice is the best fit.  Thoughts?

Ricochet

Quote from: Chrispy75 on June 09, 2018, 09:51:14 AM
B Rice vs L Austin vs J Heron.

To fill D8, but needs to play the next two weeks (only 19-20 during byes).  JS vital and prefer better scoring.  Price also a factor

My thoughts: 
JS - Heron, Rice, Austin
Scoring - Austin, Rice, Heron
Price - Heron, Austin, Rice

Overall, thinking Rice is the best fit.  Thoughts?
I'd go Austin mate. With his two big scores so far, he's proj to make more money short term too

Samsturmfels

Heron vs brodie

need to consider points they will give me during the bye and price