Player X vs. Player Y

[crowls]

menegola v heeney v gray for f1.     looking for consistency   
lobb out.

[shaker]

menegola v heeney v gray for f1.     looking for consistency   
lobb out.

Heeney for me

[ubeaut]

menegola v heeney v gray for f1.     looking for consistency   
lobb out.

Heeney > Gray > Menegola

Heeney hasn't missed a beat, and is still improving.
Gray has been on fire but more prone to playing fwd (I think they missed his smarts around goal vs Bombers) and throwing up a stinker. Round 10 bye.
Menegola still a good pick with GAJ out but not as good as Heeney or Gray.
All good options, all should be top 8 fwds, but that's how I would prioritize them.

[crowls]

thks guys.    like menegola dpp, and low ownership of 5%,  gray 9%   
head says heeney

[jfitty]

Have to bring one of these guys in early, who would you pick to grab this week:

Matt Guelfi or David Mirra?

[Huttabito]

Have to bring one of these guys in early, who would you pick to grab this week:

Matt Guelfi or David Mirra?

Think both are ok to jump. Personally would grab Mirra purely because we know he's playing and named on field - Guelfi  is unknown until Monday, although Worsfold sung praise this week.

[Bully]

Have to bring one of these guys in early, who would you pick to grab this week:

Matt Guelfi or David Mirra?

Guelfi the better option, 99% sure he won't be dropped. The deciding factor being the scoring potential versus the other forward rookies.

[Thewizz71]

Have to bring one of these guys in early, who would you pick to grab this week:

Matt Guelfi or David Mirra?

Guelfi the better option, 99% sure he won't be dropped. The deciding factor being the scoring potential versus the other forward rookies.

thinking about going early on Guelfi to allow Brayshaw -> YEO or McLEAN.

So Yeo vs McLean this week?

[Bully]

Have to bring one of these guys in early, who would you pick to grab this week:

Matt Guelfi or David Mirra?

Guelfi the better option, 99% sure he won't be dropped. The deciding factor being the scoring potential versus the other forward rookies.

thinking about going early on Guelfi to allow Brayshaw -> YEO or McLEAN.

So Yeo vs McLean this week?

I'm picking Yeo this week, just feel he's very close to bottoming out.

[SilverLion]

Have to bring one of these guys in early, who would you pick to grab this week:

Matt Guelfi or David Mirra?

Guelfi the better option, 99% sure he won't be dropped. The deciding factor being the scoring potential versus the other forward rookies.

thinking about going early on Guelfi to allow Brayshaw -> YEO or McLEAN.

So Yeo vs McLean this week?

Depends on the rest of your team's structure.

I'd probably go McLean, just because the defender rookies are scoring better than the forwards.

[GoSaints3]

Have to bring one of these guys in early, who would you pick to grab this week:

Matt Guelfi or David Mirra?

Guelfi the better option, 99% sure he won't be dropped. The deciding factor being the scoring potential versus the other forward rookies.

thinking about going early on Guelfi to allow Brayshaw -> YEO or McLEAN.

So Yeo vs McLean this week?

Depends on the rest of your team's structure.

I'd probably go McLean, just because the defender rookies are scoring better than the forwards.

+1

Acres vs Silicy ?

[Mongoose528]

Goldy > Grundy
Brayshaw> Mirra (Via Finlayson)

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

Surely Doedee has more cash to make? No way I'd trade any of Doedee/Murray/Finlayson out yet.

agreed... Doedee has another 150-200K to make

Agree with this too ;D ... Scrap bringing in Yeo, the defence is looking like the last line to be upgraded. Will probably bring in Danger or another premium forward.

[_wato]

Coffield v Mirra + 70k

[B.]

Coffield v Crowden??

[crowls]

Coffield v Mirra + 70k

mirra, quicker cash gives more trade options.