Player X vs. Player Y

[shaker]

Gray v Sicily + 100k

For me Sicily but Gray is a good get just his bye ? depending on your situation ?

[ubeaut]

Gray v Sicily + 100k

Depends what u can do with 100k.
As a Sicily owner I'm happy yet still nervous...
Is Gray worth 100k more?
If he continues this form and Sicily goes 90 odd I'd say yes.
If Sicily can push a 100 avg then he's worth picking with the extra cash saved.

[Mongoose528]

Gray v Sicily + 100k

For me Sicily but Gray is a good get just his bye ? depending on your situation ?

It's looking like Gray will be my first man in after his bye. Sicily is looking great for his price.

[Mongoose528]

Gray v Sicily + 100k

Depends what u can do with 100k.
As a Sicily owner I'm happy yet still nervous...
Is Gray worth 100k more?
If he continues this form and Sicily goes 90 odd I'd say yes.
If Sicily can push a 100 avg then he's worth picking with the extra cash saved.

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Gray v Heeney v Buddy?

[SilverLion]

Gray v Heeney v Buddy?

Heeney

[ubeaut]

Gray v Sicily + 100k

Depends what u can do with 100k.
As a Sicily owner I'm happy yet still nervous...
Is Gray worth 100k more?
If he continues this form and Sicily goes 90 odd I'd say yes.
If Sicily can push a 100 avg then he's worth picking with the extra cash saved.

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

Surely Doedee has more cash to make? No way I'd trade any of Doedee/Murray/Finlayson out yet.

[fuzeski]

Kelly > Martin
Brayshaw > Coffield

OR

Goldy > Grundy
Brayshaw> Mirra (Via Finlayson)

[Keeper27]

Trading out Taberner and Bonner.

A) Parfitt BE 4 (F4) and Geary BE 86 (D4)

B) Gray BE 72 (F1) and Coffield BE -43 (D4)


DEF: Laird/Savage/Shaw/ ? ? ? /Finalayson/Doedee (Murray/Richards)
FWD: Smith/Petracca/Sicily/ ? ? ? / Dunkley/ Henry (Waterman/Fritsch)

A - pros: Geary @ D4 gives me 5 x 90+ players onfield & at 95+ is good enough to sit at D4-D6, and Parfitt gives me points + $120K by his BYE, if he avg 95-100 good enough to sit at F4-F6 (also can swing with Taranto M7)
cons: Parfitt is not a keeper

B - Pros: Gray will be top 5 FWDS, Coffield will continue to make money ($180 by his BYE)
Cons: Gray's BYE, can Coffield


thoughts??

[Keeper27]

Goldy > Grundy
Brayshaw> Mirra (Via Finlayson)

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

Surely Doedee has more cash to make? No way I'd trade any of Doedee/Murray/Finlayson out yet.

agreed... Doedee has another 150-200K to make

[SilverLion]

Trading out Taberner and Bonner.

A) Parfitt BE 4 (F4) and Geary BE 86 (D4)

B) Gray BE 72 (F1) and Coffield BE -43 (D4)


DEF: Laird/Savage/Shaw/ ? ? ? /Finalayson/Doedee (Murray/Richards)
FWD: Smith/Petracca/Sicily/ ? ? ? / Dunkley/ Henry (Waterman/Fritsch)

A - pros: Geary @ D4 gives me 5 x 90+ players onfield & at 95+ is good enough to sit at D4-D6, and Parfitt gives me points + $120K by his BYE, if he avg 95-100 good enough to sit at F4-F6 (also can swing with Taranto M7)
cons: Parfitt is not a keeper

B - Pros: Gray will be top 5 FWDS, Coffield will continue to make money ($180 by his BYE)
Cons: Gray's BYE, can Coffield


thoughts??

B easily.

Option A has the potential to catastrophically wrong, forcing another 2 trades. Option B doesn't.

[shaker]

Goldy > Grundy
Brayshaw> Mirra (Via Finlayson)

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

Surely Doedee has more cash to make? No way I'd trade any of Doedee/Murray/Finlayson out yet.

agreed... Doedee has another 150-200K to make

Don't know if he has that much cash left in him another smallish score this week against the Swans will stall him somewhat

[Marstar]

Goldy > Grundy
Brayshaw> Mirra (Via Finlayson)

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

Surely Doedee has more cash to make? No way I'd trade any of Doedee/Murray/Finlayson out yet.

agreed... Doedee has another 150-200K to make

Don't know if he has that much cash left in him another smallish score this week against the Swans will stall him somewhat

And that's ignoring Yeo's future price while waiting for Doedee to make that money.

Yeo could also be $50-100k more expensive ... so you stand to make a less $$ than you think on the exchange and a tonne less points.

He is already the 7th best Def with a R3 score of 27 to his name ... so I basically rate him as a shoe-in for Top6 at a bargain price.

[Bully]

Goldy > Grundy
Brayshaw> Mirra (Via Finlayson)

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

Surely Doedee has more cash to make? No way I'd trade any of Doedee/Murray/Finlayson out yet.

agreed... Doedee has another 150-200K to make

Don't know if he has that much cash left in him another smallish score this week against the Swans will stall him somewhat

And that's ignoring Yeo's future price while waiting for Doedee to make that money.

Yeo could also be $50-100k more expensive ... so you stand to make a less $$ than you think on the exchange and a tonne less points.

He is already the 7th best Def with a R3 score of 27 to his name ... so I basically rate him as a shoe-in for Top6 at a bargain price.

Spot on, I still adhere to the principle of the BE must be under the average in order to hold. Unless you believe he's a keeper then nothing changes in Doedee's case. As for bench coverage, I reckon Mirra is solid depth.

[fuzeski]

Goldy > Grundy
Brayshaw> Mirra (Via Finlayson)

The other 100k allows me to bring in Yeo for Doedee next week.

Surely Doedee has more cash to make? No way I'd trade any of Doedee/Murray/Finlayson out yet.

agreed... Doedee has another 150-200K to make

Any reasoning behind this?

Kelly could be out for another couple weeks