Player X vs. Player Y

[zoomba23]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

[GoLions]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZORKOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[ben_020285]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

Crouch the better pick but has the worst bye. Hard to pick him with Danger, Dusty and Fyfe sharing his bye.

Would think about Oliver as an alternative to Zorko.

[GoLions]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

Crouch the better pick but has the worst bye. Hard to pick him with Danger, Dusty and Fyfe sharing his bye.

Would think about Oliver as an alternative to Zorko.

Why would you purposely pick the inferior player though. This isn't golf.

[ben_020285]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

Crouch the better pick but has the worst bye. Hard to pick him with Danger, Dusty and Fyfe sharing his bye.

Would think about Oliver as an alternative to Zorko.

Why would you purposely pick the inferior player though. This isn't golf.

I didn't.

I like Crouch more than Zorko but don't like Crouch's bye so would go for Oliver who I like as much as Crouch but more than Zorko.

[Hazza09]

Have done some changes...6 in fact!  ;D

Mirra / Josh Kelly / O’Meara / Heeney / Dunkley / Rayner

Vs

Bonner / Bont / Brodie or Dow / Walters / Petracca / Stephenson

Am concerned with D8 being an issue with Mirra/Murphy unlikely to play.
Not sure if Bonner is the answer for D4 but I only have 260k.
Not sold on Dunkley or anyone at the 260-300k mark so upgraded to Petracca.
Rayner’s fitness is also a concern as he might play more forward.

Really struggling.

[GoLions]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

Crouch the better pick but has the worst bye. Hard to pick him with Danger, Dusty and Fyfe sharing his bye.

Would think about Oliver as an alternative to Zorko.

Why would you purposely pick the inferior player though. This isn't golf.

I didn't.

I like Crouch more than Zorko but don't like Crouch's bye so would go for Oliver who I like as much as Crouch but more than Zorko.

Oliver might not even play round 1!

[ben_020285]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

Crouch the better pick but has the worst bye. Hard to pick him with Danger, Dusty and Fyfe sharing his bye.

Would think about Oliver as an alternative to Zorko.

Why would you purposely pick the inferior player though. This isn't golf.

I didn't.

I like Crouch more than Zorko but don't like Crouch's bye so would go for Oliver who I like as much as Crouch but more than Zorko.

Oliver might not even play round 1!

He will. On light duties due to a minor knock to the knee but close to certain for round 1.

[Ricochet]

Crouch v Zorko?
Zork more deviation higher ceiling.
Crouch more consistency but may lose points to Gibbs.
Any thoughts?

Yeh Zorko, for that Gibbs reason. Just a bit of an unknown atm

[RaisyDaisy]

One of Crouch/Zorko/Neale/Merret/Pendles/Bont etc + Brayshaw/Brodie + Bundy

VS

Conigs + Libba + 117-123k fwd rookie on field

Option 1 looks more appealing, but Option 2 might score slightly better and potentially be 2 keepers, where as Option 1 is just premo keeper

[Perts24]

One of Crouch/Zorko/Neale/Merret/Pendles/Bont etc + Brayshaw/Brodie + Bundy

VS

Conigs + Libba + 117-123k fwd rookie on field

Option 1 looks more appealing, but Option 2 might score slightly better and potentially be 2 keepers, where as Option 1 is just premo keeper

I would go for option 1 because you should get a keeper, whereas i personally don't think coniglio or libba will average enough to be keepers.

Kreuzer and parker vs Goldy and Dusty

[tommy10]

One of Crouch/Zorko/Neale/Merret/Pendles/Bont etc + Brayshaw/Brodie + Bundy

VS

Conigs + Libba + 117-123k fwd rookie on field

Option 1 looks more appealing, but Option 2 might score slightly better and potentially be 2 keepers, where as Option 1 is just premo keeper

Option 1 for me. As you said potentially 2 keepers..I don’t see Libba as a keeper imo. More cash generation with option 1 with Brayshaw over Brodie and I would say it’s between Zorko/Zerrett/Bont for me. As a pod Zorko.

[SilverLion]

One of Crouch/Zorko/Neale/Merret/Pendles/Bont etc + Brayshaw/Brodie + Bundy

VS

Conigs + Libba + 117-123k fwd rookie on field

Option 1 looks more appealing, but Option 2 might score slightly better and potentially be 2 keepers, where as Option 1 is just premo keeper

I would go for option 1 because you should get a keeper, whereas i personally don't think coniglio or libba will average enough to be keepers.

Kreuzer and parker vs Goldy and Dusty

Easily Goldy and Dusty

[ubeaut]

1.)Danger,Cripps M5,JOM M6,Billings F4
(Sicily D3)
Vs
2.)Kelly,Titch M5,Zorko M6,Byrne D3
(Sicily F4)

Option 2 gives strong mids with 6 premos but weak D3,although Sicily can be swung back if needed.

Option 1 has Danger, weaker mids with JOM instead of Zorko M6,Cripps instead of Titch M5,but stronger backs and
with Billings instead of Byrne.
Common mids are Dusty,Fyfe,Merrett

Anyone?

[GoLions]

1.)Danger,Cripps M5,JOM M6,Billings F4
(Sicily D3)
Vs
2.)Kelly,Titch M5,Zorko M6,Byrne D3
(Sicily F4)

Option 2 gives strong mids with 6 premos but weak D3,although Sicily can be swung back if needed.

Option 1 has Danger, weaker mids with JOM instead of Zorko M6,Cripps instead of Titch M5,but stronger backs and
with Billings instead of Byrne.
Common mids are Dusty,Fyfe,Merrett

Anyone?

Danger, Zorko, Armo, Billings