Player X vs. Player Y

[ubeaut]

Hurley(D1), Coffield(D4), Banfield(M7), Heeney(F1), Greene(F2), Billings(F3) V Simpson(D3), C. Ellis(D4), O'meara(M7), Smith(F1), Petracca(F2), Sicily(F3) +100k

Option 1 is 4 premos and 2 rookies.
Option 2 is 1 proven premo 5 midpricers with 3 of thrm a chance to be premo.
Not a fan of Ellis(JS) or Petracca(will he get enough mid time)
I have JOM Sicily and Smith but put them with Ellis and Trac and it's option 1 for me.

[ubeaut]

Hurley(D1), Coffield(D4), Banfield(M7), Heeney(F1), Greene(F2), Billings(F3) V Simpson(D3), C. Ellis(D4), O'meara(M7), Smith(F1), Petracca(F2), Sicily(F3) +100k

Sloane v MCrouch

Sloane is a tempting POD. If he can score better when copping occasional tag he will outscore Crouch imo.

[SilverLion]

Hurley(D1), Coffield(D4), Banfield(M7), Heeney(F1), Greene(F2), Billings(F3) V Simpson(D3), C. Ellis(D4), O'meara(M7), Smith(F1), Petracca(F2), Sicily(F3) +100k

Option 1 is 4 premos and 2 rookies.
Option 2 is 1 proven premo 5 midpricers with 3 of thrm a chance to be premo.
Not a fan of Ellis(JS) or Petracca(will he get enough mid time)
I have JOM Sicily and Smith but put them with Ellis and Trac and it's option 1 for me.

Harsh to put both Smith and Ellis in the same mid-price bracket, Smith is over 200k dearer.

I've got everyone from option 2 except Petracca. Feel you need a proven prem at F1. Heeney, Menegola, Franklin, Dahlhaus etc.

[Money Shot]

Hurley(D1), Coffield(D4), Banfield(M7), Heeney(F1), Greene(F2), Billings(F3) V Simpson(D3), C. Ellis(D4), O'meara(M7), Smith(F1), Petracca(F2), Sicily(F3) +100k

Option 1 is 4 premos and 2 rookies.
Option 2 is 1 proven premo 5 midpricers with 3 of thrm a chance to be premo.
Not a fan of Ellis(JS) or Petracca(will he get enough mid time)
I have JOM Sicily and Smith but put them with Ellis and Trac and it's option 1 for me.

Harsh to put both Smith and Ellis in the same mid-price bracket, Smith is over 200k dearer.

I've got everyone from option 2 except Petracca. Feel you need a proven prem at F1. Heeney, Menegola, Franklin, Dahlhaus etc.

Agree, think I need to find a happy medium.

[Money Shot]

Byrne v C. Ellis v Coffield (D4)

[ubeaut]

Byrne v C. Ellis v Coffield (D4)

Rather take a more experienced player.
Byrne if named may have beaten Mullet,O'Shea,O'Brien for that HB role so it could be his to lose?
Ellis has Broad,Graham,Miles etc. knocking on the door.
Coffield I'm not sure about but it may turn out he will have better JS but who knows.
Maybe we'll have to wait for round one teams, I'm finding D4 the hardest spot to fill myself.

[Money Shot]

Byrne v C. Ellis v Coffield (D4)

Rather take a more experienced player.
Byrne if named may have beaten Mullet,O'Shea,O'Brien for that HB role so it could be his to lose?
Ellis has Broad,Graham,Miles etc. knocking on the door.
Coffield I'm not sure about but it may turn out he will have better JS but who knows.
Maybe we'll have to wait for round one teams, I'm finding D4 the hardest spot to fill myself.

Yep F4 is easy with Bundy around and with me not wanting to spend any more than 250k but still wanting some reliability down back finding the right candidate for D4 is hard. Ellis has a lot too prove tonight and I will be watching him closely.

[SilverLion]

Byrne v C. Ellis v Coffield (D4)

If they were all named Rd. 1, probably Ellis. Would try to squeeze Coffield at D5 if I could though.

[tommy10]

Jacobs and Coffield (D4) vs Lycett and Hanley (D4)

[GoLions]

Jacobs and Coffield (D4) vs Lycett and Hanley (D4)

Sauce and Coff easily imho

[SilverLion]

Jacobs (R1) + 123k FWD rookie (F5) vs. Lycett (R2) + Robbo (F3)

[Levi434]

Jacobs (R1) + 123k FWD rookie (F5) vs. Lycett (R2) + Robbo (F3)

Is Robbo a keeper? I don't think so. Also Goldy > Sauce.

[SilverLion]

Jacobs (R1) + 123k FWD rookie (F5) vs. Lycett (R2) + Robbo (F3)

Is Robbo a keeper? I don't think so. Also Goldy > Sauce.

Averaged 80+ the last 6 years. Including 95.8 excl. injury last year.

I just couldn't pick Goldstein :P

[Blues Blues Blues]

Jacobs (R1) + 123k FWD rookie (F5) vs. Lycett (R2) + Robbo (F3)

Is Robbo a keeper? I don't think so. Also Goldy > Sauce.

Averaged 80+ the last 6 years. Including 95.8 excl. injury last year.

I just couldn't pick Goldstein :P

Agree re Goldstein. Although if Preuss gets injured I’d be all over Goldy like a fat kid on a cupcake

[tommy10]

Jacobs (R1) + 123k FWD rookie (F5) vs. Lycett (R2) + Robbo (F3)

Is Robbo a keeper? I don't think so. Also Goldy > Sauce.

Averaged 80+ the last 6 years. Including 95.8 excl. injury last year.

I just couldn't pick Goldstein :P

Agree with SL and BBB on Goldy. With Preuss in the team, I’ll be reluctant to pick him.