Player X vs. Player Y

[jricey]

Hey Guys!

What's everyone's thoughts on the two mid-priced mids?

Stephen Coniglio - mid - (GWS, $452,400)

or

Pearce Hanley - mid/def - (GCS, $28,000)

Hanley possibly getting a little more value given his DPP?

Both looking at much more game time this year and looking to regain some form?

[GoLions]

Hey mate, we have this thread in the Players and Trades board which is a perfect place for you to ask these questions :)

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,110600.msg1909057.html#msg1909057

[GoLions]

Hey mate, we have this thread in the Players and Trades board which is a perfect place for you to ask these questions :)

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,110600.msg1909057.html#msg1909057

:P

Barlow and Conigs fwiw though ;)

[DCAK]

Hey Guys!

What's everyone's thoughts on the two mid-priced mids?

Stephen Coniglio - mid - (GWS, $452,400)

or

Pearce Hanley - mid/def - (GCS, $28,000)

Hanley possibly getting a little more value given his DPP?

Both looking at much more game time this year and looking to regain some form?

I'd take Hanley @ $28K  ;)

[DCAK]

Hi guys!

Whats everyone's thoughts on the two mid-priced, duel-position forwards?

Michael Barlow (GCS, $462,700)

or

Christian Pretracca (MEL, $33,300)

If Petracca was $33.3K I'd take him!  :o

[jricey]

Petracca or Barlow?

&

Coniglio or Hanley?

[GoLions]

Petracca or Barlow?

&

Coniglio or Hanley?

Barlow much more likely of delivering premo scores than Petracca imo, so I'd go with him, even with the Suns early bye week

Would prefer Coniglio to Hanley, Conigs a chance of taking that next step this year. Don't think Hanley will score as well as some are predicting personally.

[Southstorm]

Petracca or Barlow?

&

Coniglio or Hanley?

Honestly wouldn't go with any of them. Barlow and Hanley are just as likely to go back to scoring in the 80-90 range, Coniglio is still expensive for what he'll realistically average and Petracca is probably going to be playing his 2017 HFF role and scoring not much better than last year.

[jricey]

Shiel or Cripps?

Both same price and 2017 average, Shiel could be nice POD at just 1%...

[SilverLion]

Petracca or Barlow?

&

Coniglio or Hanley?

Barlow and Coniglio

[SilverLion]

Shiel or Cripps?

Both same price and 2017 average, Shiel could be nice POD at just 1%...

Cripps

Shiel very bad shoulders, could break down any time.

[jricey]

Shiel or Cripps?

Both same price and 2017 average, Shiel could be nice POD at just 1%...

Cripps

Shiel very bad shoulders, could break down any time.

Cripps not just as injury prone?

[shaker]

Post in SC players not team advice  ;)

[SilverLion]

Shiel or Cripps?

Both same price and 2017 average, Shiel could be nice POD at just 1%...

Cripps

Shiel very bad shoulders, could break down any time.

Cripps not just as injury prone?

Possibly, just think Shiel is more so. Bloke is playing injured when he is out there, not sure he's been 100% fit his whole career.

[shaker]

Post in SC players not team advice ;)