Player X vs. Player Y

[kosduras]

Dangerfield + Coniglio vs Ablett + Pendlebury?

Been scratching my head on this one for ages

The best player in the land + someone who is underpriced  vs two iffy premiums whose best could be or probably is in the past
Danger + Coniglio for me easily.
I'd love to think GAJ will play 20-22 games this year. It would be great for the competition. I just can't see it happening though.
Pendles has been great and he could go 115+ but I see him in decline from his glory days and Buckley doesn't help his cause.

zerrit v bont v zorko,

i cant decide between these guys at d5 with one of coniglio or beams at d6. if i take beams i wont take zorko, feel as though they would eat off each other

thoughts??

Beams is a lock so that rules out Zorko for you.
Bont> Zerrett> Zorko then.

zerrit v bont v zorko,

i cant decide between these guys at d5 with one of coniglio or beams at d6. if i take beams i wont take zorko, feel as though they would eat off each other

thoughts??

You mean m5, right?

I would probably go with Zerrett + Beams, or Zorko + Coniglio.

yeah m5 sorry, and yeah fair enough

Dangerfield + Coniglio vs Ablett + Pendlebury?

Been scratching my head on this one for ages

The best player in the land + someone who is underpriced  vs two iffy premiums whose best could be or probably is in the past
Danger + Coniglio for me easily.
I'd love to think GAJ will play 20-22 games this year. It would be great for the competition. I just can't see it happening though.
Pendles has been great and he could go 115+ but I see him in decline from his glory days and Buckley doesn't help his cause.

zerrit v bont v zorko,

i cant decide between these guys at d5 with one of coniglio or beams at d6. if i take beams i wont take zorko, feel as though they would eat off each other

thoughts??

Beams is a lock so that rules out Zorko for you.
Bont> Zerrett> Zorko then.

bont and beams then? cheers for the feedback guys

[SilverLion]

Coniglio vs. Prestia

[GoLions]

Coniglio vs. Prestia

Coniglio less risk, Prestia higher reward. I'd be tempted to take Prestia.

[quinny88]

Coniglio vs. Prestia

Coniglio less risk, Prestia higher reward. I'd be tempted to take Prestia.

Coniglio better bye too so would take him

[Bully]

Coniglio vs. Prestia

I'm definitely on the Prestia train, could easily hit 600k if he maintains the form he produced over the past 7 games.

[Grufflez]

Buddy vs Howe ?

[Huttabito]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy - more likely to finish higher in his position.

[GoLions]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy - more likely to finish higher in his position.

Hmm, assuming this is like "go stronger up fwd or down back", then got to also keep in mind who the rookie (or whoever) will be that comes into the other position. Value/rookie fwds stronger than the value/rookie defenders atm imo, which could make Howe the better option. Agree though, Buddy more likely to be top 3 or 6 up fwd than Howe is down back (but would expect Howe to go top 10 or so anyway).

[shaker]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Had Howe last year scores good but also threw in 5 scores in the 60's ..... hang on that sounds like Buddy as well  :D maybe if the Pies show they have some sort of game plan this year Howe might be worth a punt

[Torpedo10]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy - more likely to finish higher in his position.

Hmm, assuming this is like "go stronger up fwd or down back", then got to also keep in mind who the rookie (or whoever) will be that comes into the other position. Value/rookie fwds stronger than the value/rookie defenders atm imo, which could make Howe the better option. Agree though, Buddy more likely to be top 3 or 6 up fwd than Howe is down back (but would expect Howe to go top 10 or so anyway).

Where are these value forwards you speak of? Haha.

[GoLions]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy - more likely to finish higher in his position.

Hmm, assuming this is like "go stronger up fwd or down back", then got to also keep in mind who the rookie (or whoever) will be that comes into the other position. Value/rookie fwds stronger than the value/rookie defenders atm imo, which could make Howe the better option. Agree though, Buddy more likely to be top 3 or 6 up fwd than Howe is down back (but would expect Howe to go top 10 or so anyway).

Where are these value forwards you speak of? Haha.

Lobb, Christensen, Curnow, MRobbo, VenaGOAT, Higgins, Garlett, Rioli, Ryan, Rayner, Stepho, Ah Chee, Scheer, Ahern could all be decent cheaper premos or rookies

Then in defence, once you go under 410k, you basically have Mills, Maynard, McGrath, Birchall, Coffield, Hibberd, Doedee, O'Shea, Cumming

That's all off the top of my head, may have a missed a few. But I'd be a lot more confident in those fwds than the defenders

[Torpedo10]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy - more likely to finish higher in his position.

Hmm, assuming this is like "go stronger up fwd or down back", then got to also keep in mind who the rookie (or whoever) will be that comes into the other position. Value/rookie fwds stronger than the value/rookie defenders atm imo, which could make Howe the better option. Agree though, Buddy more likely to be top 3 or 6 up fwd than Howe is down back (but would expect Howe to go top 10 or so anyway).

Where are these value forwards you speak of? Haha.

Lobb, Christensen, Curnow, MRobbo, VenaGOAT, Higgins, Garlett, Rioli, Ryan, Rayner, Stepho, Ah Chee, Scheer, Ahern could all be decent cheaper premos or rookies

Then in defence, once you go under 410k, you basically have Mills, Maynard, McGrath, Birchall, Coffield, Hibberd, Doedee, O'Shea, Cumming

That's all off the top of my head, may have a missed a few. But I'd be a lot more confident in those fwds than the defenders

Interesting, I like the Defender a lot more with a few off the top of my head.

Jelwood & Coniglio or Danger & Griffen?

[SilverLion]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy

[SilverLion]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy - more likely to finish higher in his position.

Hmm, assuming this is like "go stronger up fwd or down back", then got to also keep in mind who the rookie (or whoever) will be that comes into the other position. Value/rookie fwds stronger than the value/rookie defenders atm imo, which could make Howe the better option. Agree though, Buddy more likely to be top 3 or 6 up fwd than Howe is down back (but would expect Howe to go top 10 or so anyway).

Where are these value forwards you speak of? Haha.

Lobb, Christensen, Curnow, MRobbo, VenaGOAT, Higgins, Garlett, Rioli, Ryan, Rayner, Stepho, Ah Chee, Scheer, Ahern could all be decent cheaper premos or rookies

Then in defence, once you go under 410k, you basically have Mills, Maynard, McGrath, Birchall, Coffield, Hibberd, Doedee, O'Shea, Cumming

That's all off the top of my head, may have a missed a few. But I'd be a lot more confident in those fwds than the defenders

Interesting, I like the Defender a lot more with a few off the top of my head.

Jelwood & Coniglio or Danger & Griffen?

Danger and Griffin

Neither of Jelwood or Coniglio are likely to be top 10, Danger is a certainty and Griff will make money.

[js19]

Buddy vs Howe ?

Buddy - more likely to finish higher in his position.

Hmm, assuming this is like "go stronger up fwd or down back", then got to also keep in mind who the rookie (or whoever) will be that comes into the other position. Value/rookie fwds stronger than the value/rookie defenders atm imo, which could make Howe the better option. Agree though, Buddy more likely to be top 3 or 6 up fwd than Howe is down back (but would expect Howe to go top 10 or so anyway).

Where are these value forwards you speak of? Haha.

Lobb, Christensen, Curnow, MRobbo, VenaGOAT, Higgins, Garlett, Rioli, Ryan, Rayner, Stepho, Ah Chee, Scheer, Ahern could all be decent cheaper premos or rookies

Then in defence, once you go under 410k, you basically have Mills, Maynard, McGrath, Birchall, Coffield, Hibberd, Doedee, O'Shea, Cumming

That's all off the top of my head, may have a missed a few. But I'd be a lot more confident in those fwds than the defenders

Interesting, I like the Defender a lot more with a few off the top of my head.

Jelwood & Coniglio or Danger & Griffen?

Danger and Griffin

Neither of Jelwood or Coniglio are likely to be top 10, Danger is a certainty and Griff will make money.

+1