Player X vs. Player Y

[enzedder]

My concern with Hibberd is the inclusion of Lever into the side

Should have a positive effect in freeing him up.

[SilverLion]

::)

Liberatore  V  Coniglio.

Coniglio definitely. Not even sure Libba is best 22 currently.

[quinny88]

::)

Liberatore  V  Coniglio.

Coniglio definitely. Not even sure Libba is best 22 currently.

Partied too hard after the premiership and had a poor year but let's not forget how good he was before that.
Averages of 110, 106 then 90 coming off an acl

[crowls]

Yeo v Laird v Hibberd... rank them.

Laird > Hibberd > Yeo

Agree,  Yeo still has lot of unanswered questions about his role within WCE.     Laird is mr dependable down back.  He will rack up high 90 avg for next 5 years.    Hibberd should continue on similar to last year unless Melbourne have a significant change in game plan for defence.

[kosduras]

de goey vs petracca, im so tempted to take one of these blokes this yeah at a decent price and realistically both have the talent to have a huge break out year! but which one???

de goey finished strong and will likely get the minutes in the mid, but apparently petracca is training the house down, but will he get the mid minutes?

[SilverLion]

de goey vs petracca, im so tempted to take one of these blokes this yeah at a decent price and realistically both have the talent to have a huge break out year! but which one???

de goey finished strong and will likely get the minutes in the mid, but apparently petracca is training the house down, but will he get the mid minutes?

Neither, but if forced to pick, probably De Goey.

[TexR74]

Jack Viney vs Stephen Coniglio???

[PassivePenguin]

Jack Viney vs Stephen Coniglio???

Coniglio >> Viney (had this spud in 2016... Never again)

[SilverLion]

Jack Viney vs Stephen Coniglio???

Coniglio

[Big Mac]

de goey vs petracca, im so tempted to take one of these blokes this yeah at a decent price and realistically both have the talent to have a huge break out year! but which one???

de goey finished strong and will likely get the minutes in the mid, but apparently petracca is training the house down, but will he get the mid minutes?

Petracca was told at his exit interview last year to prepare for this season as a midfielder - i'd take him but i'm heavily biased haha

[Money Shot]

Sauce v Big Boy v Smith

[Money Shot]

de goey vs petracca, im so tempted to take one of these blokes this yeah at a decent price and realistically both have the talent to have a huge break out year! but which one???

de goey finished strong and will likely get the minutes in the mid, but apparently petracca is training the house down, but will he get the mid minutes?

Petracca was told at his exit interview last year to prepare for this season as a midfielder - i'd take him but i'm heavily biased haha

Ive been all over Brayshaw recently. Do you know what was said in his exist interview ;D

[quinny88]

de goey vs petracca, im so tempted to take one of these blokes this yeah at a decent price and realistically both have the talent to have a huge break out year! but which one???

de goey finished strong and will likely get the minutes in the mid, but apparently petracca is training the house down, but will he get the mid minutes?

Petracca was told at his exit interview last year to prepare for this season as a midfielder - i'd take him but i'm heavily biased haha

Ive been all over Brayshaw recently. Do you know what was said in his exist interview ;D

To stop getting knocked out lol

[js19]

Sauce v Big Boy v Smith

Smith > Sauce > Big Boy for me

[SilverLion]

Sauce v Big Boy v Smith

Sauce>>>>Smith>Big Boy

This one depends on your bye situation a bit though.