Player X vs. Player Y

[bkimm32]

Simpson vs Shaw vs KEEP hibberd (I'm sure a lot of people are having this dilemma atm) for me its between simpson vs keeping hibberd atm, but not really sure. hate hibberds role right now.

[no eye deer]

Waterman v Garlett v Fogarty

(Who will generate the most cash)

Fogarty (assuming he stays in the side).

Fisher vs Taranto?

Taranto imo

Goldy v Nank v Jacobs

Goldy

[Ricochet]

Goldy v Nank v Jacobs

Goldy

[GoLions]

Simpson vs Shaw vs KEEP hibberd (I'm sure a lot of people are having this dilemma atm) for me its between simpson vs keeping hibberd atm, but not really sure. hate hibberds role right now.

You had an opportunity and you blew it.

Keep Hibberd imo

[_wato]

Been done a thousand times but seen both play twice now.

Titch v Dusty

Both with low be’s and both gone huge 2 weeks in a row. Who do I pick?

[MC]

Been done a thousand times but seen both play twice now.

Titch v Dusty

Both with low be’s and both gone huge 2 weeks in a row. Who do I pick?

To preface: I currently have Titch and am bringing in Dusty this week for Crouch.
If I had to pick one for now, I'd go with Titch. Even when tagged he still racks up 40-odd, and he's 0 chance of getting lost in the forward line for a quarter or two. I still have a thing about Martin as well - last year he broke all the records, his side won the flag and he managed 119/game. Can he do it all again? As a final point, his record vs his next few teams is not great, not sure what to make of it but it would point me towards Titch being the better option imo

I also read somewhere that Dusty hasn't managed 120+ against only 2 teams in his career. Hawks and Demons, both of whom he plays in the next few rounds.
I hope he bucks the trend given that I'm grabbing him, but like I said, Titch would be my choice.

[mzunguman]

Ryan V Waterman V Marshall to bring in this week...

[Mantis]

Been done a thousand times but seen both play twice now.

Titch v Dusty

Both with low be’s and both gone huge 2 weeks in a row. Who do I pick?

Yeah I'm with Titch to, isn't relying on goals for these massive scores, just an absolute ball magnet

[Mantis]

Ryan V Waterman V Marshall to bring in this week...

Ryan, has the better job security and will make some fast cash after last weeks score. Waterman may make way when Kennedy returns

[Mantis]

Simpson vs Shaw vs KEEP hibberd (I'm sure a lot of people are having this dilemma atm) for me its between simpson vs keeping hibberd atm, but not really sure. hate hibberds role right now.

You had an opportunity and you blew it.

Keep Hibberd imo

. That 40pt last qtr in R1 shows what he can do. He has been a good scorer for a while now and will continue to be

Im with this, keep hibberd

[shaker]

C Curnow v Taranto

[Mantis]

C Curnow v Taranto

I'm not a massive fan of trading in mid pricers unless you think they will be keepers. I have my doubts on either of them being top forwards but out of the 2 i would pick curnow. I'm not off to the best start this season so take this with a grain of salt hahaha

[Mantis]

Just seeing what people's opinions are on who to trade to

Beams to either Oliver vs Cripps
Rayner to either Barry vs Waterman

I feel as if i have the other required rookies. Currently looking at oliver and barry but that extra cash from cripps may help with my first upgrade.

[shaker]

C Curnow v Taranto

I'm not a massive fan of trading in mid pricers unless you think they will be keepers. I have my doubts on either of them being top forwards but out of the 2 i would pick curnow. I'm not off to the best start this season so take this with a grain of salt hahaha

Yeah I here you but getting rid of Greene upgrading O'Meara to Coniglio and that leaves me just over 400K , I'm leaning to Curnow Blues have a fairly good draw , bit of a punt  ;D

[shaker]

Just seeing what people's opinions are on who to trade to

Beams to either Oliver vs Cripps
Rayner to either Barry vs Waterman

I feel as if i have the other required rookies. Currently looking at oliver and barry but that extra cash from cripps may help with my first upgrade.

Yep the reason a lot are doing some sideways stuff Cripps will save some cash got some attention last week and still scored 115 and Barry might have a bit better JS