Player X vs. Player Y

[ubeaut]

Know it's been asked before, but
Kelly vs Treloar? And reasons why?

Exactly same price, similar average.
Treloar's DE is his worry
Kelly's Groin is his
Kelly probably better player, but Treloar has great numbers every week

Other mids are Titch,Dusty,Fyfe,Oliver,
Cripps,Crouch,Danger

[whynot102]

I had the same decision went Treloar given Collingwoods upcoming draw

Know it's been asked before, but
Kelly vs Treloar? And reasons why?

Exactly same price, similar average.
Treloar's DE is his worry
Kelly's Groin is his
Kelly probably better player, but Treloar has great numbers every week

Other mids are Titch,Dusty,Fyfe,Oliver,
Cripps,Crouch,Danger

[Huttabito]

Know it's been asked before, but
Kelly vs Treloar? And reasons why?

Exactly same price, similar average.
Treloar's DE is his worry
Kelly's Groin is his
Kelly probably better player, but Treloar has great numbers every week

Other mids are Titch,Dusty,Fyfe,Oliver,
Cripps,Crouch,Danger

If you trust the groin, Kelly.
If you think Kelly might be given a one week rest with a slight niggle, Trelaor.

I'd go Treloar personally. Easy draw coming up and a flat track bully. I also don't trust the groin. Go with your gut. If Kelly plays the rest of the season, you might miss out on 50 points total. Too much risk for me.

[backpocket]

McDonald & Mihocek
Or
Crisp & Joel Smith

[Wanderer]

Kelly vs Bont

Kelly - only issue is whether groin injury will flare up again otherwise a gun
Bont - not sure how bad his strain was last week, but he should play more midfield time now without Macrae (and 20K cheaper)

[dmac07]

Kelly vs Bont

Kelly - only issue is whether groin injury will flare up again otherwise a gun
Bont - not sure how bad his strain was last week, but he should play more midfield time now without Macrae (and 20K cheaper)

Kelly for sure

[dmac07]

Last Mid Spot

Fyfe, Mitchell, Martin, Cripps, Oliver, Merrett, Crouch, _______?

Can afford anyone.

Options I'm considering are, Danger, Kelly, Treloar.. anyone else? Leaning to Kelly at this point.

[Mongoose528]

Franklin vs Crisp/Hurley/Hurn

[ubeaut]

Franklin vs Crisp/Hurley/Hurn

I'm grabbing Buddy as my last upgrade. Need to grab a semi POD to try and make up some ground overall.
Higher ceiling and can finish seasons strongly.

[Mongoose528]

Franklin vs Crisp/Hurley/Hurn

I'm grabbing Buddy as my last upgrade. Need to grab a semi POD to try and make up some ground overall.
Higher ceiling and can finish seasons strongly.

I think I'm leaning towards Franklin as well, we've seen him do it in the past.

[jbjimmyjb]

Cripps vs Kelly?

[Blues Blues Blues]

Last Mid Spot

Fyfe, Mitchell, Martin, Cripps, Oliver, Merrett, Crouch, _______?

Can afford anyone.

Options I'm considering are, Danger, Kelly, Treloar.. anyone else? Leaning to Kelly at this point.

Kelly

[billnats]

Joel Smith vs Battle?

[petefisker]

Treloar to who:

Kelly v Higgins v Danger v Neale

Really like Neal's draw, ceiling and PODship

[Thewizz71]

Lloyd v Westhoff  v Crisp to finish the side off.
Can swing Sicily back to allow it to happen.
Leaning towards Lloyd, then Crisp.