Player X vs. Player Y

[RaisyDaisy]

Thanks lads - my gut has always said Hoff but I had Hurley in for the time being - will go with my gut and pick Hoff (which keeps Sicily down back so DPP remains open too)

[ubeaut]

For forward/defense upgrade - Hurn +45k / Wingard +120k / Harris Andrews +10k / Hogan +40k

For midfield upgrade - Oliver or Kelly

Tbh I think all those options are likely to average around the 90-95 mark, although I have my doubts on Andrews as he's unproven.
Wingard usually ends up a 90+ player,and his recent form says to me he'll go back to that average,even with less mid time.
The extra 110k saved over Andrews would surely help too.
Hurn would be the "safe" option, Wingard and Hogan more upside.
Andrews not worth it unless u see him significantly outscoring the others.

Oliver over Kelly.

[SilverLion]

J. Smith vs. Dawson

This is if Garlett isn't named, and will be for M10 (with Ahern at M9, Giro at M11).

[RaisyDaisy]

J. Smith vs. Dawson

This is if Garlett isn't named, and will be for M10 (with Ahern at M9, Giro at M11).

Seeing as you already have Ahern and Giro you probably don't need to spend up on J.Smith - grab a cheapo for M11 and bank more cash to use elsewhere

[Woppa15]

Final mid spot (Macrae replacement).
Neale vs Oliver?

Fyfe. Titch. Danger. Dusty. Cripps. Crouch. Cogs. Neale/Oliver?

Neale in ripper form, Freo have 6 games in Perth for the remainder of the year, Sandi back in the side and only 6% ownership.

Oliver also in ripping form, melb a winning side, Gawn as ruck, 18% ownership.

[billnats]

I'll go Oliver. Even when he stinks it, he still gets points from tackles and can impact scoreboard etc.

Coniglio v Zerrett

[Wanderer]

Hoff vs McDonald - If I go Hoff I can afford to keep Fritsch as F7, but if I go McDonald I will have to keep Ronke as F7

Or I can just go Hoff and keep Ronke at F7 and pocket $92K.

[SilverLion]

Final mid spot (Macrae replacement).
Neale vs Oliver?

Fyfe. Titch. Danger. Dusty. Cripps. Crouch. Cogs. Neale/Oliver?

Neale in ripper form, Freo have 6 games in Perth for the remainder of the year, Sandi back in the side and only 6% ownership.

Oliver also in ripping form, melb a winning side, Gawn as ruck, 18% ownership.

Oliver

I'll go Oliver. Even when he stinks it, he still gets points from tackles and can impact scoreboard etc.

Coniglio v Zerrett

Cogs, but better options than both for 50k ish more.

Hoff vs McDonald - If I go Hoff I can afford to keep Fritsch as F7, but if I go McDonald I will have to keep Ronke as F7

Or I can just go Hoff and keep Ronke at F7 and pocket $92K.

Hoff with Fritsch at F7

[billnats]

I'll go Oliver. Even when he stinks it, he still gets points from tackles and can impact scoreboard etc.

Coniglio v Zerrett

Cogs, but better options than both for 50k ish more.

I was trying to cheap out and save the cash for a rainy day...
But I could go Treloar, Kelly or Neale?

[SilverLion]

I'll go Oliver. Even when he stinks it, he still gets points from tackles and can impact scoreboard etc.

Coniglio v Zerrett

Cogs, but better options than both for 50k ish more.

I was trying to cheap out and save the cash for a rainy day...
But I could go Treloar, Kelly or Neale?

Probably Kelly, but no bad options there :)

[Gandalf123]

Andrews v Hurley

[backpocket]

Harris Andrews v jack Crisp... haven’t seen much of Andrews but he’s scoring well without producing massive stats... what’s getting him the tonnes?

[dmac07]

Harris Andrews v jack Crisp... haven’t seen much of Andrews but he’s scoring well without producing massive stats... what’s getting him the tonnes?

Andrews gets contested intercept marks which is supercoach gold, and he is smart with his ball use as well. I'd still go with Crisp though.

[backpocket]

Harris Andrews v jack Crisp... haven’t seen much of Andrews but he’s scoring well without producing massive stats... what’s getting him the tonnes?

Andrews gets contested intercept marks which is supercoach gold, and he is smart with his ball use as well. I'd still go with Crisp though.

Well then it comes to should I bring in mihocek or Joel smith?
Bringing in mihocek let’s me get Tom McDonald

[ubeaut]

Harris Andrews v jack Crisp... haven’t seen much of Andrews but he’s scoring well without producing massive stats... what’s getting him the tonnes?

Andrews gets contested intercept marks which is supercoach gold, and he is smart with his ball use as well. I'd still go with Crisp though.

Well then it comes to should I bring in mihocek or Joel smith?
Bringing in mihocek let’s me get Tom McDonald

Depends if you're ok with Mihocek getting dropped when Reid returns.
Joel has better JS at this stage imo.