Player X vs. Player Y

[ubeaut]

Simpson vs Yeo trade in possibly get the other next week.

Yeo is preferred but risk of re-injury.
Simpson cheap as, but worried I've missed his big scores has also copped a tag twice(hence his cheapness)

Wish I'd started one of these guys over spud Hibberd...

McDonald is another option but unproven and has been up against weaker teams last 4 games.

Yeo is in stellar form, that one 20 odd has skewed the numbers.

Yes I know that. It's his knee that worries me.

[enzedder]

Heeney  v Oliver

[ubeaut]

Heeney  v Oliver

In what context?
Trading in one this week? Heeney is a must for fwd line, has a good run of opponents coming up and is under 500k.
Oliver obviously scoring better but played with a broken hand, so I'd prioritize Heeney, esp if your fwds are weaker than mids like many.

[enzedder]

Heeney  v Oliver

In what context?
Trading in one this week? Heeney is a must for fwd line, has a good run of opponents coming up and is under 500k.
Oliver obviously scoring better but played with a broken hand, so I'd prioritize Heeney, esp if your fwds are weaker than mids like many.

To trade one in.
T Kelly to Oliver M8
ZGL to Heeney
In terms of points Heeney, unless Kelly spuds again and/or Oliver kills it.
In terms of dollars/BE then Oliver as Kelly will lose significant coin whilst ZGL will still make cash.
Leaning to Oliver as I feel that I can take another week's pain in the fwds and still get Heeney next week (R11)

[ubeaut]

Heeney  v Oliver

In what context?
Trading in one this week? Heeney is a must for fwd line, has a good run of opponents coming up and is under 500k.
Oliver obviously scoring better but played with a broken hand, so I'd prioritize Heeney, esp if your fwds are weaker than mids like many.

To trade one in.
T Kelly to Oliver M8
ZGL to Heeney
In terms of points Heeney, unless Kelly spuds again and/or Oliver kills it.
In terms of dollars/BE then Oliver as Kelly will lose significant coin whilst ZGL will still make cash.
Leaning to Oliver as I feel that I can take another week's pain in the fwds and still get Heeney next week (R11)

I'm really reluctant to trade Kelly.
BE is 120. Was averaging close to 100 before last round. Geelong will bounce back vs Blues then Suns next week. Two scores of 90+ and he goes down to 400k then will make cash again.
I regret trading Holman and Kelly is much more consistent.
I'd at least wait a week as Oliver has that hand issue. You'd hate for Kelly to outscore Oliver which is totally possible given their respective match ups.
I traded Holman to Crouch, Crouch got 92 + 0, Holman 50 + 120!

[enzedder]

Heeney  v Oliver

In what context?
Trading in one this week? Heeney is a must for fwd line, has a good run of opponents coming up and is under 500k.
Oliver obviously scoring better but played with a broken hand, so I'd prioritize Heeney, esp if your fwds are weaker than mids like many.

To trade one in.
T Kelly to Oliver M8
ZGL to Heeney
In terms of points Heeney, unless Kelly spuds again and/or Oliver kills it.
In terms of dollars/BE then Oliver as Kelly will lose significant coin whilst ZGL will still make cash.
Leaning to Oliver as I feel that I can take another week's pain in the fwds and still get Heeney next week (R11)

I'm really reluctant to trade Kelly.
BE is 120. Was averaging close to 100 before last round. Geelong will bounce back vs Blues then Suns next week. Two scores of 90+ and he goes down to 400k then will make cash again.
I regret trading Holman and Kelly is much more consistent.
I'd at least wait a week as Oliver has that hand issue. You'd hate for Kelly to outscore Oliver which is totally possible given their respective match ups.
I traded Holman to Crouch, Crouch got 92 + 0, Holman 50 + 120!

I didn't intend to trade Kelly so soon but his 48 has changed my thinking.
Getting Heeney for him though (not Oliver) as he is the must have of the two and it opens up DPP for me again which is handy with the byes looming.

[Chrispy75]

question 1:

Ridley vs Rice.

With bye rounds coming, who appears to be likely to play rounds 12-14?

Question 2:

Alternative plan using DPP magic would be getting Phillips in the mids.  Is this better than question 1?

[GoSaints3]

question 1:

Ridley vs Rice.

With bye rounds coming, who appears to be likely to play rounds 12-14?

Question 2:

Alternative plan using DPP magic would be getting Phillips in the mids.  Is this better than question 1?

I would take Phillips. Get one of the other two next week once you have had another look at them

[tkringle]

Upgrade Finlayson or Murray? the other will still be around for a couple of weeks at least

[Eric the Eel]

Hurn or Simpson or Ryan (Essentially any defender at Simpson’s price or less)
- Upgrading Hibberd

[Ringo]

Upgrade Finlayson or Murray? the other will still be around for a couple of weeks at least

Would do Murray as keeping Finlayson also gives you the DPP when trading later as well.

[Ringo]

Hurn or Simpson or Ryan (Essentially any defender at Simpson’s price or less)
- Upgrading Hibberd

Simpson from that list.

[mzunguman]

Howe or Webster???

[Hazza09]

Heeney v Sicily v Zorko?

[Hazza09]

Howe or Webster???

howe