D4

[meow meow]

Naughton got slaughtered by a VFL player today. I wouldn't be confident of him playing regularly and I wouldn't be confident of his scoring ability, not to start on field.

Scored 75 today which is good

Not sure I'd be running with a rookie at D3 though

If he plays round 1 and gets well beaten you'd better hope that Young has a shocker in the VFL. Or maybe Wood goes back and a guy like Wallis takes Wood's spot in the forward line. Offensively Naughton looks okay (hence the score) but he can't give up 5 goals a match and keep his spot.

[Bully]

Naughton got slaughtered by a VFL player today. I wouldn't be confident of him playing regularly and I wouldn't be confident of his scoring ability, not to start on field.

Scored 75 today which is good

Not sure I'd be running with a rookie at D3 though

If he plays round 1 and gets well beaten you'd better hope that Young has a shocker in the VFL. Or maybe Wood goes back and a guy like Wallis takes Wood's spot in the forward line. Offensively Naughton looks okay (hence the score) but he can't give up 5 goals a match and keep his spot.

Coffield vs Naughton will be an interesting choice. With Murphy looking like a non-starter will have to pick 1 I think.

[RaisyDaisy]

Coffield vs Naughton will be an interesting choice. With Murphy looking like a non-starter will have to pick 1 I think.

I dunno, I reckon we can field Murray, Doedee and Finlayson and then we just need 2 of Payne, Stoddart, Murphy, Keeffe etc to fill the bench meaning we can pass on all the 150k+ rookies all together

[Bully]

Coffield vs Naughton will be an interesting choice. With Murphy looking like a non-starter will have to pick 1 I think.

I dunno, I reckon we can field Murray, Doedee and Finlayson and then we just need 2 of Payne, Stoddart, Murphy, Keeffe etc to fill the bench meaning we can pass on all the 150k+ rookies all together

Fingers crossed, Keeffe is the one who would be huge value for those with Sicily.

[hawkers65]

D4 is 100% a rookie for me. Plenty of options down back who can score and score quite well as we've seen. ATM i have Coffield and Naughts over the basement ones tho

[enzedder]

Coffield looks a Round 1 lock.
I've seen both Saints JLT games and he's been super impressive. He's my D4.

[RaisyDaisy]

Currently going with Doedee at D4, with Murray and Finalyson also on field

[meow meow]

O'Shea will average 180 so I think I'll slot him in at D4

[Torpedo10]

O'Shea was in my initial draft, but with the plethora of Defender rookies coming out of the woodwork I think you'll find it hard to fit him in without compromising somewhere else. One less uber premium, perhaps?

[RaisyDaisy]

O'Shea was in my initial draft, but with the plethora of Defender rookies coming out of the woodwork I think you'll find it hard to fit him in without compromising somewhere else. One less uber premium, perhaps?

For the time being, I think it's probably best to just pick one of O'Shea, Coffield or Naughton just as a place holder for the time being, and then you lock one of them come Round 1. Doing this allows you to lock in your structure as at least 1 of them should line up Round 1, and in the meantime you put all the cheaper def rookies you like behind them

[Mat0369]

Something I'm thinking of rolling with

D3 - Byrne
D4 - Coffield
D5 - Murray
D6 - Finlayson
D7 - Naughton
D8 - Doedee

Then I can add Tom Mitchell into my midfield and it looks really good.

[HoleMeal]

Something I'm thinking of rolling with

D3 - Byrne
D4 - CoffieldKeefe
D5 - Murray
D6 - Finlayson
D7 - Naughton
D8 - Doedee

M8 - Coffield

Then I can add Tom Mitchell into my midfield and it looks really good.

This is what I am doing.

Allows me DPP with Keefe and Sicily.
and also Coff and Finlayson.

[Mat0369]

I don't think Keefe is in the Giants best 22

[Keeper27]

I don't think Keefe is in the Giants best 22

[Bully]

I don't think Keefe is in the Giants best 22

Has been training with the rucks so maybe they plan to use him as relief ruckman.