Top 2/5 rucks, 2018 Thread

[North Melbournes Finest]

Grundy is looking like the best preseason pick I've ever had for supercoach (since day 1).

[quinny88]

Grundy is on fire! Well done to anyone that jumped on

[SilverLion]

Bit the bullet and traded Grundy in before the game .... nice  :D

Who for?

I started Ryder expecting to use 2 trades for his bye and when he got injured I got Witts ( stupid trade ) just could not afford Grundy I could this week so traded him in for Witts figured it's still 2 trades and I have avoided all the other carnage , worked out ok  ;)

Interesting...

Think you were a bit harsh trading out Witts so soon. Last week was his first ever sub 70 since joining the suns IIRC.

Though I guess you can't complain with Grundy so far haha.

[shaker]

Bit the bullet and traded Grundy in before the game .... nice  :D

Who for?

I started Ryder expecting to use 2 trades for his bye and when he got injured I got Witts ( stupid trade ) just could not afford Grundy I could this week so traded him in for Witts figured it's still 2 trades and I have avoided all the other carnage , worked out ok  ;)

Interesting...

Think you were a bit harsh trading out Witts so soon. Last week was his first ever sub 70 since joining the suns IIRC.

Though I guess you can't complain with Grundy so far haha.

Yeah maybe you are right about Witts but I had a chance to grab Grundy this week with only Ryan to fix next week it might not be possible so it worked out well  :)

[Bully]

Bit the bullet and traded Grundy in before the game .... nice  :D

Who for?

I started Ryder expecting to use 2 trades for his bye and when he got injured I got Witts ( stupid trade ) just could not afford Grundy I could this week so traded him in for Witts figured it's still 2 trades and I have avoided all the other carnage , worked out ok  ;)

Interesting...

Think you were a bit harsh trading out Witts so soon. Last week was his first ever sub 70 since joining the suns IIRC.

Though I guess you can't complain with Grundy so far haha.

Yeah maybe you are right about Witts but I had a chance to grab Grundy this week with only Ryan to fix next week it might not be possible so it worked out well  :)

Decisive trading, I like it. Grundy will be a good pick this year.

[ubeaut]

So much for the "he doesn't score well with Cox in the team"
He's got the most potential of any ruck to improve, is very mobile and athletic for a big guy.
Spewing I doubted him with the Cox factor and picked Goldy. Can't see Goldy getting back to his best tbh.
Would have made the trade if I didn't have so many other issues.

[Bully]

So much for the "he doesn't score well with Cox in the team"
He's got the most potential of any ruck to improve, is very mobile and athletic for a big guy.
Spewing I doubted him with the Cox factor and picked Goldy. Can't see Goldy getting back to his best tbh.
Would have made the trade if I didn't have so many other issues.

I had Grundy in there for a brief moment but ultimately went for Goldy. Very much open to trading this week if Goldy has a another shocker.

[SilverLion]

So much for the "he doesn't score well with Cox in the team"
He's got the most potential of any ruck to improve, is very mobile and athletic for a big guy.
Spewing I doubted him with the Cox factor and picked Goldy. Can't see Goldy getting back to his best tbh.
Would have made the trade if I didn't have so many other issues.

Don't go there...

I picked Grundy last year expecting him break out like he seems to have this year, and although he was good, he didn't.

Buckley also played Cox in the ruck for a lot of last year, and the games where he did, Grundy scored poor.

This year, Cox is playing almost exclusively forward and Grundy is breaking out. I didn't pick Grundy again because I figured Cox would continue taking a share of the ruck.

Gotta love Collingwood :-X

[crowls]

Thinking that with Grundy only 24 & entering his prime years this could be the big breakout year. Can't see anyone stealing his thunder, Gawn & Grundy top 2 in my opinion.

+1

[DunnyBrush]

Need 2 of Gawn, Grundy, Martin, NinNat theres the top 4.

Goldy is shower.

[Hazza09]

Goldy has to go! Enough is Enough!

[fuzeski]

Goldy has to go! Enough is Enough!

[enzedder]

Considering a Jacobs to Grundy trade for next week.
As things stand right now it's a done deal. Just depends on what happens with today's games (no injuries) and a positive update/news on J Kelly.

[crowls]

I made a mistake.  Thought his personal issues were behind him.,  Goldy is out.  Grundy in this week.   
Was a pleasure watching Grundy on Friday night.   Great tap work, and then 25 possessions as well.   

[Torpedo10]

Goldy has a good bye, Grundy doesn't.

Hopefully Goldy doesn't get dropped, because unless he is, there are more pressing issues for my side personally than a Ruckman averaging 90.