Top 2/5 rucks, 2018 Thread

[Rusty00]

Based on Big Boy’s performance today if Geelong don’t bring back Smith and stick with Stanley, NicNat will score 200 next week.............in 50% game time

[ubeaut]

Based on Big Boy’s performance today if Geelong don’t bring back Smith and stick with Stanley, NicNat will score 200 next week.............in 50% game time

Why the hell they would play Stanley as sole ruck is beyond me. Would have been better off with Buzza lol.
Ratugolea out hurt too. Hawkins was useless. I'd be playing Buzza and Smith over Stanley and Hawkins.

[jfitty]

Sandilands; stick or twist?

Do you have much cash in the bank?

I'd almost consider trading him if the rest of your team is settled. Breakeven of 136, which isn't too high, but don't want him to pump out another shocker score and be out of reach of any ruckman to sideways trade to (NicNat/Nank).

[Mongoose528]

Sandilands; stick or twist?

Do you have much cash in the bank?

I'd almost consider trading him if the rest of your team is settled. Breakeven of 136, which isn't too high, but don't want him to pump out another shocker score and be out of reach of any ruckman to sideways trade to (NicNat/Nank).

I've only got 30k in the bank, so if I get rid of him, I'd have to trade one of Cameron, Armitage, Lobb or Naughton.

I'm just thinking of doing Cameron -> Olango
and Sandi -> Goldstein

[SilverLion]

Expecting Stef to bounce back this week against Dixon/Westhoff in a big way.

[Frankfaust]

Byrne -> Bonner


Hibberd - > Simpson


Worth doing both?

[GoLions]

Byrne -> Bonner


Hibberd - > Simpson


Worth doing both?

Big Dawson Simpson?

[Frankfaust]

Byrne -> Bonner


Hibberd - > Simpson


Worth doing both?

Big Dawson Simpson?

Ha! That would be a whole other pile of p**! No, Kade, I mean.

[SilverLion]

Byrne -> Bonner


Hibberd - > Simpson


Worth doing both?

Big Dawson Simpson?

Ha! That would be a whole other pile of p**! No, Kade, I mean.

Think GL was stirring ya because you posted that in the Rucks thread ;)

Fwiw, Byrne to Bonner is worth it, Hibberd to Simpson I feel is just getting caught up in 2 weeks of good form by one, and bad form by the other. Should average around the same come season's end.

[Frankfaust]

Oops. Apologies. I got my entry tangled up - doing so much reading here. Mea culpa. Can someone shift it? Or not worth it, probably.

[Frankfaust]

Byrne -> Bonner


Hibberd - > Simpson


Worth doing both?

Big Dawson Simpson?

Ha! That would be a whole other pile of p**! No, Kade, I mean.

Think GL was stirring ya because you posted that in the Rucks thread ;)

Fwiw, Byrne to Bonner is worth it, Hibberd to Simpson I feel is just getting caught up in 2 weeks of good form by one, and bad form by the other. Should average around the same come season's end.

Thanks Silverlion. Appreciated.

[ubeaut]

Byrne -> Bonner


Hibberd - > Simpson


Worth doing both?

Big Dawson Simpson?

Ha! That would be a whole other pile of p**! No, Kade, I mean.

Think GL was stirring ya because you posted that in the Rucks thread ;)

Fwiw, Byrne to Bonner is worth it, Hibberd to Simpson I feel is just getting caught up in 2 weeks of good form by one, and bad form by the other. Should average around the same come season's end.

I think it's more to do with role than form. Simpson is the man without Doch, whereas Hibberd is taking much less kick ins and less interceptions due to Lever.
I way over thought Simmo trying to find reasons not to pick him (age,only avgs 90 ) when its quite simple. No Doch ='Simmo kills it.

[Nige]

The Nank pick has worked well the first two weeks, the boy looks good.

Has a good challenge against Big Boy this week, but I'm still expecting at least a 90.

[Huttabito]

Kreuzer owes me big time the next few weeks.

[SilverLion]

Soo Todd Goldstien

???