Top 2/5 rucks, 2018 Thread

[Money Shot]

My question is what is more important Cameron playing and averaging 60 for the first ten rounds or a donut for a captains loop hole???

Mids are too valuable to have a donut and there is no 102k priced players with D/F eligability to float with Sicily.

So my thinking is it is Olango or nothing in terms of floating donut.

[meow meow]

I started Witts last year and it was one of my greatest supercoach picks, barely anyone had him. Feel like i should count myself lucky and not try it two years straight with Lycett hahaha

I thought everyone had him.

[quinny88]

My question is what is more important Cameron playing and averaging 60 for the first ten rounds or a donut for a captains loop hole???

Mids are too valuable to have a donut and there is no 102k priced players with D/F eligability to float with Sicily.

So my thinking is it is Olango or nothing in terms of floating donut.

Depends if you have set and forget rucks or not. If you do I would just go with Olango to use the captains loophole but if you have a riskier pick like Lycett then Cameron becomes very important

[quinny88]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

[Money Shot]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

Think a lot is riding on JLT2

[quinny88]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

Think a lot is riding on JLT2

Don't think Sinclair will play in it with his ankle injury so we might not get the full picture but hopefully Cameron has a big game

[TomK]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

Sinkers #1 with others pinch hitting, Reid, Towers, Aliir all capable

[Levi434]

Hickey, Lycett, Cameron locked in for me

[Money Shot]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

Think a lot is riding on JLT2

Don't think Sinclair will play in it with his ankle injury so we might not get the full picture but hopefully Cameron has a big game

Sydney are versing GWS which won't really give a great indication either as Lobb won't be playing.

[quinny88]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

Think a lot is riding on JLT2

Don't think Sinclair will play in it with his ankle injury so we might not get the full picture but hopefully Cameron has a big game

Sydney are versing GWS which won't really give a great indication either as Lobb won't be playing.

That's true. Still, a big game from him will give the Sydney selectors something to think about for round 1. Especially considering they play Westcoast round 1 and will likely want 2 rucks if they are coming up against Nicnat and Lycett

[rebird]

Naismith - ACL http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-07/huge-blow-for-swans-with-ruckman-naismith-to-miss-2018
Cameron moves up the list

OOps

[quinny88]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

Sinkers #1 with others pinch hitting, Reid, Towers, Aliir all capable

Sinkers has sunk - ACL http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-07/huge-blow-for-swans-with-ruckman-naismith-to-miss-2018
Cameron moves up the list

Sinkers = Sinclair

[GoLions]

My question is does this even mean Cameron gets a game or does Sinclair just become the #1 ruck and have others pinch hit?

Sinkers #1 with others pinch hitting, Reid, Towers, Aliir all capable

Sinkers has sunk - ACL http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-07/huge-blow-for-swans-with-ruckman-naismith-to-miss-2018
Cameron moves up the list

Sinkers != Naismith ;)

[ubeaut]

My question is what is more important Cameron playing and averaging 60 for the first ten rounds or a donut for a captains loop hole???

Mids are too valuable to have a donut and there is no 102k priced players with D/F eligability to float with Sicily.

So my thinking is it is Olango or nothing in terms of floating donut.

Depends if you have set and forget rucks or not. If you do I would just go with Olango to use the captains loophole but if you have a riskier pick like Lycett then Cameron becomes very important

If Cameron is named u just about have to pick him. Set and forget sounds great in theory but if a 1-2 week injury happens to one of your guns then you'll kick yourself for having to trade or cop a donut when u could have picked Cameron. Last year we had Nank to swing into the rucks, there's no-one this year.
There's Murphy or Ballenden for only 15k more than Olango. Picking Sicily even more worth it now.

[Levi434]

Agree with ubeaut. Nothing worse than coping a donut.