Top 5/10 Fowards, 2018 Thread.

[Money Shot]

Vote for top 5

List top 10

Heeney
Greene
Franklin
Billings
Dahlhous
Barlow
Lobb
Bennell
Menegola
Kennedy

My big call and it is very big is that Bennell will be a top 10 forward come seasons end.

Lobb is at number 7 assuming he is the number 1 ruck at GWS.

Barlow and Dahlhous to go back to a 95+ average this season.

Big drop is Dixon who won't be a top 15 forward at the end of the season.

This was much harder than the defenders haha.

[shaker]

Heeney
Greene
Billings
Menegola
Dahlhaus
Franklin
Gray
Mundy
Wallis
Lynch  GC

Yes much harder than the backs Lobb will be if he lone rucks but don't know that so left him out

[crowls]

Rated by Average or Total points?


total points
Billings
Greene
Barlow
Franklin
Heeney
JJK
Lobb
Wallis
Bennell
Dahlhaus

[Money Shot]

Rated by Average or Total points?


total points
Billings
Greene
Barlow
Franklin
Heeney
JJK
Lobb
Wallis
Bennell
Dahlhaus

Total points would be a better representation.

[quinny88]

Total points is harder to predict because you're guessing at injuries and suspensions but on average I would say

Heeney - 102
Barlow - 100
Billings - 98
Franklin - 98
Greene - 96
Menegola - 96

[Ringo]

Total points is harder to predict because you're guessing at injuries and suspensions but on average I would say

Heeney - 102
Barlow - 100
Billings - 98
Franklin - 98
Greene - 96
Menegola - 96

Reckon Toby McLean could go 95/100 if role still the same as second half of season. 

[SilverLion]

Menegola
Heeney
Franklin
Billings
Lobb
Greene
Barlow
JJK
Wingard
Dahlhaus
McLean

[Grufflez]

Heeney
Billings
Buddy
Lobb
McLean

I think will make top 10

[Peter]

Barlow will make top 6, but bye buggers it up for SC and RDT

[crowls]

Heeney
Billings
Buddy
Lobb
McLean

I think will make top 10

Plus Barlow.    Likely to be top six at year end.   

[Grufflez]

Heeney
Billings
Buddy
Lobb
McLean

I think will make top 10

Plus Barlow.    Likely to be top six at year end.

He should be there abouts, but i'll wait and see how the new coach uses him in jlt, bit slow and not a great user
of the footy, maybe GCS will want to get their midfield structures right from the get go this time, get the midfield core that the want
moving forward to gel asap, is Barlow in those longer term plans?

[crowls]

Heeney
Billings
Buddy
Lobb
McLean

I think will make top 10

Plus Barlow.    Likely to be top six at year end.

He should be there abouts, but i'll wait and see how the new coach uses him in jlt, bit slow and not a great user
of the footy, maybe GCS will want to get their midfield structures right from the get go this time, get the midfield core that the want
moving forward to gel asap, is Barlow in those longer term plans?

Sorry Gruff, got to disagree,  only value in Barlow is as a mid player.  His last couple of years at Freo demonstrated that.   So GCS understood what they were getting when he moved.  He will be full time mid and be great value for SC coaches.

[quinny88]

Heeney
Billings
Buddy
Lobb
McLean

I think will make top 10

Plus Barlow.    Likely to be top six at year end.

He should be there abouts, but i'll wait and see how the new coach uses him in jlt, bit slow and not a great user
of the footy, maybe GCS will want to get their midfield structures right from the get go this time, get the midfield core that the want
moving forward to gel asap, is Barlow in those longer term plans?

Sorry Gruff, got to disagree,  only value in Barlow is as a mid player.  His last couple of years at Freo demonstrated that.   So GCS understood what they were getting when he moved.  He will be full time mid and be great value for SC coaches.

Yeah Barlow has to play mid. They need some experience in there and hes pretty much useless anywhere else so it's either play him mid or don't play him at all

[Peter]

Barlow will play midfield, but how can be relevant for SC with his bye, unless prepared to give away 40-50 points with a rookie or you swing him to midfield and hope you still have a decent rookie. Surely only relevant for AF?

[Money Shot]

Barlow will play midfield, but how can be relevant for SC with his bye, unless prepared to give away 40-50 points with a rookie or you swing him to midfield and hope you still have a decent rookie. Surely only relevant for AF?

+1  ;D ;D ;D