Top 5/10 Defenders, 2018 thread.

[strikeforce]

Tom Mac as a top 6 forward or defender? Whats the chances?

[jvalles69]

Tom Mac as a top 6 forward or defender? Whats the chances?

I'm tossing up him or Buddy this week. Mac suits my byes better, but Buddy higher ceiling.  :-\

[strikeforce]

Tom Mac as a top 6 forward or defender? Whats the chances?

I'm tossing up him or Buddy this week. Mac suits my byes better, but Buddy higher ceiling.  :-\

Exactly my trade thoughts to. Buddy's heel worry's me a little but like you said, Huge ceiling

[ubeaut]

Really tempted by T.Mac.
Playing on the wing a bit too I think?
However his opposition has been Saints,Bombers,Suns and and Blues.
Might see how he goes against the Crows first.

[iZander]

Tom Mac as a top 6 forward or defender? Whats the chances?

I'm tossing up him or Buddy this week. Mac suits my byes better, but Buddy higher ceiling.  :-\

Exactly my trade thoughts to. Buddy's heel worry's me a little but like you said, Huge ceiling

Wouldnt go Buddy if i were you, that heel im almost certain will make him miss more games in the future

Im one of those who started with him and held :(

[Ricochet]

Tom Mac as a top 6 forward or defender? Whats the chances?

I'm tossing up him or Buddy this week. Mac suits my byes better, but Buddy higher ceiling.  :-\

Exactly my trade thoughts to. Buddy's heel worry's me a little but like you said, Huge ceiling

Wouldnt go Buddy if i were you, that heel im almost certain will make him miss more games in the future

Im one of those who started with him and held :(

100% agree. Too risky for me

[SilverLion]

:-\

To all the Brisbane supporters.
What are your thoughts on Harris Andrews ??

???

Would've been a great starting pick but don't think he'll be in the top 10 come season's end.

He's getting better and better though, maybe next year?

[RaisyDaisy]

Was going to bring in TMac this week, but might delay that move and see how he pulls up over the next couple of weeks after today's toe concern

[RaisyDaisy]

Need to bring in a prem defender this week, and to my surprise it needs to be a R14 player

Lloyd and Webster are the top two, but also don't mind the look of Luke Ryan for 60k cheaper

Which one?

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)

Currently have Laird,  Hurley,  Webster, and will add Yeo and Sicily after their byes and then hope to hell Sicily doesn't get white line fever, and the rest don't get injured.
I'd go Webster RD, although I'd probably be inclined to put this decision off if you could in order to see if the Mills injury influences Lloyds role at all.

;)

[Bully]

Need to bring in a prem defender this week, and to my surprise it needs to be a R14 player

Lloyd and Webster are the top two, but also don't mind the look of Luke Ryan for 60k cheaper

Which one?

Think you have to take Lloyd.

[petefisker]

Really want to bring in Yeo this week as it suits my byes slot.. being R12. As apposed to Lloyd or Howe. When do we get confirmation Yeo got on the plane? I suppose even then he may still pull out..

[shaker]

Really want to bring in Yeo this week as it suits my byes slot.. being R12. As apposed to Lloyd or Howe. When do we get confirmation Yeo got on the plane? I suppose even then he may still pull out..

They say he's playing you'll know for sure mid day Sunday

[Ringo]

Already confirmed on plane.

adrian barich
‏Verified account @adrianbarich

Elliott Yeo is on the plane to Melbourne @7NewsPerth

[bonebones]

Really want to bring in Yeo this week as it suits my byes slot.. being R12. As apposed to Lloyd or Howe. When do we get confirmation Yeo got on the plane? I suppose even then he may still pull out..

A certain starter according to Simpson
https://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/west-coast-eagles/elliot-yeo-a-certain-starter-against-hawks-says-west-coast-coach-adam-simpson-ng-b88847193z