The Value Forwards

Started by Money Shot, December 14, 2017, 03:25:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

kosduras

ill be taking 2 of ah chee bennell and lobb, perrhaps all three if they play well in the jlt,

one person that hasnt been discussed much is Jordan De goey, many people have been tagging him as a break out chance in recent years but no talk this year?

79 average after a rough start to the year and a broken arm, last 6 games he posted 6 scores 100+

with a full pre season and maybe a few more midfield minutes any chance he goes 90+ ???

had my eye on him since late last year as a potential get to either upgrade or tred water until the better scorers pop up-??

crowls

Quote from: kosduras on December 19, 2017, 05:49:46 PM
ill be taking 2 of ah chee bennell and lobb, perrhaps all three if they play well in the jlt,

one person that hasnt been discussed much is Jordan De goey, many people have been tagging him as a break out chance in recent years but no talk this year?

79 average after a rough start to the year and a broken arm, last 6 games he posted 6 scores 100+

with a full pre season and maybe a few more midfield minutes any chance he goes 90+ ???

had my eye on him since late last year as a potential get to either upgrade or tred water until the better scorers pop up-??
de goey certainly is in breakout territory and is in the watchlist.    likely a good POD.  If he has a decent JLT people will jump all over him.   

Money Shot

Quote from: crowls on December 19, 2017, 06:30:48 PM
Quote from: kosduras on December 19, 2017, 05:49:46 PM
ill be taking 2 of ah chee bennell and lobb, perrhaps all three if they play well in the jlt,

one person that hasnt been discussed much is Jordan De goey, many people have been tagging him as a break out chance in recent years but no talk this year?

79 average after a rough start to the year and a broken arm, last 6 games he posted 6 scores 100+

with a full pre season and maybe a few more midfield minutes any chance he goes 90+ ???

had my eye on him since late last year as a potential get to either upgrade or tred water until the better scorers pop up-??
de goey certainly is in breakout territory and is in the watchlist.    likely a good POD.  If he has a decent JLT people will jump all over him.
I have thought about De Goey my self and he is definitely on my watch list. The only problem I see with De Goey is for just 30-50k more you can get someone like a Barlow or a Dahlhous who I trust much more.

enzedder

Quote from: Money Shot on December 20, 2017, 02:54:54 PM
Quote from: crowls on December 19, 2017, 06:30:48 PM
Quote from: kosduras on December 19, 2017, 05:49:46 PM
ill be taking 2 of ah chee bennell and lobb, perrhaps all three if they play well in the jlt,

one person that hasnt been discussed much is Jordan De goey, many people have been tagging him as a break out chance in recent years but no talk this year?

79 average after a rough start to the year and a broken arm, last 6 games he posted 6 scores 100+

with a full pre season and maybe a few more midfield minutes any chance he goes 90+ ???

had my eye on him since late last year as a potential get to either upgrade or tred water until the better scorers pop up-??
de goey certainly is in breakout territory and is in the watchlist.    likely a good POD.  If he has a decent JLT people will jump all over him.
I have thought about De Goey my self and he is definitely on my watch list. The only problem I see with De Goey is for just 30-50k more you can get someone like a Barlow or a Dahlhous who I trust much more.
Yep. I’m not going near DeGoey. Those other options you say are much more appealing.

PiPies

Quote from: kosduras on December 19, 2017, 05:49:46 PM
ill be taking 2 of ah chee bennell and lobb, perrhaps all three if they play well in the jlt,

one person that hasnt been discussed much is Jordan De goey, many people have been tagging him as a break out chance in recent years but no talk this year?

79 average after a rough start to the year and a broken arm, last 6 games he posted 6 scores 100+

with a full pre season and maybe a few more midfield minutes any chance he goes 90+ ???

had my eye on him since late last year as a potential get to either upgrade or tred water until the better scorers pop up-??

I see the stat of last 6 games 100+ posted a bit, footy wire shows 3 100+ and 3 around the 50 mark. All comes down to role IMO, Pies have too many mids for me to touch him.

Peter

You have to have Lobb, based on GWS form in finals and based on their start

meow meow

Crameri will be a better pick than Harley.

Peter

And he’s a rookie, so not a great wrap for Harley

eaglesman

Quote from: Grufflez on December 15, 2017, 09:59:04 PM
Quote from: iZander on December 15, 2017, 02:09:57 PM
Quote from: Holz on December 15, 2017, 10:16:20 AM
basically got all of them at the top of my radar except Lobb 400k is too much. Dont like the forward premos either so makes it an even early decision.

Always take the risk on guys who are a risk of injury over guys who are risk of scoring.

People are punting on Menegola at 550k who will be good but its just as risky.

Menegola  + 120k fwd + 120k fwd

give me

Bennel + Ah Chee + Christon +50k in the bank at this stage.



lets say

90 60 60

v

75 75 75

remember the rookies you are getting are not the best 2-3 options its the 4-5 best fwd rookies you are picking up.
IF lobb lines up sole ruck round 1 then hes less of a scoring risk than Christo/Ah chee and without the injury risk. IMO anyway

Exactly, i really really just can't believe Holz that you see no value in Lobb, his sample games as sole ruck were great sc results.
Other sc sites have shown stats that Lobb also has a fantastic HOTA% which after the ruck scoring system changes a few year back
is pretty much the be all end all to the top rucks scoring, 5 points if it lands on a midfielders chest, none if you shark it.

Lobb will be extremely highly owned this year. LOCK

quinny88

Has there been a word said about Bennells pre season prior to Xmas?
Freo seem to be really quiet on him which I'm not sure if its a good or bad thing

Peter


Grufflez

Quote from: meow meow on December 31, 2017, 08:40:24 PM
Crameri will be a better pick than Harley.

What about your man Toby Mclean?
I have replaced Walters with him at the moment.

quinny88

And there it is.. Bennell apparently got in a fight at a night club and was a no show at training. Surely the last straw

enzedder

Quote from: quinny88 on January 08, 2018, 10:59:25 PM
And there it is.. Bennell apparently got in a fight at a night club and was a no show at training. Surely the last straw
Will be interesting to see how it unfolds.
He’s been a very naughty boy.

Money Shot

Quote from: enzedder on January 09, 2018, 06:21:12 AM
Quote from: quinny88 on January 08, 2018, 10:59:25 PM
And there it is.. Bennell apparently got in a fight at a night club and was a no show at training. Surely the last straw
Will be interesting to see how it unfolds.
He’s been a very naughty boy.
Out goes Bennell (at this stage anyways) and in comes Ah Chee or Christensen. Don't know who I like better. Both could average 80 or so but one is a high chance of getting injured and the other could be destined for a 60 average if he doesn't play in the right position. decisions decisions hey.