2018 rookies

[RaisyDaisy]

Smith or Ridley... Who would you go early on if you had to take one?

Smith has DPP right? I reckon I will go early on him, definitely going early on one of them because I can't get Philips

[Gigantor]

Smith or Ridley... Who would you go early on if you had to take one?

Smith has DPP right? I reckon I will go early on him, definitely going early on one of them because I can't get Philips

Nope wrong Melbourne Smith, I made the same mistake haha

Joel has FWD/DEF DPP Tim FWD only

[MontyJnr]

Smith or Ridley... Who would you go early on if you had to take one?

Smith has DPP right? I reckon I will go early on him, definitely going early on one of them because I can't get Philips

Nah Tim Smith is FWD only. Ridley is DEF only.

[RaisyDaisy]

Smith or Ridley... Who would you go early on if you had to take one?

Smith has DPP right? I reckon I will go early on him, definitely going early on one of them because I can't get Philips

Nope wrong Melbourne Smith, I made the same mistake haha

Joel has FWD/DEF DPP Tim FWD only

Billings to Smith sounds like a solid upgrade then!

[Bully]

Smith or Ridley... Who would you go early on if you had to take one?

Smith has DPP right? I reckon I will go early on him, definitely going early on one of them because I can't get Philips

Nope wrong Melbourne Smith, I made the same mistake haha

Joel has FWD/DEF DPP Tim FWD only

Billings to Smith sounds like a solid upgrade then!

Billings to anyone is a solid upgrade.

[AaronKirk]

Ridley has looked like a 100 game defender on debut today. Should get a good run at it. 123k defender.

What happens when Hurley returns?
Does Hooker go fwd again or do we play him,Hurls and Ridley back?
McKernan and Daniher will influence his JS too I'd say.

I think given their athleticism we can play Hurls, Hooker and Ridley back. As well as McKernan played he will be straight out when Danhier is back imo.

[Big Mac]

Reckon it might be better to wait on Tim Smith if possible

SC score might look attractive but he was probably our worst player in the first half and is only in the side due to Weideman getting injured. Pedo also kicked 6 goals in the VFL on saturday so Smith has a couple players on his heels

[smashbox]

Ok so who are the rookies this week? Any must haves?

We all thought Phillips was one, but he didn’t set the world on fire in his 2nd game. Did anyone watch?

[Rusty00]

Ok so who are the rookies this week? Any must haves?

We all thought Phillips was one, but he didn’t set the world on fire in his 2nd game. Did anyone watch?

He was solid without being spactacular. The problem is that St Kilda are getting trounced each week, meaning team selection will probably regularly be a revolving door.

[fanTCfool]

Reckon it might be better to wait on Tim Smith if possible

SC score might look attractive but he was probably our worst player in the first half and is only in the side due to Weideman getting injured. Pedo also kicked 6 goals in the VFL on saturday so Smith has a couple players on his heels

How long is Weideman out for?

[sammy123]

Ok so who are the rookies this week? Any must haves?

We all thought Phillips was one, but he didn’t set the world on fire in his 2nd game. Did anyone watch?

He was solid without being spactacular. The problem is that St Kilda are getting trounced each week, meaning team selection will probably regularly be a revolving door.

Think his efficiency was down hence poor score

[john23132]

Not a plethora of options this week, personally not going early on any either so no downgrades for me

[jvalles69]

Ridley or Rice?  ???

[Gigantor]

Ridley or Rice?  ???

Fantasy Freako
‏
Team-high 8 intercept possessions for Rice on debut for St Kilda last round. I'd look at him instead of Ridley if you're going early on a defender rookie. #SuperCoach


But he did only score 55  :-\

[jvalles69]

Ridley or Rice?  ???

Fantasy Freako
‏
Team-high 8 intercept possessions for Rice on debut for St Kilda last round. I'd look at him instead of Ridley if you're going early on a defender rookie. #SuperCoach


But he did only score 55  :-\

Lol, this is the tweet I saw prior to asking the question!  Going with Ridley at this stage, might have to jump on both though, 1 this week and 1 next week.