2018 rookies

[RaisyDaisy]

If Naughton spuds again, unless trading to Bonner, is it a case of waiting for Richards to get a third game, or maybe Mirra or Mihocek? I don't see any other options.

Pretty much

Or you could just leave Naughton as your D7/8 as his JS should be pretty good

[Ringo]

If Naughton spuds again, unless trading to Bonner, is it a case of waiting for Richards to get a third game, or maybe Mirra or Mihocek? I don't see any other options.

Pretty much

Or you could just leave Naughton as your D7/8 as his JS should be pretty good

This is sound advice especially if you do not have Keeffe for DPP with Sicily. JS is sound and although may not be a heavy scorer OK to sit and D8 and use as needed.

[SilverLion]

If Naughton spuds again, unless trading to Bonner, is it a case of waiting for Richards to get a third game, or maybe Mirra or Mihocek? I don't see any other options.

Pretty much

Or you could just leave Naughton as your D7/8 as his JS should be pretty good

This is sound advice especially if you do not have Keeffe for DPP with Sicily. JS is sound and although may not be a heavy scorer OK to sit and D8 and use as needed.

Would it be reasonable to consider bringing in Murphy for Naughton this week? (Didn't start him myself, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray, Naughton are D4-8 for me).

[Ringo]

If Naughton spuds again, unless trading to Bonner, is it a case of waiting for Richards to get a third game, or maybe Mirra or Mihocek? I don't see any other options.

Pretty much

Or you could just leave Naughton as your D7/8 as his JS should be pretty good

This is sound advice especially if you do not have Keeffe for DPP with Sicily. JS is sound and although may not be a heavy scorer OK to sit and D8 and use as needed.

Would it be reasonable to consider bringing in Murphy for Naughton this week? (Didn't start him myself, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray, Naughton are D4-8 for me).

Dependent on Murphys JS with Crows injury list.  If you need cash then maybe. I have basically the same players except Murphy for Bonner.

[RaisyDaisy]

If Naughton spuds again, unless trading to Bonner, is it a case of waiting for Richards to get a third game, or maybe Mirra or Mihocek? I don't see any other options.

Pretty much

Or you could just leave Naughton as your D7/8 as his JS should be pretty good

This is sound advice especially if you do not have Keeffe for DPP with Sicily. JS is sound and although may not be a heavy scorer OK to sit and D8 and use as needed.

Would it be reasonable to consider bringing in Murphy for Naughton this week? (Didn't start him myself, Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray, Naughton are D4-8 for me).

You've got solid depth with Murray and Naughton on the pine - not sure getting Murphy is really a priority for you and worth the trade

You use 1 trade to only net 65k, and then use another trade when you cash in on Murphy - might as well just wait for Naugton to go up 50k or so in value and then use 1 trade only

[SilverLion]

Dependent on Murphys JS with Crows injury list.  If you need cash then maybe. I have basically the same players except Murphy for Bonner.

You've got solid depth with Murray and Naughton on the pine - not sure getting Murphy is really a priority for you and worth the trade

You use 1 trade to only net 65k, and then use another trade when you cash in on Murphy - might as well just wait for Naugton to go up 50k or so in value and then use 1 trade only

Cheers guys. yeah think I'll just save the trade. Unless Naughton comes out with another sub 30, then I'll definitely consider.

[Ringo]

Really hoping that Naughton does not spud again as his B/e is 41 following last weeks 25 so if he canot get the 41 this week will see his price fall though. So maybe a trade is worth it rather than have a rookie losing cash sitting on the bench. Just discovered this when starting to do my research on correction trades for next week. So another to throw into my Rd 3/4 trades correction equations.

[_wato]

How close is Mirra to a debut?

[RaisyDaisy]

Not a rookie, and I know he has been mentioned around here before but MacPherson from GC off to a flying start again after putting up 81 last week and having a big JLT

257k forward

[Koop]

Not a rookie, and I know he has been mentioned around here before but MacPherson from GC off to a flying start again after putting up 81 last week and having a big JLT

257k forward

Zac Fisher 6k more expensive, 93 first week and 106 so far today. ;)

[Bully]

Not a rookie, and I know he has been mentioned around here before but MacPherson from GC off to a flying start again after putting up 81 last week and having a big JLT

257k forward

Definitely one to consider.

[kilbluff1985]

Dow is a spud

[GoLions]

How close is Mirra to a debut?

Mirra was probably bog for the hawks today in their loss to the tigs

[Mongoose528]

Murray’s going to ruin our scores.

[Torpedo10]

Murray’s going to ruin our scores.

He's having an absolute howler. Hoping he can scrape 50 somehow.