2018 rookies

[Gavdroid]

One day I’ll start doedee on field

Same. With Keeffe in my team and Adelaide's games early in the round I have put the E on him. Totally unnecessary.

What's everyone's thoughts of me trading Naughton to keefe?

Im a little bit chuffed that I started keeffe, paid for himself already with two loops, but I probs wouldn’t burn a trade

Yep I started Keeffe too - was a no brainer for anyone starting Sicily. DPP and looping already :)

I took him out for Murphy when I saw he wasn't playing. Didn't want to start off with 2 non scoring players on the bench.

[Ricochet]

One day I’ll start doedee on field

Same. With Keeffe in my team and Adelaide's games early in the round I have put the E on him. Totally unnecessary.

What's everyone's thoughts of me trading Naughton to keefe?

Im a little bit chuffed that I started keeffe, paid for himself already with two loops, but I probs wouldn’t burn a trade

Yep I started Keeffe too - was a no brainer for anyone starting Sicily. DPP and looping already :)

So you have 2 non playing rookies?

[GoLions]

One day I’ll start doedee on field

Same. With Keeffe in my team and Adelaide's games early in the round I have put the E on him. Totally unnecessary.

What's everyone's thoughts of me trading Naughton to keefe?

Im a little bit chuffed that I started keeffe, paid for himself already with two loops, but I probs wouldn’t burn a trade

Yep I started Keeffe too - was a no brainer for anyone starting Sicily. DPP and looping already :)

So you have 2 non playing rookies?

And a non playing potato

[TomK]

I reckon Murphy has done enough to hold his spot a while longer, even with some returning Adelaide players. Injuries might mean he would play anyway.

Doedee killed it, looking like he should make some fast cash 8)

Yeah, Murphy won't be getting dropped anytime soon.

I have the other 2 crows rookies and don't have Fogerty but loved the way he played and attacked the ball up forward. I'd be surprised if Adelaide drop him either.

Not sure how we're gonna fit Fog in when Lynch is back but we are gonna have to, what a gun, very happy to be proven wrong by him.

[Bully]

I reckon Murphy has done enough to hold his spot a while longer, even with some returning Adelaide players. Injuries might mean he would play anyway.

Doedee killed it, looking like he should make some fast cash 8)

Yeah, Murphy won't be getting dropped anytime soon.

I have the other 2 crows rookies and don't have Fogerty but loved the way he played and attacked the ball up forward. I'd be surprised if Adelaide drop him either.

Not sure how we're gonna fit Fog in when Lynch is back but we are gonna have to, what a gun, very happy to be proven wrong by him.

Nice work with your Murphy advice, much appreciated!

[Mat0369]

Yeah, Murphy won't be getting dropped anytime soon.

Had a nice little purple patch in the game where he kicked 2 goals pretty quickly. He did enough and with a couple more guys getting injured it would be hard to see him losing his spot.

[RaisyDaisy]

One day I’ll start doedee on field

Same. With Keeffe in my team and Adelaide's games early in the round I have put the E on him. Totally unnecessary.

What's everyone's thoughts of me trading Naughton to keefe?

Im a little bit chuffed that I started keeffe, paid for himself already with two loops, but I probs wouldn’t burn a trade

Yep I started Keeffe too - was a no brainer for anyone starting Sicily. DPP and looping already :)

So you have 2 non playing rookies?

Yep, Olango and Keeffe

The points I will gain by being able to use Keeffe to loop a defender or forward every week, plus swing Sicily back and forth outweigh'd the poor cash generation by picking Waterman/Ryan/Langdon IMO, which was my dilemma

[Ricochet]

One day I’ll start doedee on field

Same. With Keeffe in my team and Adelaide's games early in the round I have put the E on him. Totally unnecessary.

What's everyone's thoughts of me trading Naughton to keefe?

Im a little bit chuffed that I started keeffe, paid for himself already with two loops, but I probs wouldn’t burn a trade

Yep I started Keeffe too - was a no brainer for anyone starting Sicily. DPP and looping already :)

So you have 2 non playing rookies?

Yep, Olango and Keeffe

The points I will gain by being able to use Keeffe to loop a defender or forward every week, plus swing Sicily back and forth outweigh'd the poor cash generation by picking Waterman/Ryan/Langdon IMO, which was my dilemma

Risky. Especially when Venables, Banfield, Barry, Naughton, Murphy could be either slow burns or have limited JS.

[RaisyDaisy]

One day I’ll start doedee on field

Same. With Keeffe in my team and Adelaide's games early in the round I have put the E on him. Totally unnecessary.

What's everyone's thoughts of me trading Naughton to keefe?

Im a little bit chuffed that I started keeffe, paid for himself already with two loops, but I probs wouldn’t burn a trade

Yep I started Keeffe too - was a no brainer for anyone starting Sicily. DPP and looping already :)

So you have 2 non playing rookies?

Yep, Olango and Keeffe

The points I will gain by being able to use Keeffe to loop a defender or forward every week, plus swing Sicily back and forth outweigh'd the poor cash generation by picking Waterman/Ryan/Langdon IMO, which was my dilemma

Risky. Especially when Venables, Banfield, Barry, Naughton, Murphy could be either slow burns or have limited JS.

Even if they are slow burns or get dropped it doesnt change the fact that the only alternatives to Keeffe were scrubs either way, so by picking Keeffe I certainly haven't missed out on a good rookie

In hindsight I would have picked a DPP ruck instead of Olango, but I'm very happy I started Keeffe over the junk alternatives as it's already paid off - fielded Doedee last night and put the E on Murphy which I can now bank due to Keeffe

[Ricochet]

One day I’ll start doedee on field

Same. With Keeffe in my team and Adelaide's games early in the round I have put the E on him. Totally unnecessary.

What's everyone's thoughts of me trading Naughton to keefe?

Im a little bit chuffed that I started keeffe, paid for himself already with two loops, but I probs wouldn’t burn a trade

Yep I started Keeffe too - was a no brainer for anyone starting Sicily. DPP and looping already :)

So you have 2 non playing rookies?

Yep, Olango and Keeffe

The points I will gain by being able to use Keeffe to loop a defender or forward every week, plus swing Sicily back and forth outweigh'd the poor cash generation by picking Waterman/Ryan/Langdon IMO, which was my dilemma

Risky. Especially when Venables, Banfield, Barry, Naughton, Murphy could be either slow burns or have limited JS.

Even if they are slow burns or get dropped it doesnt change the fact that the only alternatives to Keeffe were scrubs either way, so by picking Keeffe I certainly haven't missed out on a good rookie

In hindsight I would have picked a DPP ruck instead of Olango, but I'm very happy I started Keeffe over the junk alternatives as it's already paid off - fielded Doedee last night and put the E on Murphy which I can now bank due to Keeffe

Yeh English is the one that comes to mind that you've missed. But you can do a rookie correction with Olango

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah English and L.Fogarty are the two I'm eyeing, and Ill probably trade Bell to English which will give me cash for Dusty and Bonner next week so Bell being dropped could actually be a blessing in surprise

[petefisker]

Is it ridiculous to be thinking of trading L.Ryan to English up fwd and keeping the Lavender loopwhole?
FWD line is Green, Billings, Mclean, D.Smith, Dunkley, Fritsch | Ryan, Garlett.
Ryan did "ok" at home and only managed 35. English will bring a lot more $$ but worried about his JS.

[Samsturmfels]

Is it ridiculous to be thinking of trading L.Ryan to English up fwd and keeping the Lavender loopwhole?
FWD line is Green, Billings, Mclean, D.Smith, Dunkley, Fritsch | Ryan, Garlett.
Ryan did "ok" at home and only managed 35. English will bring a lot more $$ but worried about his JS.

if english scores well again this week and ryan scores roughly the same id 100% do that trade.

what do yous think of trading naughton to o'shea. even though i am keen to get doedees emergency score, with naughton named id love to trade him so i dont cop a possibly a 25. I was at once thinking of trading in keefe (to get doedees score) but thats to risky considering the depth GWS have, and he might not get a game anytime soon

[GoLions]

Mirra was probably bog for the hawks today in their loss to the tigs

[ubeaut]

If Naughton spuds again, unless trading to Bonner, is it a case of waiting for Richards to get a third game, or maybe Mirra or Mihocek? I don't see any other options.