2018 rookies

[Ringo]

Not sure where he stands at Freo but Crowden has looked impressive in JLT.

Crowden hasn't played a JLT game?

My apologies he is playing today but good reports coming out on him.

[fanTCfool]

Not sure where he stands at Freo but Crowden has looked impressive in JLT.

Crowden hasn't played a JLT game?

My apologies he is playing today but good reports coming out on him.

Could definitely do with another rookie forward, so here's hoping he tears it up. Banfield and Brayshaw too.

[Bully]

Not sure where he stands at Freo but Crowden has looked impressive in JLT.

Crowden hasn't played a JLT game?

My apologies he is playing today but good reports coming out on him.

Could definitely do with another rookie forward, so here's hoping he tears it up. Banfield and Brayshaw too.

Crowden is a true mid as well, won't necessarily play there to start with but could easily get midfield minutes in such a young side. His kicking is also elite, CD will go nuts when they see his laser left foot.

[hawkers65]

Brodie done enough for me that half. Running at 30% DE and has still got 41. Finds the contested ball well

[batt]

Brodie done enough for me that half. Running at 30% DE and has still got 41. Finds the contested ball well

Gonna have a tough time picking two of Brayshaw, Dow and Brodie.  Leaning towards 1 and 3 atm.

[hawkers65]

Brodie done enough for me that half. Running at 30% DE and has still got 41. Finds the contested ball well

Gonna have a tough time picking two of Brayshaw, Dow and Brodie.  Leaning towards 1 and 3 atm.

Easy for me. Brodie easily the #1 for me. Brayshaw wouldnt have to do much today for mine to be picked over Dow. Not a fan

[Ringo]

Not sure how many have seen this press conference from Buckley after the game.

Real concern whether Sam Murray will start rd 1. From the 5 minute mark.  Make your own minds up.

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/video/2018-03-10/buckley-speaks-after-jlt-win

[Bully]

Not sure how many have seen this press conference from Buckley after the game.

Real concern whether Sam Murray will start rd 1. From the 5 minute mark.  Make your own minds up.

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/video/2018-03-10/buckley-speaks-after-jlt-win

In the mix but areas he needs to work on.

[Ricochet]

Not sure where he stands at Freo but Crowden has looked impressive in JLT.

Crowden hasn't played a JLT game?

lol

[zoomba23]

Haven't seen much about him but is anyone considering Geelong's Constable? Averaged 20 disposals in JLT, and got 18 today despite Jelwood and Duncan getting 70 between them, so ball winning ability doesn't look to be a problem. Given that mid rookies are looking a bit thin with Barry and Worpel in doubt for R1, would he be worth a look?

[Ricochet]

Haven't seen much about him but is anyone considering Geelong's Constable? Averaged 20 disposals in JLT, and got 18 today despite Jelwood and Duncan getting 70 between them, so ball winning ability doesn't look to be a problem. Given that mid rookies are looking a bit thin with Barry and Worpel in doubt for R1, would he be worth a look?

GAJ, Menegola and Danger (basically) to come back to that midfield group from today. So have to take that into consideration

[RaisyDaisy]

Haven't seen much about him but is anyone considering Geelong's Constable? Averaged 20 disposals in JLT, and got 18 today despite Jelwood and Duncan getting 70 between them, so ball winning ability doesn't look to be a problem. Given that mid rookies are looking a bit thin with Barry and Worpel in doubt for R1, would he be worth a look?

GAJ, Menegola and Danger (basically) to come back to that midfield group from today. So have to take that into consideration

Worthy of one of the mid bench spots I think, if he gets named of course

Seems like Geelong might have a few rookies choices for us this year

[Bully]

Haven't seen much about him but is anyone considering Geelong's Constable? Averaged 20 disposals in JLT, and got 18 today despite Jelwood and Duncan getting 70 between them, so ball winning ability doesn't look to be a problem. Given that mid rookies are looking a bit thin with Barry and Worpel in doubt for R1, would he be worth a look?

Not AFL ready, even if he gets a game round 1 he will be the first dropped.

[hawkers65]

Brayshaw looking very good as well. May be the best high priced rookie mid pick

[Ricochet]

JJK just said he's looking at round 3, might give Waterman a few games to try and cement a spot